✌REVIEW - Here Comes the Younger Byun! (by catssss)
✔✔TRAVERSE SHOP - REVIEW & PROOFREAD✔✔Story title:
Author(s):
Genre(s):
Fluff
Romance
Romance
Story Status:
Ongoing
No.of Chapters:
6
Category:
Multi-Chaptered
Total Points:
44/60
TITLE: 3/5
The title's a bit too long, and the fact that it ends with a punctuatuion mark (!) adds to that. Titles should only be 4 words long. Also, I would not recommend your title to end with punctuations such as exclamation points (!), question marks (?), and an interrobang (?!) because chances are, readers are not going to take your story seriously.
DESCRIPTION/FOREWORD: 7/10
I find the description clean, since it's brief and doesn't give much of the plot. But there's one thing missing:
Where is the conflict?
Personally, when I see a story's description where the conflict is missing, off to the next story! And isn't just any conflict, the major conflict. Sure, there is some minor conflict at Chapter 4, but that's it. What else?
Please be not one of those type of stories where it exists purely just for the sake of fluff. Unless your readers are desperately thirsty for fluff and are Lay-biased, in-depth readers will not find the story interesting.
Spice up your story a little bit. I've seen a lot, and when I mean a lot, I mean tons and tons of those types of stories, where it exists just for fluff.
I see that at the first paragraph of your Foreword, it's just the description paraphrased. I recommend you to remove it because it's unnecessarily repetitive.
Where is the conflict?
Personally, when I see a story's description where the conflict is missing, off to the next story! And isn't just any conflict, the major conflict. Sure, there is some minor conflict at Chapter 4, but that's it. What else?
Please be not one of those type of stories where it exists purely just for the sake of fluff. Unless your readers are desperately thirsty for fluff and are Lay-biased, in-depth readers will not find the story interesting.
Spice up your story a little bit. I've seen a lot, and when I mean a lot, I mean tons and tons of those types of stories, where it exists just for fluff.
I see that at the first paragraph of your Foreword, it's just the description paraphrased. I recommend you to remove it because it's unnecessarily repetitive.
PLOT: 7/10
Anyway,
The plot... well... it's kinda hard to explain... I can't express this in words...
Basically, this is like snippets of everyday life of Byun Soojin?
I found a plot hole here (not exactly) in Chapter 4. I'll explain it in the Characters. But there's one thing that kept me entertained throughout the story: the comedy
Flow of the Story: 4/5
I found nothing disrupting the story flow except for one detail but let's talk about story progression first. Up until Chapter 6, supposedly, nothing major happened. No, not even a spark of Lay x Soojin. They haven't talked properly yet even up until Chapter 6. And I consider that slow.
CHARACTERS: 7/10
Byun Baekhyun... you and your overprotectiveness xD
I see a little bit of OOC here. Specifically, Soojin. From my perspective, she is someone who is sassy (proven when she sassed Minoyea, off Minho) , sarcastic, and straightforward (heck yes, when she sassed Mino) and someone who is certainly not softspoken (I can't find the right word lol), because of the fact that she will not hesitate to punch Mino's face according to her thoughts.
Then there goes the OOCness.
Later in Chapter 4, she didn't even tried tobeat the living sh!t out of that Queenka retaliate. If that would've happen, she would be a badass! Congrats, Soojin! Out of all the stories I've read, you're the first to stand up against a Queenka! But it didn't... It would be cool to see her do that! But she didn't do it... Not even the 'martial arts that look painful' (To all the readers, if you know that reference, you're awesome as ! And you're obviously a Carat too :D).
I see a little bit of OOC here. Specifically, Soojin. From my perspective, she is someone who is sassy (proven when she sassed Mino
Then there goes the OOCness.
Later in Chapter 4, she didn't even tried to
WRITING STYLE: 3/5
I'm not fond of changing POV. Not at all. It's confusing and somehow limits descriptive writing and the charcaterization to just one category (a character's thoughts). Why not just focus on Soojin's POV since she's the protagnist of the story? I know that you want to show the readers what the characters are thinking, but it can be shown through descriptive writing and characterization (like how Soojin sees the other characters, what the characters do, ect.)
The capitalized texts (such as BYUN BAEKHYUN AIN'T LEAVING THIS PLANET YET., ect.) is somewhat incorrect through a professional writer's perspective,but who gives a ! Majority of us are not professional readers xD admit it however, it makes up for its comedy value because these capitalized texts are somewhat emphasized to be funny and it's working :D
The capitalized texts (such as BYUN BAEKHYUN AIN'T LEAVING THIS PLANET YET., ect.) is somewhat incorrect through a professional writer's perspective,
Grammar: 5/5
I find nothing distracting about the Grammar.
Satisfaction: 10/10
I'm definitely excited for the future chapters! How does Jin makes his move? Will Baekhyun beat the living sh!t retaliate on his sister's behalf!? Please update, author-nim!
scroll
edelweiss themes
Modified by StoicBread
Modified by StoicBread
Like this story? Give it an
Upvote!
Thank you!
Comments