On The SWINGS of Love

The Sleepless Phoenix Review & Consulting Shop [CLOSED]


Author: MicTest

Story title: On The SWINGS of Love

Story type: Chaptered

Reviewer: vronvron

Review completion: 2/4/2016

Story Link

Overall Story rating: 8/10 


Title: [9/10]

The title definitely suits the genre of your story as it has a bit of cheesiness and also has the metaphorical aspect to it as well. Not much to say here other than that. Hoever, it is a bit cliche.

Foreword/Description: [10/10]

Your description is short and sweet. It tells us the main plot of the story, yet it keeps many things hidden, which makes the reader want to continue following on to find out what will happen to the couple.

Plot/ character development:[8/10]

I feel as though the story was a bit rushed towards the start, although I don't know how long you're planning to make this story. The introduction of Yonghwa was a bit fast and I feel that you could have moved the flashback to an earlier part of the chapter since it caused a bit of confusion as to what had happened for Seohyun and Yonghwa to meet. Since its only the beginnings of the story, the development of the characters seems to be doing better.

Characterization: [7/10]

The characters are somewhat cliche in the sense that you have the different types of friends in the group. The shy girl and the bad boy is also a bit cliche.

Grammar/Syntax:[6/10]

Most of your sentences seem rather short and there isn't a great variety of length between them. This can sometimes bore readers since the mind needs to be stimulated a bit more, with a range of short and long sentences. Your grammar is good, however, there were a few small changes of word choice that I could see that needed to be made. They were only minor though and wouldn't cause too much of an issue.

Your descriptions could be a little less direct I feel. More showing rather than telling. For example:

Her hair was in pigtails, and she was wearing nerdy glasses.

This could be better read as:

She had tied her hair up into pigtails and had put on her glasses - which some people may have seen as rather nerdy.

 

Vocabulary: [8/10]

Your choice of vocabulary is very simple but also much more colloquial. It gives a more familiar vibe, however, I think that perhaps if you used some more sohpisticated vocab, it could turn out better. However, even though I do say that, the simple language does suit the lighthearted story.

Setting/Description: [8/10]

The setting was a little confusing for me at first. When reading the first chapter, it almost seemed like Seohyun was getting ready for high school rather than university. I feel like you could probably put in a bit more effort to add more to the descriptions about the settings/places where the characters are at since it can get a bit confusing at times.

/Conclusion:[10/10]

As the story isn't complete yet, I'll just go off what I read and it seems like the story will end pretty well since it is a romcom.

Enjoyment:[9/10]

Overall, I enjoyed it quite a bit, however I did notice that it felt like I had either read a story ot seen a drama with a similar concept of a shy girl being forced to be with a bad boy even though she has a crush.

Total: 75/90


Thank you for using our services, I hope you are satisfied with your review and I'm sorry that some parts may be a bit short or if I seemed a tad harsh. However, I do hope that it assists you in some way. Don't forget to credit our shop in your story and comment below.

Good luck with the rest of your story ^^


 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
Tychee
++sujuELFsarang your review will be ready by tomorrow i'm sorry for the late review ++

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
TurbulenceTenshi #1
Chapter 46: Oh, hey, "Want and Resent"'s back up... if anyone's interested! Thanks either way :)
sujuELFsarang
#2
Chapter 45: Finally! I was actually waiting after the day you announced that it will be posted. Anyway, I'm happy for your review.

I know it is something not all people will waste time reading. It's cliche. Over used plot. Nothing really special just some typical drama. XD. No one would actually repeat reading stories that is already predictable. What am I saying? Lol. I am not really aiming for readers when I first wrote this. This is actually a gift for a friend because she really really love Baekhyun and she was the one who told me to post it here and ask for a review. But, when people started noticing it, I was like "I have to at least tell them what happened after. They deserve it" and yes, I know I will give them a sequel that is not really something to go back XD Lol.

Regarding the title, I would really really like to change it but my friend already read this and she doesn't want me to change what was done. She's kind of childish and selfish C:

Thank you for correcting my errors. I know there are lots of it and I do need someone who can point it out for me because I can't do it for myself. (disadvantage of not having English as the mother language) Thank you and sorry I wasn't able to meet your satisfaction :( .

Thank you Tychee! C: Gonna credit after this.
shadowjjong #3
Chapter 43: I have read my review and will credit as soon as possible, I am a bit under studying pressure, so it may take a while. Thank you very much again.
redocean-
#4
(c) for the side story of this oneshot (it's going to focus more on the past of Kai and Krystal), because I feel like I was too focused on trying to make this unbreakable bond between the two of them that I forgot to explain more about their past. So, there will be answers to your questions on the side story, I'll probably request a review for it once I posted it!

Whoa, I didn't realise I made that typo. I'll fix it right away, thank you so much!

Once again, thank you so much for reviewing and reading this story. I'm very honoured that you like it overall, I'm really glad that you had a good read and the time I spent brainstorming the plot and characterisation didn't go to waste. I will certainly comeback to this shop to get another review from you. I've also credited your shop in my foreword and upvoted this thread. Thank you so much, have a nice day <3