CALLING FEFEDOVE

The Library Review Shop (CLOSED)

we belong together
written by fefedove
reviewed by -ericsnams

 

Title: 9/10
Upon first reading your title, I was actually thinking that the story was probably going to be something angty(-ish) or romance-y, which turned out to be very much wrong, but it’s definitely not bad! I see the link between the title and your story’s content, so that’s good!

 

Plot: 14/25

                4/10: Setting
                Nothing much happens in this section, but I am however also aware that setting isn’t exactly the main focal point - and to be honest, I doubt it would help your story move forward if it was, taking the context into consideration.

                4/5: Originality
                Reading your description, I actually didn’t think this would score as high on the originality-chart because I just thought it would be a oneshot collection like so many others - but /boy was I in for a surprise/. The very concept isn’t that unusual, I reckon it all comes down to a question of looking closely through the tag filters of the internet, but the content is… Definitely new to me, and that’s not /only/ because I don’t really read EXO stories.

                6/10: Believability
                Correct me if I’m wrong, but I have a very strong feeling the believability isn’t the most important concept in this thing - after all, it’s s and es (peni???) with thoughts and feelings, and a car that turns into a person; it’s supposed to seem very unreal. But the unbelievability is very believable, I’ll give you that!

 

Characterization: 14/35

                5/5: Presentation
                The presentation of the characters in these small drabbles are actually pretty substantial - I’d probably frown upon it if they weren’t, because the unique situations in which Tao and Sehun find themselves kind of imply that you’ll need some kind of background information before diving into the whole thing. But you’ve managed to do it pretty well, and I’m very happy about that.

Fun fact, I’m so innocent (not really, but let’s pretend for a while that I am, yeah?) that I thought the recap of the first drabble was meant in a metaphorical way all the way until I actually got around to read the description (school has scarred me, everything is a metaphor!!!!!).

                4/10: Development
                Because each chapter portrays a different story, there isn’t really much to talk about development-wise as a whole entity. But discussing your drabbles as single pieces of work, there’s a sense of consistency in what you do, although I have a feeling that you maybe didn’t write this with character development in mind - which is fine, because I recognize this story is not meant to be extremely well-articulated in terms of what kind of characters you use.

                5/20: Diversity/Purpose
                This section was actually kind of hard, because other than serving as a comic relief in some cases where the situation calls for it, the purpose of your characters wasn’t that clear to me. I’m only allowing myself to tell you this in the way that I do because you’ve made it clear that it’s a crack story, and if you feel like I’m skating over some things superficially, please tell me!

 

Writing Style: 28/30

                10/10: Narration
                I really like your narration - you keep a steady pace and get the important stuff explained in a relatively simple manner, and I feel like there’s some underlying humor in your words and explanations, which I really like. It’s like sarcasm or irony, but in a nice and friendly-minded way. Amazing!

                8/10: Consistency/Flow
               
As previously mentioned, your individual stories have some kind of consistency within them, although I reckon it can be very hard with such relatively short space to do it, so I salute you! Good job!

                10/10: Spelling/Grammar
                I really don’t want to give you the impression that I think your story’s just for s and giggles, because I don’t. I actually think you have something good and fun going on for you here, and your readers seem to think the same thing, so no matter how this turns out to score, keep in mind that your readers are happy - that’s gotta count for something, right?

When it comes to your spelling, I can’t really find anything that’s off. Your language really brings your stories to life, and if there /are/ any mistakes, my guess is that they’re so small and insignificant that they can easily be corrected by a quick once-over before posting your drabbles.

 

TOTAL: 65/100

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
SouthWest
Calling yummyvanillacream! Your Review is ready!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
yummyvanillacream
#1
Chapter 57: WOW I'M THRILLED. Didn't expect the review to be this good (or maybe I did). Ahaha.
First of all, BIG BIG thanks to you SouthWest! I can clearly see how you really read through each important detail in my story and I feel very appreciated. Thank you for all the time you took to review, it means a lot to me! I had a bad experience when I paid kps for a review yet they did it so poorly as if they just skimmed the story rather than read it. But this shop actually gave free service for such a great review! Months of waiting for this review is totally worth it.
Okay, and I actually sort of predicted the downside you mentioned here since I've worried about it a lot: the slow progress of the story. It didn't occure to me when I first wrote it, but it did when I almost finished it and read it back. So thank you so much for telling me about it. Now I can be sure that it is a problem I should fix. And about the question on why he was even in SM when he wanted to be with Ana so much, the explanation of all that is actually on the next chapter. It's still on the process of beta-reading for now so I'll post it once the editing is finished. I hope you'll read it when you have time ^^
I like it how you noticed that I focused more on emotions rather than visuals. Actually, describing visuals has been my weakness. I find describing the feelings is rather easier than visuals; or perhaps I guess I'm just so obsessed with pain and heartbreak /slapped. But I will try to keep improving on that!
This is the part that I'm thrilled about: how you said I'm really good at getting into a character’s head. I've been thinking that this is my talent /slapped again-- ahaha but not so many people told me this, and I'm always happy whenever someone mentions it. (Will continue on the reply)
yummyvanillacream
#2
Hello, I'm sorry, not that I'm rushing or anything-- but how is the progress of my request? I have seen that the person doing my review doesn't have their name on the foreword anymore, and I'm wondering why. May I know what happened?
KangminBread
#3

After thinking much i still believe that Clovers is the best title because of Youngwoon’s struggle and the end revelation that there are two 4-leaf-clovers. What other titles would you think would fit? i really can’t think of anything. I will pay more attention to the chronological set, thanks for pointing it out, describing places is not my forte.
if you would like to make better comparison you can watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=01xbvbbSyvc it shows the main story of the manga and pretty much explains the background i tried to incorporate, basically Suu (the four leaf clover) makes a deal with a wizard, kazuhiko (the one with a leaf in his hand) would take her out of her cave and bring her to an amusement park, once there Suu would kill herself, the other wizards didn’t know of this bargain and tried to capture her back so they used the power of the other imprisoned clovers (the serpent, the birds and the fairy statue), in the end she saves kazuhiko but kills herself. I really don’t like this end lol so I wrote what i wanted suu to do for the other clovers and the biological power is my invention XD the bomb is from the clover manga, suu kills herself by allowing the wizard to implant a bomb in her and then exploding it when she was alone at the amusement park
I will take your advices in the development and when i have time i will work on exploring more of Sungmin’s feelings thanks for pointing that out too
should i add the video i liked you in the description to help those that had never read the manga?
wolfie-88
#4
Chapter 49: hi there TT ok i am really sorry that i am so late for this...i haven't been around in aff for a while now...busy with life TT i just read your review...well to be honest it was kind of harsh lol but i am ok with it...i didn't have any high expectations for my story too. it was my first time writing that long in eng and i tried my best...but well yeah i agree it was not good at all...that's why i have stopped writing in eng for a while now :/ i went back to writing in my native language ...but i guess some of the stuff you mentioned are not language related so i will try to work on them...once more i am really sorry for being late, i didn't mean to be rude :* tnx for the hard work dear
That-One-Writer
#5
Chapter 47: Thank you so much for the review, SouthWest!!
I'm sorry for such a late pick-up, I've been on hiatus during the end of year, and I just now came back! Now to my comment!

You’re right about the title! I didn't add the element of fate anywhere in the story, and I'm feeling really silly because of that now XD I usually have trouble with titles, and I didn't think too much when coming up this one XD (maybe I'll try to add a mention of fate here and there with the old lady, to tie-in with the title!)
About the fieldtrip, I actually wanted to describe Jeju a bit more (especially the volcanic caves part, which I'm super interested in!), but because of the word count restrain, I feel that a lot of things got left out. After reading your review, I found myself wanting to edit it and just forget about the word count XD
About the scene in the convenience store (in chapter two, with Maeri panicking because Mingyu disappeared), I think the problem is my description XD. She's panicking because she felt abandoned and like she didn't have control over the situation. He disappeared and she didn't even notice, because she was too wrapped up in herself and such. She was feeling bad about herself, and being judgmental with her own personality, which only fueled those anxieties she had. I think I should definitely edit that scene and try to make that come through a little more (and maybe remove the word 'panic', since it's such a strong word, and try other adjectives).
I'm so happy you gave me a perfect score for characterization!! That's what I focus most on my stories, and it's nice to see my efforts paid off! (Though Mingyu seems to need some editing! He needs to be more consistent. I think I was focusing too much on developing Maeri, and I sort of forgot about his motivations. I definitely have to review those moments you mentioned! Thanks for bringing it to my attention!)
(Rest of the comment in the reply section because I write too much XD)
snow7ys
#6
Chapter 4: Hye,
I would like you to review my story
Loving you was my favourite mistake..
Link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1199607/loving-you-was-my-favorite-mistake-jungyonghwa-parkshinhye-yongshin-yongshincouple-yongshinlove

I'll appericate your honest reviews....It would help me to write better stories in future...
Take your time...
Blessed 2017...