The Fallen - Susakaele

Light Livid Dreams: A Review Shop (Open) (Batch 2~)
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

if you're on mobile, please rotate your screen for a better and comfortable view ^^

 SUGALGI     01/09/18     9 CHAPTERS     sTORY LINK  Susakaele The
fallen INTRODUCTION (3/5)

I really like your introduction; however, it fits better if you add it to your prologue. It's too long to be a foreword and same goes to what you wrote in the description section. Forewords are often used to catch your reader's attention and make them curious as to what is behind it. Even if you did made them curious because of the element of cliffhanging, the way you did your introduction looks like you revealed a big part of the story which I disapprove. It's as if I'm reading a chapter instead of an introduciton.

I recommend for you to either write a few sentences that can summarize the story OR write just a paragraph.

Basic summary (2/5)

I was a bit lost with the summary you've submitted since you didn't really gave me the actual summary. Most of the time, the summary helps us, reviewers, know what the story is all about without reading the story yet. For my case, I used it as a basis to see if your story doesn't go far from the summary.

 You should already give me the main points of the story or the plot, to be exact. For example, I have to actually read the story just for me to know:

1. What is a Guardian?

2. Why Taehyung is somewhat against to the Head Guardian's orders and who the Head Guardian is?

3. What did Taehyung do to have his wings get sliced off?

4. What does Eunbi have to do with him?

5. What did Taehyung want them to understand and who is them?

I unfortunately couldn't give you an example summary since your story is still not yet finished but I hope you get what I meant here. title originality (7/10)

Most Angel AU's have the word fall, fallen or a word similar to it in their title so it's not really that new to me since we all know that every angel who goes against their own kind, commits a crime or goes against their rules would be banished from the above and thus, to be called a Fallen or Fallen Guardian/Angel.

I'm honestly not sure if what you meant by Guardian as in Guardian Angel or basically they're angels but since your title is The Fallen, I assumed that this is an Angel AU.

presentation of story (8/10)

Despite the things I said about the title and the introduction, your presentation is not really that bad. Although it's a bit messy since like what I said before, your introduction can already be mistaken as a chapter. The way you wrote it somehow covers that messiness.

I admit that even if I was suprised and beyond confused when I read both the foreword and the description but I was deeply mesmerized at how you wrote it.

The poster is also very pretty and gothic so it kind of gave me the right vibe when I started reading your story.

chapter flow (20/20)

Okay, honestly, I was deeply and truly amazed at how your story is written. The flow of the chapter is very satisfying and I didn't get lost between the chapters. Each chapter is attached securely to each other wherein it is really connected with both the previous and after chapters.

I absolutely love how you describe everything in each chapter. Since I have a wild imagination, your descriptive paragraphs helps a lot in making m

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
XxLittleKittyXx
Hello- Kitty here!
I am free and open to do reviews! Feel free to request from me anytime :D

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Moonshiner #1
Request form

Author : moonshiner

https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1900944

Title : Sea in your Eyes

https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1411855/sea-in-your-eyes

Character : Chanyeol and Kyungsoo and Jongdae
Genre : fantasy and slice of life(?) idk
Summary : false diagnosis of schizophrenia and sea creatures


Non rated
Type : chaptered with 7 currently
Ult bias : Jongdae and Kyungsoo
No preferred reviewer, everyone is welcomed
Ongoing

Author note: just tell me if anything is confusing, coherence and whether it is all over the place.
Aryaprava_1993-
1101 streak #2
Author : Aryaprava_1993-
Story title : stubborn beloved
Link :https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1334233/stubborn-beloved
Profile link :https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1636545
Character : oh sehun x Oc
Genre : romance ,comedy (and little bit )
Summary : She has fire in her eyes and he has a heart colder than ice. She cares for other and he can't be more careless. She always wears a smile and all his lips can do is smirk coldly.
Chapters :22 and completed
Password : livid
Favourite bias : sehun and Jin
Author note : it's already completed and I wanted to have a review about it.
Preferred reviewer : XxLittleKittyXx
Thank you!
charlislekim
#3
Author: charlislekim

Story Name: every last bead

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1360039/every-last-bead-angst-fantasy-romance-yeri-crackship-bts-mythologyau-supernaturalau-faeries-jungkook-btsjungkook-redvelvet-btsvelvet-bangtanvelvet-redvelvetyeri-jungri-siren-gidle-yuqi

Profile Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1524000

Characters: Yeri and Jungkook

Genre: fantasy, supernatural, romance

Summary: In exchange for magical favors, debts are given to the receiver in the form of black beads. Seven years ago, Yeri gathered enough black beads to fill her whole entire left arm. Now, Jungkook, with a chaste kiss and mischievous smile, is finally ready to collect his debts.

Chapters: 1 - 4 (i'm not rlly sure what u mean sorry)

Password: livid

Favorite Bias: kyungsoo

Author's Note: it's not complete yet and still pretty short but i wanna see how it is so far^^

Preferred Reviewer: sugalgi (if not possible, any is fine)

thank you!!
PCYplusBBH
#4
Hi, I requested for a review a few months ago, in like July, and it hasn't been done yet. I was just wondering if there was a hold up? I had completely forgotten about the review, but I recently got another story reviewed and I suddenly remembered >.< You can take your time, but I wasn't sure if you needed the time or just didn't want to do my review >.< (at the time my usernames was PCYplusBBH) I'm not at all trying to sound rude or anything, I promise >.<
charlislekim
#5
Also is it possible to request more than one per batch??
charlislekim
#6
Hello! Is it okay to request if my story is only two chapters long?
PCYplusBBH
#7
Author: PCYplusBBH

Story Name: Catch me when I fall

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1339434/catch-me-when-i-fall-angst-exo-exok-exom-hunhan-chanbaek

Profile Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1751762

Characters: Luhan and Sehun (exo)

Genre: angst

Summary: Luhan is terrified of ever trusting anyone else. He has been let down left and right, he has been in love, or so he thought, so many times. And all he was given back was false affection and lies. So when Oh Sehun stumbles into his life and takes all of that pain away, Luhan must decide whether he will open his heart one more time or if he will learn from his past mistakes and ignore this new feeling Sehun has given him. Whatever he decides, it will affect his future greatly.

Chapters: 1

Password:Livid

Favorite Bias: I have two, Hoseok (BTS) and Chanyeol (exo)

Author's Note: This was my first time writing a story like this. It's kinda dark in the beginning, but gets lighter as the story goes on.

Preferred Reviewer: Grackie
SpillTheUnicornBlood
#8
and i don't know if it's okay to ask for another review, but i'm sending again. feel free to turn me down if i can't. u.u

Author: SpillTheUnicornBlood

Story Name: Wake Up and Look At Me

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1205473

Profile Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1169976

Characters: Seventeen's Joshua, Mingyu, S.Coups, Wonwoo, Vernon, Jun, DK, and mention of other members

Genre: Romance, Fantasy, Suspense (?)

Summary: Monday to Saturday. A series of encounters with Jisoo waking up being loved by a different man.

Chapters: 7

Password: Livid

Favorite Bias: Seventeen's Hiphop Unit (I gave up choosing u.u)

Author's Note: English is not my first language >.< the story might have a lot of plot holes and hanging/unanswered questions are intentional

Preferred Reviewer: none. (anyone is fine! ^^)
SpillTheUnicornBlood
#9
Chapter 42: hi! i'm picking up my review!
(reviewer-nim, my comments are in the reply so other people won't be bothered by my lengthy post >.<)