Whisper of my heart by edherei

Monochromatic Pixel's Review Request Shop

Reviewer: aznchika @ http://monochromaticpixel.tumblr.com/

FANFIC LINK: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/36025/


`Story Title[did it catch my attention?] : 3/5

-As a reader, I would say the title does not capture my attention. It sounds cliché, and I’ve heard it numerous of times before.

 

`Appearance[what was my first impression? Did it catch my attention?] : -/10

-I’ve decided to exclude this section since you don’t have a poster or BG yet [:

 

`Forewords[did your forewords make me wanting to read more?] : 8/10

-The forewords were fine. It didn’t particularly interest me, and it also confused me at some point, but it does set the readers up for what they were going to read.

 

`Plot[was the plot cliche or was it interesting?] : 15/15

Full marks! I really like the plot! I’m the kind of person that’s interested in mystery and suspense, and I really love the way you set up the mysterious and dangerous atmosphere! This is definitely not a common plot, and I give you kudos for that! Great job!

 

`Characterization[was I able to learn about the characters?] : 10/10

-From the way you write, I can definitely tell how Jiyong feels throughout the story. It’s no secret that he truly loves his wife and would do anything to find her, even giving up all his wealth. Although, I think it would be more interesting if you can also tell us what Dara was like.

 

`Creativity/Originality[was it creative?] : 10/10

-Very creative and original! Most stories nowadays feature common and cliché parts, but this story has its own unique twist to it! So full marks once again!

 

`Spelling/Grammar/Vocabulary[was I able to understand what you were trying to say?] : 7/10

-Like I stated earlier, your vast vocabulary makes it hard for me to comprehend the story. I’m sorry, but I’m only thirteen and – I may be wrong- there are also people about the same age as me that don’t know the words you know. I think it would help your fanfic if you could loosen your vocab just a little bit. There were no spelling mistakes, however there was a few grammar problems. Here’s an example:

“Best? Is this the best you can show me, huh?! Well these things are all futile!”, Jiyong retorted as he rimpled the papers and hurled them directly to the person who just stayed deeply rooted on his spot.

If someone is talking, then you place the comma inside the quotation marks like this: “ Blah Blah Blah,”

If someone is yelling or asking a question, there shouldn’t be a comma after the quote. There’s both a comma and exclamation mark between the words ‘futile’ and ‘Jiyong’. There should only be one, and it would be best if it was the exclamation mark.

 

`Flow[was it too fast or too slow to my liking?] : 10/10

-I thought the flow was perfectly fine! It didn’t go too fast, but it wasn’t too slow either. Good job!

 

`Writing Style[did your writing style make it easy for me to read?] : 9/15

-I’m sorry to say, but your writing style makes it boring and complicating for me to read. I suggest- this is what I think- that you should loosen up on your vocabulary. Your plot is interesting, but your words take away the mood of the story.

 

`Overall Enjoyment[did I enjoy this story?] : 4/5

-Despite all of the complication and confusion, I really did actually like the story. The fanfic was very interesting, and I just love it whenever a man is truly dedicated to his wife.

 

`Total : 69/90 = 77/100

`Bonus : 1/5

-I’m sorry, but I just love the way Jiyong loves Dara so much!

 

Overall Total: 78/100

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Ladychi #1
Chapter 53: Yamaha ni encuentro está historia, alguien tiene una copia, please
CutieWay #2
I don't know how to explain this, but there is a move in which you move your chest while your fingers are going down. Also the move in which your body is following your body isn't easy for someone who wants to start dancing.
flyingyen
#3
Hey there! Sorry to be leaving a message like this in your comments but Ravenous Temptations are hiring for more staff! We are looking for dedicated graphic designers, reviewers, writers and advertisers! So please help us out because we are overloaded with requests and lack the staff to complete them ^^;;<br />
<br />
http://ravenous-temptations.blogspot.com
ElephantsandCrayons4
#4
Hello I was just wondering if my story was going to be reviewed? I put up a request on the day you said would be the last day of accepting reviews so I don't know if it's valid or not
janie6789
#5
Ahh kay. Thank you for the review and the encouraging words and the great score :D<br />
I really like my poster though!! :P I think the shop I used was fantastic. I didn't want a quote because it seems cheesy to me, and to be honest, book covers never show the story line anyways, so I disagree with you in that respect. I also find backgrounds to be distracting when navigating through the chapters, which is why I don't use one. ;) <br />
I think your comment on the length of it also got me thinking, and I may go through and have a compilation of the "must read" chapters for new readers so they can skip over some of them. Thank you very much again for the review :)
janie6789
#6
@Chp. 51: To be fair, the real Taemin went to normal school until after Ring Ding Dong, if I'm not mistaken. There was a rumour that he was bullied at school, with a series of pictures of him in class. He transferred to an arts school after Ring Dong Dong.
HanaKyu
#7
Omo. Thank you so much! LOL I targeted that I would get a 70.. Hihi. Yeah, I at grammar and describing things! ^^ But I will try my best to fix that! I really appreciated it that you have time to review my story. ^^ And again, thank you! <3
__eccedentesiast_ #8
Just posted up the review
__eccedentesiast_ #9
Thanks for the review I'll put it up when I'm not on my phone