"Strangers" By: Qyurie.

|Rainy Day Cafe Review Shop & Blog | St-renaissance| NOT ACCEPTING !!
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

 

 

“Strangers”

By: Qyurie.

 

 

Reviewer: Gtoprenaissance.

 

1-Title: The title "Strangers" is suitable, I'd say. Considering your story is one of tragic drama, the noun 'Strangers' indicates the unspoken underlining of the romantic mien of the classical English tragedy (where love is not the main theme, pain is.) I don't think changing it would be necessary.

 

Rating: [10/10].

 

 

2-Description/Foreword: Though the description is there and valid, it doesn't serve your story justice. The description details the characters' relationship as toxic but it claims that one character doesn't value the existence of the other, which impressed upon me (as a reader) that this relationship won't happen in the first place, but it did. It's merely imperfect and abusive. But both characters were acknowledged by each other. I thought it was misleading to a certain extent, but it’s simply an observation, not a fault. The poster is quite lovely and the layout is quite neat and professional. Good job!

 

Rating: [9/10].

 

 

3-Plot: You've used the third-person narrative style which usually accompanies the characters' natural psychological and emotional development through the looking glass of the reader rather than the narrator. The story begins beautifully, you've employed the elements of time (winter) and place (car) and you've allowed your readers to anticipate the next element of action. Your beginning is tricky though, diving into the story without an initial introduction to the characters can be confusing for readers whose idea of either characters is slight and slim. I'm not a fan of either characters, and I assume I'm not the only one whose knowledge of this group is limited, so I suggest either introducing the main characters properly or obtain a strict use of titles/names.

The plot in itself is good, unoriginal, but good. As a reviewer, I’ve reviewed plenty of stories with a similar outline of your plot, whether it’s domestic abuse, psychological maladjustment or self-harm, they all tend to lightly touch on the topic without analyzing the core of problem. I’d say your story did well in analyzing the problem because the characters were built neatly and professionally. You’ve managed to lay out a certain issue and exhibit the proper reaction practiced by each character, I don’t recommend changing a thing about the general plot.

Your use of diction is brilliant in all its forms. Its effectiveness is usually elicited from the proper illustration of everything, from the environment to the characters' thoughts. You can succeed in extracting a catharsis from your readers by deploying a purposeful contrast between heart and mind; usually in post-modern literature, the contrast is between a developing theory and society. For example, The Help by Kathryn Stockett discusses racial discrimination. Your character's struggle to leave his lover is an adequate example, but it's not competent enough to carry an entire plot by itself. I recommend supplying your story with a sub-plot, perhaps one lead by minor characters.

Speaking of the aspect of dictionary correctness, I'd say your choice of words is suitable for a story with such ambience. As for the clearness of speech, I'm glad you've refrained from using commonly exhausted foreign vocabularies such as "Oppa" and whatever other authors tend to use in stories.

As for using Surrealism in your plot and contradicting the ordinary, I’d say it’s a riske move to mix tragedy and Surrealism but since it has worked so well in your story makes i

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
St-renaissance
Currently NOT accepting!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
BangMind
#1
omg, love your reviews, they are really in-depth and helpful. i wish you'll open in the future so i can request!
Sphinx_
#2
Chapter 81: Hello, thank you so much for taking your time in writing this very thorough review! There is a lot that I can learn from this that would help me improve not only for this particular story but for my writing in general as well. The discussion on the story's setting and how to deliver the characters' situation and thoughts to the reader are pointers that I needed to hear. Thank you for also giving me clear examples of those pointers. I'll read the review over and over, and make sure I improve from this.

I've credited the shop in my foreword already. Again, thank you and take care!
Sphinx_
#3
Hello, I would like to submit a request for a story review. It's my first time requesting one and I am a little nervous but here goes nothing!

-Title of your story/one-shot: Lost n' Found

-Number of chapters: 1 (with around 2690 words)

-Type/theme of your story: Slice of life

-State of your story: I'm contemplating if I should add another chapter, but for now, the story is "completed" as it is.

-Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1477721/lost-n-found
Misskittyrose
#4
Are u accepting request?
vivibop
#5
Chapter 2: 1. Innocence Lost [Sehun]
2. 20 chapters (only 7k words)
3. Angst<3
4. Completed
5. https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1286739

Thank you!!
diamondELF193
#6
Chapter 2: 1-Every Rose Has its Thorn
2- 20 chapters
3-Romantic-Drama; Friends with benefits
4-Completed
5-https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/879665

I’ve done review and writing workshops in college, but this is my first time requesting feedback outside of school. Would love to have another opinion!
parkyume
#7
Chapter 78: i love how you spelled out every detail on where the goods and bads in the story as well as what kind of improvements i can work on. well, especially on the characterization and the plot! and yeah i never thought i didn't do proper character introduction since im too focused on the haha and when you mentioned that i did tend to leave the rest of imaginations to the readers! i'm actually very excited to include more of what's happening in the surrounding of the characters and to show more of their personalities and develop their characterization (this is going to be tough since i think my skills are lacked in this area)

i really appreciate the amount of information written in this thorough, super insightful and honest review on my story! thank you so much for taking the time to read and give me feedback!😍
parkyume
#8
Chapter 2: I’ve read the rules and my story is eligible to request for review!!! 😍😍😍

Title: Thorned Roses Under the Moonlight Shade (by parkyume)
No. of chapters: 9
Theme: , PWP, Joseon AU, Noble x Lowborn, In search of love, Possessive/Abusive Love, -driven plot
State of my story: On-going
Direct link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1427576/thorned-roses-under-the-moonlight-shade

I’d love it if you could help me finding out on how to develop the plot and characterization from here until the end!! You can give me advice and opinions!!! because that’s what I need!! 🤩🥸 Thank you so much!!!
parkyume
#9
HIII!!! I want to request!!! But I’m at work so can I request a slot & submit the official application by today??? 😍😍😍😍😍😍 I’m sorry I hadn’t read the rules yet 😭😭😭
purplerain-
#10
Thank you! I read the whole thing and I took notes on how I can further improve my writing. There's a lot to learn and I'm glad I requested from you. I didn't even know what a Character Cluster is! I would love to talk more about writing with you, but I do not know if you're busy or not. This is just a hobby of mine that I picked up and am trying to hone (A measly med student here). I would be interested in what I could further do to improve (except read books 'cause I do that daily). On another note, my favorite book is called "The Lies of Locke Lamora". What's yours? Agh, I've been rambling. I better stop. Once again, I thank you for your work, and as per the rules, I gave credits in the Foreword.

Happy Holidays!