First Impressions: [10/10]
at first glance what i thought (sometimes unedited thoughts
and how my mind works when i first look)
AGH. this poster is like perfect. what do i even have to say?
Other reviews i have to look at how to give points, 
here i have to think of what to subtract!
i have to stare and get up close an personal to it,
to see if theres any areas to improve.
i dont know how you improve on perfect though.

Technique: [19.5/20]
how masterful are you at blending/cutting
you know your blending is like perfect right?
i have to really really be looking for something to comment to find these things.
the top of the girl's head is a bit too blurred.
maybe lasso, feather and then add some contrast there.
but she is blended pretty damn well in there especially since the background is from the guy's picture.
at first i thought you went and got some stock like
in a train cabin. thats what it felt like to me, but the i saw the dudes original picture
and it was a locker room lol.
oh well. still makes me think of the animated Anastasia movie.
the only other thing i can comment on is that blob on the left.
is it a cloud? or smoke? or from texture? iono but it stands out just a hair too much.
makes me think of an hourglass. not sure if its good of bad.
i would have probably moved the stock up to raise the horizon line 
to minimize hourglass

yes she is rocking a halo.
 

Resources: [19/20]
does your images/stocks/brushes/textures enhance the poster
images are good goes well with theme.  i dont like how the girl 
is looking down but whatever still matches. textures use good. 
nothing unneeded there. i like the subtlety it brings. the light scratches for instance.
i like that subtle glow behind the quote, adds more dimension.
you got the train part down but i wish there was something connecting it to the heaven part.
i like how the stock adds that one point perspective
and brings even more attention into the title. 
maybe make the stock show up a bit more?
to make it obvious what kind of scene or image it is.
right now because its qu