Review from Peachy Review Request Shop

Without You

This time, I got a review from Peachy Review Shop

This is their review:

 

Without You

Story Title: 7/10

Comment: Even though the title sounds like a cliché fanfic,it actually suits the story quite well^^Great work~!(Y)  

 

Storyline: 24/30

Comment: Oh my gosh,can I tell you,this fic made me cry at some partsTT TT I feel so bad for Junhyung... Let her be with Junhyung goddammit! I'm unsatisfied only because of that,in other words-This fic is amazing.^^  

 

Grammar/Spelling: 6/10

Comment: As much as I want to give you full marks for the great story,your grammar wasn't perfect>.< There are some weirdly phrased sentences,and some misused vocabulary.  

 

Originality: 5/10

Comment: Though I loved the fic,it wasn't exactly the most original one.The plot line has been used before,but usually the girl would end up with the guy who she liked back(in this case,Junhyung) than the guy she actually married(Doojoon) so,nice twist!  

 

Flow: 9/10

Comment: The flow was rather smooth,and quite enjoyable.  

 

Characters: 15/20

Comment: The guy characters were very well portrayed in this fic,but what about the female protagonist?She seemed too perfect,and unrealistic.I mean,it's not very common having two hot guys fall in love with you,right?  

 

Want for updates: -N/A-

Comment: -The story's finished-

 

Total: 66/90= 73% Good job^^  

 

Suggestions: -None-(since the fic is already over)

 

Criticism: Just work on your grammar,but since you've already said that English wasn't your first language,I'm not complaining much.

Since this fic was so great(in my opinion) I'm going to add it in the recommended fics section:)

 

Reviewed by PeachCherryProposal

 

Haha~ I got in to the recommended fic section. Thank you so much, Peach~ ^^

Review credit to PeachCherryProposal

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
KiwiPrincess #1
Chapter 43: aawwww..sweet ending..love it..and she end up with Doojoon..yeay.. \(^0^)/

you know? this fic was amazing..you do a good job authornim..really good job..i love this fic so much.. ^^
Typical-Singaporean
#2
Chapter 43: Waaahhh~ A super sweet ending with DooJoon! <33
han-na #3
It's a such beautiful story! I love it!
Thank you,,,
AngelicNaty
#4
No!!!!!! I can't believe that the fic it's end!!!! I finish this story now and I have to say that I love it...! No one knows how much I cry reading this fic...! Unnie really u are amazing!! Thanks for ur amazing story! :')
Kpopmimi
#5
NOONONOONONOONONONONOONONONONOO IT'S ENDED TT^TT u know I read this in one night it's 2:07 am right now Kekekekekkek I LOVE IT SSSSSSSSOOOOOOOOO MUCH R U KIDDING ME !!! who wouldn't love this !!! I cried through out the story and got heart attacked several times lol!!!! (how drama queen am I ) BUT come On now ! I just can't resist this story thank you !!<3
hikamayra
#6
i love this..

thanks for a great story...
mefika
#7
got here from "searching for fiance" then, "Please Say No to Him Coz I Still Love You" then this "Without You" : i become 1 of ur fan..really luv ur style of writing..:)
KeYusMkaii #8
Nice story. I like the ending its so unique and I love the plot ^^
rosemary #9
love thissssssss:D