Calling... Minlovesmin

♨ Kimchi Dumplings Review Shop ♨ || Closed Hiatus ||

 

Title[4/5]: It wasn't eyecatching but it did fit your story.

 

Poster(s)[2/5]: Your poster was plain. But it was kind of cute. I'd suggest either getting a new poster from a shop or adding more emotional colors to it.

 

Description & Foreword [4/10]: Your description doesn't tell me anything about your story except when it started. The spaces in your foreword..... good grief. I had to scroll down so much to read 5 lines. It would be way better to just make everything into one or two paragraphs. But each lines of your foreword was very interesting. But honestly your description and the format of your foreword turn me off from the story.

 

Plot and Characters[21/30]: Your plot mixed perfectly with your characters. Your chapters and characters were okay, not the best they could have been. Having an 18 year old girl with cancer in your story makes it much more interesting than some perfect Mary-Sue who is loved by everyone. G-Dragon, well anyone in the K-Pop industry period, being thug-like is something seen too often from AFF authors. Your story may come off as a cliche from many people, because it slightly is. But your twist to the idea is one of the best I've seen, and boy have I seen alot.

 

Grammar/Spelling/Punctuation/Word Chose[18/25]: The format of your chapters doesn't please me. From every fanfic, story, book, etc. I expect decent chapters. That it's the case with AFF authors also. It would be better to make actual chapters from what you have written. Your chapters are perfectly fine except for their formatting. I suggest going back to read each and every one of your chapters,  just to be safe. Your grammar, spelling, punctuation, and word chose can be improved slightly, but it was acceptable.

 

Flow[9/10]: Your flow was alright.

 

Overall Enjoyment[4/15]: Honestly and truthful, I really didn't like your story, the idea of thug X cancer patient isn't my cup of tea. Don't let my review discourage you! Just look at how many comments and suscribers you have! That means they love your story.

 

Grade: 62% 

I think I was alittle too harsh here.... Oops! And I reviewed it alittle too late. Reviewed By: cottonSHINeecandy

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
cottonSHINeecandy
SmileFlyy-- has deactivated without informating me, sorry if you requested from her. Please request again from someone else.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Miss-Kpop
#1
In_Disguise #2
Chapter 2: Is there by any chance , *cough cough* my review will be finished after a year? XD just wondering, I'm just wondering why a sudden stop of updating?
Chullys
#3
Ummmm this is random but you spelt "subscribe" wrong on your foreword? Perhaps this was done on purpose? O_O
In_Disguise #4
Chapter 1: Hi~! Can I um.. Pass my request to Imyeoniyeomni? Please do (^-^) thank you.
psyche_delic
#5
Excuse me, I just accidentally sent up my form, I was actually planned to send it on other day .__. I'm sorry
UwinLe #6
This is kind of awkward and it might seem like I'm a stalker, but I somewhat really enjoy reading your reviews on people fics. :)
Imlucifer
#7
Chapter 2: So sorry for this, but would tell AyoWhatUpKrease I would like to cancel my request.
Can I have a different reviewer instead. Any one will do but my request will go out to cottonSHINEEcandy or vnxazn. Please tell her I'm really sorry for the switch and she is still happy enough to be subscribed to my story :)
d-tsuga
#8
I added you as affies ^^
Please link back ^^
Thanks!

https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/261617
KatyMikayla
#9
Chapter 68: Hqhahha i had their ages in the forewod but people kept telling me to delete the character charts. I'll just add it in the fist chapter then :) thank you so much for the wonderful rview!!
Promi53ToB3li3v3 #10
Cool shop!:)