“You Against Pearl, Gold, Money, and Kimchi” By: Warmustard.

|Rainy Day Cafe Review Shop & Blog | St-renaissance| NOT ACCEPTING !!
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

 

 

“You Against Pearl, Gold, Money, and Kimchi”

By: Warmustard.

 

 

Reviewer: St-renaissance.

1-Title: The title is definitely original, sufficient and suspenseful; usually long titles are either for the purpose of literary significant or substantial yet eventual profundity. Several elements are mentioned (Pearl, gold, money and kimchi) so the reader will assume that each different element has a specific representation which will be elucidated throughout the story, they must have meanings. Don’t disappoint.

 

Rating: 10/10.

 

2-Description: The description is overly detailed and can be briefed in order to deliver a more compact structure and an accumulated purpose without boring the readers and exhausting the given space and information. The beginning is well-developed and carries along some useful information however, you can easily shorten the description by removing the second paragraph entirely except for the first two lines, any remaining information in the second paragraph is not important and it’s quite boring. You can connect the first paragraph to the two lines in the second paragraph and the third paragraph. By doing so, your description isn’t as lengthy and boring.

 

Rating: 7/10.

 

3-Plot: The beginning is very rushed and lacks fundamental details such as environmental description, background information and is simply flimsy and lacks planning. Initially, the story must introduce the scenery and the settings before introducing any characters, you can avoid any proper description but your story will appear incomplete and rushed. Try taking things slowly by acquainting the readers with the location and time or era of the story and how does it affect the social aspect of the plot. Is it a cold location? Is it midnight? How does that reflect the people in the story, are they indoors? Are they sociable? Then you can smoothly glide in with the character’s opinion of this aspect thus you have introduced your character without bumps. Ok, you need to do something regarding the beginning; it’s extremely tedious and has no purposeful events or important landmarks. Regarding the speech clearness, don’t use foreign terms too commonly and avoid relying on translation for one character’s dialogue, it’s a huge mistake to have one character speak in a different tongue than your audience and force them to locate a reference mainly to understand the speech of a MAIN CHARACTER. It’s a story, not an encyclopedia.

Can I make a suggestion? Avoid explicit description of the characters love-making and whatnot. You see, in literature there are only two purposes for different degrees of a, you either employ it to stimulate the audience (as done in a) or to illustrate the level of romantic involvement between the couple. Too much of either will produce your work as cliché and aimless. You have got to do something about this slow intro, it cannot possibly take you two whole chapters to talk about how much they adore each other and for how long they can hold each other’s hands. You’ve got to start discussing the main issue at hand and the readers need to be familiarized with the characters’ opinions and thoughts on any main events in spite of not having any landmark moments for two whole chapters.

The third chapter starts off perfectly, the description of varied details regarding the wood material and quality is literary brilliance; it’s those small details of a house or an environment that help construct the settings and location. You should investigate all settings with the same amount of passion and vigilance, it helps create a story behind each place and the story accumulates the significant value of the environmental aspect of the story. The general flow of the story is better and ad developed a suitable speed that’s considerate for the readers’ entertainment. Now that we’re back to the two lovers, the dialogues are basic and lacks any importance and the given situations (if any are found) makes them appear simple-minded and shallow because their psychological and behavioral patterns don’t exist. If you’ve read the rules and whatnot of my shop you’d understand that I’m very frank in order to improve your writing, and here’s what I’ve

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
St-renaissance
Currently NOT accepting!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
BangMind
#1
omg, love your reviews, they are really in-depth and helpful. i wish you'll open in the future so i can request!
Sphinx_
#2
Chapter 81: Hello, thank you so much for taking your time in writing this very thorough review! There is a lot that I can learn from this that would help me improve not only for this particular story but for my writing in general as well. The discussion on the story's setting and how to deliver the characters' situation and thoughts to the reader are pointers that I needed to hear. Thank you for also giving me clear examples of those pointers. I'll read the review over and over, and make sure I improve from this.

I've credited the shop in my foreword already. Again, thank you and take care!
Sphinx_
#3
Hello, I would like to submit a request for a story review. It's my first time requesting one and I am a little nervous but here goes nothing!

-Title of your story/one-shot: Lost n' Found

-Number of chapters: 1 (with around 2690 words)

-Type/theme of your story: Slice of life

-State of your story: I'm contemplating if I should add another chapter, but for now, the story is "completed" as it is.

-Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1477721/lost-n-found
Misskittyrose
#4
Are u accepting request?
vivibop
#5
Chapter 2: 1. Innocence Lost [Sehun]
2. 20 chapters (only 7k words)
3. Angst<3
4. Completed
5. https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1286739

Thank you!!
diamondELF193
#6
Chapter 2: 1-Every Rose Has its Thorn
2- 20 chapters
3-Romantic-Drama; Friends with benefits
4-Completed
5-https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/879665

I’ve done review and writing workshops in college, but this is my first time requesting feedback outside of school. Would love to have another opinion!
parkyume
#7
Chapter 78: i love how you spelled out every detail on where the goods and bads in the story as well as what kind of improvements i can work on. well, especially on the characterization and the plot! and yeah i never thought i didn't do proper character introduction since im too focused on the haha and when you mentioned that i did tend to leave the rest of imaginations to the readers! i'm actually very excited to include more of what's happening in the surrounding of the characters and to show more of their personalities and develop their characterization (this is going to be tough since i think my skills are lacked in this area)

i really appreciate the amount of information written in this thorough, super insightful and honest review on my story! thank you so much for taking the time to read and give me feedback!😍
parkyume
#8
Chapter 2: I’ve read the rules and my story is eligible to request for review!!! 😍😍😍

Title: Thorned Roses Under the Moonlight Shade (by parkyume)
No. of chapters: 9
Theme: , PWP, Joseon AU, Noble x Lowborn, In search of love, Possessive/Abusive Love, -driven plot
State of my story: On-going
Direct link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1427576/thorned-roses-under-the-moonlight-shade

I’d love it if you could help me finding out on how to develop the plot and characterization from here until the end!! You can give me advice and opinions!!! because that’s what I need!! 🤩🥸 Thank you so much!!!
parkyume
#9
HIII!!! I want to request!!! But I’m at work so can I request a slot & submit the official application by today??? 😍😍😍😍😍😍 I’m sorry I hadn’t read the rules yet 😭😭😭
purplerain-
#10
Thank you! I read the whole thing and I took notes on how I can further improve my writing. There's a lot to learn and I'm glad I requested from you. I didn't even know what a Character Cluster is! I would love to talk more about writing with you, but I do not know if you're busy or not. This is just a hobby of mine that I picked up and am trying to hone (A measly med student here). I would be interested in what I could further do to improve (except read books 'cause I do that daily). On another note, my favorite book is called "The Lies of Locke Lamora". What's yours? Agh, I've been rambling. I better stop. Once again, I thank you for your work, and as per the rules, I gave credits in the Foreword.

Happy Holidays!