Button

ROS'E Review Shop [Closed]
ROS'E REVIEW SHOP
| Button |
o6eF0OA.png
vimij9Z.png
REVIEWER: jawl0820


 
Xckfi7A.png
☓ REVIEW PICKUP

Story Title: 5/5

Your title is unique, and it shows contrast between Sehun and Giyeon.

Graphics: 10/10

While the poster doesn't hint romance or school life, it's cool and creepy, and once again, showing contrast between Sehun and Giyeon.

Description/Foreword: 10/10

You had me at 'that girl,' and the prologue really helped the reader get a grasp on the plot. It was detailed, and you took a common topic and make special with your twist.

Plot: 28/30

You had some minor grammar mistakes, but they were really small. The plot was intricate and well-paced. Your repetitive 18 years described how gray and empty Giyeon was, and it was sweet how colorful Sehun was in her life. The way they started opening up to each other was slow, but understandable. Lastly, it's interesting how Giyeon has two sides in her life: Sehun and her friends. The two relationships are completely different, yet they cross and overlap.


Characterization: 14/15

With the girl being so predictable and Sehun mysterious, this difference between the two characters creates room for their personalities to be flexible because of each other. You should have the two change and develop over the course of their relationship, and thus, allows the reader to feel the connection and chemistry between them.

Writing Style and Grammar: 9/10

Again, minor grammar mistakes. You wrote with detailed and complex sentences, which helped the reader feel as though the story was more than just a story. The dialogue also played a big part in moving the story forward, so keep it up.

Personal Enjoyment: 8/10

Feels!!! XD Your story was very enjoyable, especially since I felt that the characters were feeling raw emotion.

Total: 94/100 


COMMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS: You did a great job, and this surpassed my initial expectations. Fighting! OwO
REVIEWED ON: 29/3/15

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
e2aee5b02dfdaf93393f
13/5-- bangtangarang, your review is done!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
kalon_sama #1
Frick I forgot to comment after I requested //realizes like a month later
Omg kill me I'm so sorry
Pingdwae
#2
Hello! i'm back again and i've made another request for review :)
blacksmile
#3
I've sent a request XD
sleepybeans
#4
Hi! I've requested! ^_^
kalon_sama #5
Chapter 39: Sorry for the late pick-up! I just recently got stable internet ;A;
But yes thank you for this review~ I didn't think you were that harsh, it's understandable since you like BTS as well. The title I thought would get a lower score, to be honest xD because I thought that that's how the song title was written; with a 'U' instead of 'You.' (I don't know anymore OTL. I'll change the graphics to match the background, and I see where you're coming from with how vague my foreword is, but meh. I personally like vague forewords so sorry~ And thank you for your comment in the plot section! I was actually lazing around nit-picking at some lines when I got the idea actually hehe. The main character wasn't supposed to be clear as I didn't want to use names and label anyone, but it could be any BTS member you'd want I guess~
Thank you for reviewing my story once again. I'll definitely come back!
AlisCookieMonster
#6
Chapter 43: BTW, I'll follow what you suggested and add line dividers! Thanks for the suggestion, never really thought of doing it until now~
AlisCookieMonster
#7
Chapter 43: Just saw the review! I totally wasn't expecting that, but thank you for reviewing my one shot, and I will credit you guys ASAP. :3
libianno
#8
Chapter 41: Thank you sooo very much for the review on Chasing Pavements. I truly appreciate your efforts in reviewing it for me. I will credit you as soon as I put up my last chapt.
Thank you :D
Pingdwae
#9
Ah i'm sorry but i'm cancelling my request :( mianhe.
blissfulcoconuts
#10
Chapter 42: I do use microsoft word before I update. I always wright on it and sure I would put pics and such in the upcoming chapters and i'll start putting borders