My love~ you’re beautiful. I’m sorry. by Ticaissoflylikeag6

Monochromatic Pixel's Review Request Shop

 

Reviewer: Sherioka @ http://monochromaticpixel.tumblr.com/

Fanfic link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/31147/


 

`Story Title[did it catch my attention?] :The title could have been simpler and shorter. Let’s see…You’re trying to describe that Junhyung regrets his feelings toward Yuri? Or something like that? Maybe you write down some keywords and mix match the words together to make a new combination. You shouldn’t make a title so long, and in the titles, every word has to be capitalized. Don’t forget to mention, you don’t need punctuation.3/5


`Appearance[what was my first impression? Did it catch my attention?] : There isn’t any poster or background, but I liked how you gave a brief introduction on the characters and you also game some pictures. I like that. 8/10
`Forewords[did your forewords make me wanting to read more?] : Your forewords is more like an introduction of the whole story. You shouldn’t say so much, describe so much, or detail so much. You should make it a bit mysterious, adding adjectives to it. You need to add punctuation too. Your sentences are long and just information. You’ll need more than just details to catch a reader’s interest. It’s like you’re making a movie not writing a story. 6/10


`Plot[was the plot cliche or was it interesting?] : It was interesting, but what was Junghyun regretting? I don’t get it. 13/15


`Characterization[was I able to learn about the characters?] : You described them well and did a good job on putting feelings into their thought and you made their emotions clear and it was funny to read. 9/10


`Creativity/Originality[was it creative?] : So far so good, your story isn’t like others. You made Junghyun make the first move so fast. You’re on a good start; just keep on adding surprises and mysteries to add more spice into the story! 10/10


`Spelling/Grammar/Vocabulary[was I able to understand what you were trying to say?] : Little mistakes here and there, but over all…Nothing big to mention. Just reread and recheck every time you finish writing a chapter, a paragraph or even a sentence! Keep that in mind. 9/10


`Flow[was it too fast or too slow to my liking?] : The chapter flow is steady, but you kind of rushed it at first. It was like; one minute Junghyun wants to go home, while Yuri’s heads over heals for him. Then, Junghyun starts liking Yuri. You didn’t describe that enough and the progress with the story is too fast. But the flow is okay. 7/10


`Writing Style[did your writing style make it easy for me to read?] : You made it clear who’s pov it is, and you did a good job on stating who’s talking. And stating who’s talking the punctuation should be “ instead of ‘ And you should try not making the story like a movie! Every step he/she does what, and then what and then yeah. You describe too much. 11/15


`Overall Enjoyment[did I enjoy this story?] : It was cute, but could have been better. Don’t make the story as an action movie! 4/5

`Total : 80/100

`Bonus : I just love…Love…Jessica. So what if she’s mean? I like the bad people in stories. 5/5


Overall Total: 85/100

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Ladychi #1
Chapter 53: Yamaha ni encuentro está historia, alguien tiene una copia, please
CutieWay #2
I don't know how to explain this, but there is a move in which you move your chest while your fingers are going down. Also the move in which your body is following your body isn't easy for someone who wants to start dancing.
flyingyen
#3
Hey there! Sorry to be leaving a message like this in your comments but Ravenous Temptations are hiring for more staff! We are looking for dedicated graphic designers, reviewers, writers and advertisers! So please help us out because we are overloaded with requests and lack the staff to complete them ^^;;<br />
<br />
http://ravenous-temptations.blogspot.com
ElephantsandCrayons4
#4
Hello I was just wondering if my story was going to be reviewed? I put up a request on the day you said would be the last day of accepting reviews so I don't know if it's valid or not
janie6789
#5
Ahh kay. Thank you for the review and the encouraging words and the great score :D<br />
I really like my poster though!! :P I think the shop I used was fantastic. I didn't want a quote because it seems cheesy to me, and to be honest, book covers never show the story line anyways, so I disagree with you in that respect. I also find backgrounds to be distracting when navigating through the chapters, which is why I don't use one. ;) <br />
I think your comment on the length of it also got me thinking, and I may go through and have a compilation of the "must read" chapters for new readers so they can skip over some of them. Thank you very much again for the review :)
janie6789
#6
@Chp. 51: To be fair, the real Taemin went to normal school until after Ring Ding Dong, if I'm not mistaken. There was a rumour that he was bullied at school, with a series of pictures of him in class. He transferred to an arts school after Ring Dong Dong.
HanaKyu
#7
Omo. Thank you so much! LOL I targeted that I would get a 70.. Hihi. Yeah, I at grammar and describing things! ^^ But I will try my best to fix that! I really appreciated it that you have time to review my story. ^^ And again, thank you! <3
__eccedentesiast_ #8
Just posted up the review
__eccedentesiast_ #9
Thanks for the review I'll put it up when I'm not on my phone