calling shootingroses

☺♫ Saranghae Review Shop ♫☺ [CLOSED-DO NOT REQUEST]

 

Goodbye, forever.

 

a. Title (1.5/5)

It's common and it didn't catch my attention. 

b. Poster & Background & Trailer (8/10)

It's a light background and I think anyone who loves sad or drama story would like the poster. It's all perfect for the mood of your story. There is just no title in the poster so I deducted your score.

c. Description & Foreword (8/10)

It was short but it tells what we readers needed to know and it made us wonder about the big things that are about to happen. It's only a description but I love it, such a short foreword with full of wonders. 

d. Plot (8/10)

It's really a sad story and it's not very common but realistic. It can happen in real life or maybe this happened in real life (including Hara and Junhyung). The plot is really interesting for me, it made me cry and I could feel how HyunA felt when Junhyung broke up with her. It's like I was there being dumped. Just some parts are too common, but I love the way you made this story, it's so sad and emotional.

e. Originality (7/10)

I cant say this is really original. Since it's a realistic one, so probably others might have made other stories like this but I haven't seen one yet. 

f. Flow (3/5)

It is good although a few scenes bored me to death! I still like it, everything is so heartbreaking, so exclusive and exciting. Sometimes it's too long and boring so I deducted your points ...

g. Grammar/Punctuation/Spelling/Vocabulary (27/30)

I didn't really see something wrong with yours, but maybe I think a few but I haven't wrote it down to recheck it.  But I saw a few like using words from past tense and then later it was present tense. 

h. Writing Style (10/10)

You described everything well. The heartbreaks, the death... Well, all so descriptive and sounded so real. I like your style.


i. Overall Enjoyment (9/10) -

I enjoyed this so much because it made me cry. It was so real for me and even though I dont know the characters so much, it made me love them by reading your story. Ahhh, so heart warming but sad. 

 

Total Score: 81.5/100%

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
adnamav
we're NOT taking any request! The shop is busy so if you guys can refrain from requesting anymore reviews!!!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
nyarth
#1
Chapter 159: Wth man its a nice and quite detailied review however its obvious that you were led by your personal feelings for the characters and genre
500sunny500
#2
Out of curiosity, is this review shop on hiatus or completely closed (as in inactive)?
Charybdis #3
Author : Charybdis

Story Title: Skinny

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/273679

Choose your reviewer: Anyone

Thank you very much!
wintress
#4
Author : wintress

Story Title: Reflect the Storm

Story Link: http://bit.ly/1aqF4Vf

Choose your reviewer: Anybody who has time.

Anything else you want us to know? I like cheese. But in all seriousness - I don't think so?
faylieannlee
#5
Author : faylieannlee

Story Title: Oh My Devil!

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/420053

Choose your reviewer: 8symmetrical8

Anything else you want us to know? : None at the moment. :)
RayLCh #6
Author : LostInThought-_-

Story Title: Just Living

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/369626/just-living-chaerin-kryber-yulber-jessber-love

Choose your reviewer: Anybody ^_^

Anything else you want us to know?: New writer and thank you in advance ^_^
-XotichlLovee- #7
Author : MaipaLee

Story Title: Promises

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/321505/promises-etc-infinite-joo-woohyun-you-ilhoon

Choose your reviewer: Anybody. =]

Anything else you want us to know? : Nope not for now. =]
ForeverYourShawol #8
Author : ForeverYourShawol

Story Title: She's Like a Prince

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/340895/she-s-like-a-prince-comedy-fluff-highschool-romance-kai-shortstory-amberfx

Choose your reviewer: mooncake

Anything else you want us to know? I'm just starting off on this fanfic and I what to know if it's doing well so far! ^^ It's a romantic comedy that will have a lot of fluff later on.
deductionmaniac
#9
Author : kim_kyuhyunELF13

Story Title: Insanely Insane

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/203278/insanely-insane-iusinger-jieun-kevin-ukiss-ren

Choose your reviewer: Kakurine039

Anything else you want us to know? uhmm .. thanks in advance ^^
dolittle123
#10
Author : dolitle123

Story Title: The White Princess - How Taemin Changed My Life

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/49339

Choose your reviewer: Anybody

Anything else you want us to know?
Be harsh as you'd like. It would be motivating for me as I really want to finish the story. T_T