calling TuesdayD

☺♫ Saranghae Review Shop ♫☺ [CLOSED-DO NOT REQUEST]
 
a. Title (4/5) - It doesn't sound catchy to me and I wouldn't really click on it if I saw it in the Random stories. However, I also find your title really cute (when I clicked it, I realized it's cute) . Yes, it's cute 'Neighbourhood Idiots'. It sounds fun to read.


b. Poster & Background & Trailer (8/10) - The poster is very simple but I love the color and the picture choices although it looks more like a character chart style. It's cute, simple and plain, that's all. No background or Trailer, it's okay, it's not required. LOL xD

c. Description & Foreword (6/10) - I like your description. I was pondering who was saying that and that, LOL xD It sounds interesting but from the very first I read your description, I just thought it's really cliche. It's another Best friend thing love or whatever they call that.

Your foreword is nice. There were some grammatical errors and punctuation mistakes.

Ex:

Only Lee Minho were my only true friend!

-Be aware that Lee Minho is only one person which means, singular not plural. You can't use 'were' and you can't use 'was' either. You should use 'is'. So, it's like this: "Only Lee Minho is my only true friend!" No need to put another only because there is already 'only' in the first sentence.

 

Jiyong make a confused face and went away from the table.

-Jiyong made a confused face and went away from the table. (Did you notice that you used past tenses excpet 'make'? It should be 'made' to make it fit with the past tense words.)

 

The word 'fastly' had died long ago, so no need to use fastly. It is not grammatically correct in English  Language.

- Instead of using fastly, just use "Hyerin replied fast" or "Hyerin hastily replied"  or "Hyerin quickly replied"

 

He start to complain as he went towards the door, probably went to the nurse office to sleep. This college is his father share anyway.

- He started to complain as he went towards the door, he probably went to the nurse office to sleep. This college (school?) is his father's share anyway.

 

There was a few more but I can only show you these mistakes. Just in case, you need them.



d. Plot (5/10) - It wasn't that boring, it was fun to read especially the dreaming and drooling part yet it only had one chapter (including the one in the foreword). I'm not so sure about your story's plotline since you only have one chapter, but I guess I understand a little. Hyerin's best friend... the one who likes her... It could be Jiyong or somebody else, but if it's Jiyong it's not really obvious so it's a good thing that it's not obvious.

Your plot is not really catchy. When I read the description, I thought it's just a love story between bestfriends falling in love and thinking if it would work out or not so that's why I wasn't attracted to your story. Still, I give you half the score because of the Hyerin's funny parts.

e. Originality (5/10) - I thought it's about just plain neighbors who are idiots. But well, the best friend part and Hyerin forcing Jiyong about that concert thing is the creativity you wrote. It was a good start honestly.

f. Flow (5/5) - You made a very good start and for the next chapter, I am imagining what might happen next. Full marks here because of the good start.

g. Grammar/Punctuation/Spelling/Vocabulary (18/30) - I caught many mistakes here and there. Including the foreword part, also in the chapter. Also, when you write, you should start with this:

"....really?"

-That is so not right. It should just be "Really?" or something like that.

"You know her. She stubborn!"

- You know her. She's stubborn.

Actually, you just have to proofread your story and I think it will be better. As for your vocabulary, it lacked a bit but simple words and sentences and also thought is also a good thing.

I also love the way you described some of the characters in Chapter 1 by the way.


h. Writing Style (7/10) - It was just fine. I love your short description of the characters and their actions, although it's simple and some word are in wrong places.

i. Overall Enjoyment (6/10) - It was fine. I enjoyed it but I got hooked, really. I love the foreword part mostly, it was very funny. It got me laughing for a while. Sometimes, I find Hyerin very annoying and Jiyong too nice.



Total:  64 /100%
reviewed by: sususco123
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
adnamav
we're NOT taking any request! The shop is busy so if you guys can refrain from requesting anymore reviews!!!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
nyarth
#1
Chapter 159: Wth man its a nice and quite detailied review however its obvious that you were led by your personal feelings for the characters and genre
500sunny500
#2
Out of curiosity, is this review shop on hiatus or completely closed (as in inactive)?
Charybdis #3
Author : Charybdis

Story Title: Skinny

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/273679

Choose your reviewer: Anyone

Thank you very much!
wintress
#4
Author : wintress

Story Title: Reflect the Storm

Story Link: http://bit.ly/1aqF4Vf

Choose your reviewer: Anybody who has time.

Anything else you want us to know? I like cheese. But in all seriousness - I don't think so?
faylieannlee
#5
Author : faylieannlee

Story Title: Oh My Devil!

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/420053

Choose your reviewer: 8symmetrical8

Anything else you want us to know? : None at the moment. :)
RayLCh #6
Author : LostInThought-_-

Story Title: Just Living

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/369626/just-living-chaerin-kryber-yulber-jessber-love

Choose your reviewer: Anybody ^_^

Anything else you want us to know?: New writer and thank you in advance ^_^
-XotichlLovee- #7
Author : MaipaLee

Story Title: Promises

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/321505/promises-etc-infinite-joo-woohyun-you-ilhoon

Choose your reviewer: Anybody. =]

Anything else you want us to know? : Nope not for now. =]
ForeverYourShawol #8
Author : ForeverYourShawol

Story Title: She's Like a Prince

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/340895/she-s-like-a-prince-comedy-fluff-highschool-romance-kai-shortstory-amberfx

Choose your reviewer: mooncake

Anything else you want us to know? I'm just starting off on this fanfic and I what to know if it's doing well so far! ^^ It's a romantic comedy that will have a lot of fluff later on.
deductionmaniac
#9
Author : kim_kyuhyunELF13

Story Title: Insanely Insane

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/203278/insanely-insane-iusinger-jieun-kevin-ukiss-ren

Choose your reviewer: Kakurine039

Anything else you want us to know? uhmm .. thanks in advance ^^
dolittle123
#10
Author : dolitle123

Story Title: The White Princess - How Taemin Changed My Life

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/49339

Choose your reviewer: Anybody

Anything else you want us to know?
Be harsh as you'd like. It would be motivating for me as I really want to finish the story. T_T