(78.5) Entry 5 - When I Was Your Man by fyeahkpop

The Beauty and The Wolves || Writing Contest [Closed]

 

Title of Entry: When I Was Your Man

Participant: fyeahkpop

Pairing Used: seokris 

 


 

Judge: layseokris

 

Title: 8/10

-The title says every single thing about it-what more to say? (Plus, this is Bruno Mars' song and I'm kind of having a last-song-syndrome at that song that time XD) I spare two points for being a little common though :)

Storyline: 16/20

-Hmmm, the issue between former relationships right? I'm just happy that Seohyun's consistent with her decision. She doesn't waver-well probably because she really loves Lay already (and is actually happier). We all know that between seokris and seolay-a lot will choose the first one. You make a difference by sticking with seolay until the end :)

Grammar: 21/25

-There are few mispelled words, few mistakes on the tenses of verb and some slips on subject-verb agreement. Though, as one gets absorbed with your fics, I don't think it's still that noticable. :)

Flow of Story: 22/30

-Yours is actually on a fifty-fifty. I think it's fast and slow at the same time! UGH, I  don't really know how to explain it. Because I do have these feelings that you can actually give more details-but at the same time, I think that it's already the juice of what you have in your mind. IDEK what I'm already talking about.

Bonus Points:

-seokris as main (1 Point)

-uses my OT3 (2 Point)

From glamzchic:

-seokris as main (1 Point)

-seokris as main (3 Points)

 

Total Score from layseokris: 74

 


 

Judge: immakpoploverable

 

Title: 8/10

Storyline: 17/20

Grammar: 21/25

Flow of Story: 24/30

Bonus Points:

-seokris as main (1 Point)

-seokris as main (Individual Scoring-1 Point)

-angst (3 Points)

From glamzchic:

-seokris as main (1 Point)

-seokris as main (3 Points)

 

Total Score from immakpoploverable: 79

 


 

Scores: 79 Points (Aida) + 74 Points (Anne)

Average: 76.5 + early bonus point (2 Points)

Final Score: 78.5

 

*Do notify us if you find some miscalculations

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
OfSereneNights
Winners are announced! Note that there are some changes for the prizes! :)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
mantibaby
#1
whoop whoop
windyocean
#2
congratulations to all the winners WWOOOOHHH!!!!
infinitedaebakjjang
#3
Chapter 32: YOU GUYS MADE MY DAY, this is the first writing competition i ever entered and its the best really! since it was SEOEXO the shipping am so into shipping rite now 8D not only that, the other entries was so good so i never thought i would get the third place, so thank you very bery much! do make this kind of contest again, -coughsSEOHYUNcoughs- as main xD
MasterTrollSama
#4
Chapter 34: I'M SO HAPPY with this contest. You're all great judges and I absolutely enjoyed making Answers and I'm actually super surprised I got 2nd!! o__O (in a happy way) since there's so many great writers here~~
Very happy here, thank you so much ^-^
If you ever make another contest, I'll definitely join~~
beautifuldrop
#5
Chapter 13: WOW..... and thank you for the review! I didn't know you guys were going to do this either. Lol and yes I think I could of done better I put more effort into it. I was rushed I don't know why.
beautifuldrop
#6
Chapter 32: CRIES! I got sixth place, I actually didn't think I was going to win anyways ^^ This is great! It's my first time also and I changed my username. I'm sorry hehe. It went from seoulheiress to yummydrop. ;D
pikaseo
#7
Chapter 34: thank you so much!!!!!!!!!!! congrats to the winners :)
popgirl345543
#8
Chapter 32: Thank you so much for giving me third place! :) I worked hard on that story and am quite pleased ^^
tixings
#9
Chapter 32: Oh and congrats to the other placed winners! :)
tixings
#10
Chapter 32: Cry cos I got 7th place. Really thought I wouldn't be placed but I did. -sniff- Thanks for hosting thus contest! I enjoyed writing the one-shot for this. :)