Curtain Call of Our Flowers

The Sleepless Phoenix Review & Consulting Shop [CLOSED]

cover_photo_by_einoirmousse16-d9ha55n.jp



Author:Taenyz
Story Title: Curtain Call of our Flowers
Story Type: One Shot
Reviewer: toxicxiukiss
Overall Rating: 
Story Link:
Click Here


Title: 10/10    

I'm was quite impressed with the title, it for sure is a unique one and deserves a few points in originality. The theme is really common so normally I'd run away, however, it was the title that drew me in. It's for sure unique. Actually first looking at it I was hoping for a longer story, the length to me didn't feel like a one-shot type of story. I don't think it gives much away, I mean with the way you've written it the title has put the sort of feel into it

Foreword/Description:  9.5/10

For a one-shot it doesn't give too much away, you added just right information. Could maybe be a bit smaller, in the size of information. I mean it's good however for a one-shot normally its just one liner or two liners. That way it will drag and draw the reader in more and more. Being a non-yuri reader, it was enough to actually to get me reading it. 

Plot: 8/10

Ok, I was a little worried since the theme is so common. However the plot, wow! It's really good. I can tell by reading the story that you've spent a while writing it, so it's perfect. I've read it a few times, I notice that the start of the story you've written it a little fast/ I think you may have relaxed a little more within the middle of the work. I'd like to see more work from you, I mean it's a good pace for one shot. I mean maybe you have better pace for chaptered stories?

Characterization: 10/10

As for this part, I notice that you had written out quite a few characters. I was worried. However when reading your story, I was happy to see that you didn't leave any out. Or forget about any of the characters, you even gave us a bit of information of Sooyeon's character which surprised me when I read it. Overall the actual relationship of taeny was a good one. I don't normally read Yuri stories so it strange for me to like the characters. However they were all written so well and I couldn't help but like the story. You wrote it like a real story so it made it feel more realistic. 

Grammar/Syntax: 10/10

Only a few grammatical errors, nothing to lose any sleep about. Trust me it won't affect the readers enjoyment, anyway, it didn't affect mine.

Vocabulary: 10/10

I loved the words you wrote, I could tell by reading the story that you're an experienced author. It actually made the story feel more realistic. Great job in that area! 

Setting/Description: 10/10

After reading the story, I must say you didn't lose focus or go off track. It all followed the through to the end perfectly. As description go, for 2016 best yuri I've seen so far. In terms of plot and layout.

/Conclusion: 9/10

Didn't really leave me with much of the feel. However, at the end of the story, I was hoping for more. I really wanted to see more of the story. 

Overall Enjoyment: 9/10

However as the final statement,  I did enjoy the read. I mean for someone who doesn't normally go for Yuri, I might see more of your stories. It was a really nice and enjoyable read. 

Total: 86.5/90


Thank you for using our services, I hope you are satisfied with your review and i'm sorry that it may be too long or if  I seem harsh. To my demise i'm too critical and I talk too much.Don't forget to credit our shop in your story and comment below.


 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
Tychee
++sujuELFsarang your review will be ready by tomorrow i'm sorry for the late review ++

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
TurbulenceTenshi #1
Chapter 46: Oh, hey, "Want and Resent"'s back up... if anyone's interested! Thanks either way :)
sujuELFsarang
#2
Chapter 45: Finally! I was actually waiting after the day you announced that it will be posted. Anyway, I'm happy for your review.

I know it is something not all people will waste time reading. It's cliche. Over used plot. Nothing really special just some typical drama. XD. No one would actually repeat reading stories that is already predictable. What am I saying? Lol. I am not really aiming for readers when I first wrote this. This is actually a gift for a friend because she really really love Baekhyun and she was the one who told me to post it here and ask for a review. But, when people started noticing it, I was like "I have to at least tell them what happened after. They deserve it" and yes, I know I will give them a sequel that is not really something to go back XD Lol.

Regarding the title, I would really really like to change it but my friend already read this and she doesn't want me to change what was done. She's kind of childish and selfish C:

Thank you for correcting my errors. I know there are lots of it and I do need someone who can point it out for me because I can't do it for myself. (disadvantage of not having English as the mother language) Thank you and sorry I wasn't able to meet your satisfaction :( .

Thank you Tychee! C: Gonna credit after this.
shadowjjong #3
Chapter 43: I have read my review and will credit as soon as possible, I am a bit under studying pressure, so it may take a while. Thank you very much again.
redocean-
#4
(c) for the side story of this oneshot (it's going to focus more on the past of Kai and Krystal), because I feel like I was too focused on trying to make this unbreakable bond between the two of them that I forgot to explain more about their past. So, there will be answers to your questions on the side story, I'll probably request a review for it once I posted it!

Whoa, I didn't realise I made that typo. I'll fix it right away, thank you so much!

Once again, thank you so much for reviewing and reading this story. I'm very honoured that you like it overall, I'm really glad that you had a good read and the time I spent brainstorming the plot and characterisation didn't go to waste. I will certainly comeback to this shop to get another review from you. I've also credited your shop in my foreword and upvoted this thread. Thank you so much, have a nice day <3