If Only... - phantom_knight (Reviewer: jokerkkhe22)

** Starlight Review Shop ** [CLOSED]

 

 

 

Story: If Only... (Revised) 

Author: phamtom_knight

 

 

Title 5/5

If Only...

A not very seen title. It certainly fits well with the story as it expresses about someone's regret.

Appearance 4/5

Did you make the poster yourself? It expresses the regret feeling well but it lacks in the two best friends feel.

Description and Foreword 5/10

"A typical love story... A friend falling in love with her best friend"

Why did you divulge the plot for the readers? When readers read that, it will have a get bored effect and readers might choose not  to read your fanfic. Please do take note of that. Foreword is okay.

The English 28/35

You've kind of mixed present tense and past tense together.

Here is one of example:

-Yunho lend me his hand and helped me stand up -> The stand should be stood because you wrote lend and helped in the past tense and the other verb should be also in past tense.

-As my stubborn self, rested on the ground -> there is not a need of coma there.

I suggest you to write on Ms. Word first or get a beta reader if you haven't to prevent these kinds of mistakes.

Plot 13/20

Very very common plot. The only thing is, you've made it real. I really enjoyed it when I am reading, it is like I really am experiencing it.

Arrangement 30/30

Arranged it well.

Originality 7/10

Plot is very common. You twisted it very realistic, it was expressed great.

Viewer's comment 4/5

I discovered there is one who think that the story is old, deducted a point. Most readers liked it and they commented professionally, less fanfics are seen to be commented like that. Good.

Overall 96/120

 

Reviewer's note: You left the ending hanging. Are you making a sequel? Please do. I am sorry if some of my words hurt you and the review took so long but all of I said are pure honesty, thank you for choosing me to review your fanfic. Hope this helped. 

An author has to influence his/her readers to grasp the emotions of the characters portrayed

         -jokerkkhe22

 



 

Thanks for requesting. Please comment below after picking it up and don't forget to credit :)

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
grldrgn
#1
Chapter 5: Is the story about cl and onew wgm removed? Omg so sad :'(
Pabolicious #2
applied as a reviewer :)))
glowbug #3
applied as a reviewer!
salvatore
#4
applied as a reviewer :)
littlelu
#5
Chapter 101: My review?
pandaeyesxxi
#6
Chapter 109: Thanks for the review!!~
Eyagibba
#7
Chapter 3: thanks for review
h3d1ez
#8
Hi, i would like to help making your shop layouts texts etc
my shop:
Graphic pro - store:
Gives you the best requested layouts to your stories you can get: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/281348/graphic-pro-open-graphic-shop-design-layout-posterrequest
Fake_D
#9
Chapter 104: Thank you so much for the review. Actually 'As Blood Runs Black' is actually a short fic for a contest I joined. I had to rush things up because they set a limit to the chapters in the rules and unfortunately it had to be under 7 chapters(if im not mistaken). So I had no chance to explain what not and what happened to JongUp. I admit it that it was too rushy towards the end because I didn't realize I made the first few chapters too slow. I was thinking of a spin-off for this short story so that I could explain on what happened to JongUp back then that had turned him that way. Anyhow, thank you for the review, I appreciate it. ^^
littlelu
#10
Requested