♪ Fallen of the Angelus by brxkenfaeries

♪♫ Midnight Sonata Café ♫♪ | Reviews and Recs [CLOSED for requests & READ CH. 37]
R E V I E W
 
tumblr_n24re1Yop91tqq2koo1_1280.jpg  
         by brxkenfaeries
         EXO || BTS || INFINITE || APINK
         supernatural | romance
         Chapter | Ongoing
         Reviewed up to Chapter 15
         Reviewed by hopexdreams
 
♪ Mine
       by Kim JaeJoong (김재중)

Title.

Your title was rare and there isn't any other stories on AFF which has the same title as yours. That's good because your title is something new to the readers. I'm sure the readers who enjoy reading supernatural fics would be intrigued to read your story.

Appearance.

Your current poster is beautiful and it perfectly matches the story. There's nothing I could criticise about your story's appearance. Everything is just amazing.

Foreword/Description.

I love the quote you used from City of Ashes for your description. It suits the story well. However, I don't understand why is "a recrudecence of evil, love seems to tangled upon her way." typed after you pressed enter. You typed it like this. There was also grammar and spelling errors in your foreword.

What you typed;

Waking up one day as someone different from the rest of the world, is not one thing that always happen to one.  When retrievers started to have those demonic yellow colored eyes as if they're going to tear you up soon ; when the world started unwrapping its thick cloak that's been hiding innumerable dark secrets,  she got no choice but to return where she belonged  ‒ the demons world.   As she struggle against

a recrudecence of evil, love seems to tangled upon her way.  

Will she fight to love or fight for love? 

 

What it could've been;

Waking up one day as someone different from the rest of the world, is not something that always happen to one. When retrievers started to have those demonic yellow eyes that screams your death is nearing ; when the world started unwrapping its thick cloak that's been hiding innumerable dark secrets,  she has no choice but to return where she belonged  ‒ the demons world. 

 As she struggle against a recrudescence of evil, love seems to tangle upon her way.  

Will she fight to love or fight for love? 

 

Other than that, your foreword is very intriguing and it isn't possible for a supernatural fic lover to not get entranced with the description and foreword.

 

Plot/Storyline.

The plot wasn't very original as I've seen several stories with the similar plot ; the main character changing into someone different overnight. However, there was definitely a turn when the Queen captured them to be executed. I expected the Queen to transform into a demon or something and the surroundings change into a demon-ish room since you said that she had no choice but to return where she belonged which is the demons world. It's either that part hasn't came or you went out of your storyline. Make sure you stick to your storyline until you finished your story. Otherwise, the plot was pretty good.

 

Character Development.

I didn't like it how you made a chapter to introduce the characters, but it's your story and your style, after all. In my opinion, Lana's character was quite well developed. She's that type of girl who tends to talk back and can unintentionally hurt the people who are by her side. I can actually relate myself to her character. Kris too. He apprears to be a jerk-ish guy in the start of the story, but after reading more of the story, I can see how much he cares and loves Lana as a blood sister. Or even more from what I read in chapter 5. However, I didn't like it when you had all the 12 members of EXO in the story. Maybe it's cause I'm an EXOstan, but it makes me feel that some members will get less attention. For example, up to Chapter 15, Kris and Suho has the most attention, followed by Baekhyun, Sehun, Xiumin and Chen. I only saw Lay in 2 sentences, Kai in 4-5 sentences and Luhan only had the first sentence of the whole story. I don't know the pairing of this story, but the first sentence I read made me think that Lana had some special relationship, probably between friendship and relationship with Luhan. But after reading more of the story, it wasn't like that. Why wasn't Luhan in the Characters Information in your story? He had the first sentence, after all. BTS too. Only 3 of the 7 BTS members were introduced in your Characters Information. Although the other 4 might not really have a big part in the story, they should be introduced as well.

"Look, I know it's best for them to tell this all to you themselves but I think you seriously need to know this by now. Kris, Suho, Lay, Luhan, Xiumin, Kai, Kyungsoo, Tao, Sehun, Chen, Baekhyun, Chanyeol are all Nephilims and the reason why they live with you all their life is because you're one of them too, a Nephilim and their not blood related little sister." explained Rap Monster. So the entire EXO lived with her? Why did Chanyeol have only a line even after 15 chapters? And not all of them were introduced. It makes me feel like you left Chanyeol out. Other than that, I loved how you portrayed Lana and Sehun's character. It makes me feel like it's a SehunxOC or a KrisxOC story although I don't know the pairing.

 

Use of Language/Mechanics.

I didn't have much problems reading your story although you had several spelling and grammar mistakes here and there. Nobody has perfect grammar, after all. It was rather pleasant to read your story. Here are some of the grammar or spelling mistakes I listed out. I'm not listing all the errors because if I did so, you wouldn't learn from your mistakes.

 

In  Chapter  1.

I felt dizzy all of a sudden.  I felt as if I can fall from the chair at any time right now.

What it could be ; All of a sudden, I felt dizzy, as if I can fall from the chair any time.

 

Just as the words started to fly off my mouth , he cutted me off with a wave of his hand.

What it could be ; Just as the words flew off my mouth, he cut me off with a wave. (The word cut's past tense is also cut.)

 

In  Chapter  5.

"I thought you guys where the Children of the Night? as in biologically saying , Nocturnal" replied Baekhyun.

What it could be ; 'Weren't you guys the Children of Night? As in biologically saying, Nocturnal. That's what I thought." replied Baekhyun.

 

In  Chapter  7.

The wind was cold that night. More colder in the storage room.

What it should be ; The wind was cold that night, but the storage room was colder. (If you used the word 'more', there's no need to use the comparative adjective of cold. It's either 'Colder in the storage room.' or 'More cold in the storage room.' but that doesn't sound right.)

 

You should read back after you typed a chapter, to prevent any errors. Having many errors can cause many readers to lost interest in your story. Otherwise, the grammar was good and your story was easy to understand.

 

Flow.

I seriously didn't like it how your chapters were so short. I thought you progressed much with the story when I saw nearly 15 chapters written, but I can easily merge several chapters to make a chapter instead of breaking it up into several chapters. It felt rushed too when I see short chapters. There should be more elaboration on how Lana felt safe when she was with EXO. The part where her father talked to her should be in chapter 3 or 4, instead of the first chapter itself. It was too rushed. Everything just..happened in the first few chapters. Other than that, the flow was fine.

Reader's View/Enjoyment.

It wasn't very enjoyable to see the sudden change of fonts in chapter 1, where Chen spoke. It seemed as if you were trying to make him the center of attention in the chapter. The words also went out of the line in Chapters 1 and 2. My first interpretation of this story is 'you' were always in a safe place, not knowing the danger out there, then one day she snuck out not knowing she's really wanted and yeah. I kinda expected the fairy queen to morph into a demon or something though. I didn't understand what faeries are. Are they some new supernatural species similar to fairies or something else? 

Additional Comments.

I don't know what to say here. There were A LOT of grammatical errors everywhere. Please reread your story again after you typed it out. This will cause readers to lose interest in your story.



Review Credit to hopexdreams from ♪♫ Midnight Sonata Café ♫♪
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
momodays09
im sorry for the delay. school is just ughh. I can't make any promises, but I will aim to finish the two reviews in progress by the end of the month x.x

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
-caas-
#1
Hi. I'm starting a shops list and I want to add your shop/gallery/list/contest/roleplay :
Read the rules, complete this form , put it in the comments box for this link and you will be on the list.

Author's name:
Author's link:
Co-authors:
Created:
Status:
Banner's link:
Shop's Title:
Shop's link:
Shop genre:
Description:
Author's Note:
Info you want to add:
Services/Packs/posters/trailers exp:

http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/802501/dream-city-shops-list-graphic-poster-trailer-advertise-shop-layouts-reviewer
Diviana #2
Chapter 39: Chapter 38: I am surprised you got to my review as quickly as you did. Thank you for the review, I will fix those grammar mistakes. I'll keep in mind to be more detailed as I write (that as has always been a problem of mine). I don't understand how my foreword was messy though. I'll credit later today.
JESLEN #3
Chapter 36: Hi thank you for this wonderful review. I agree with everything that was mentioned and I'll try my best to incorporate the suggestion. Yes, Haha, I think this was posted late because there were some things in the review that were not included in the story anymore :D Anyway, thank you very much for the review. 81 is still a decent score since I barely started the story. Credited ^_^
azxema
#4
Chapter 37: read the review.
wow, even though I'm lacking 72 is pretty much a decent marks right? right? lol
I guess I should not abandon and pay more attention to the little things such as the comma, I didn't know it'd make so much differences.
Thanks for the effort - really appreciate it. really.
overdosagexo #5
Chapter 28: Hello >< I am so sorry about this late reply... Yes, I would still like to read my review :) I apologize if this adds on to your burden...
Story: 包子 (Baozi)
aeterniti
#6
Chapter 34: Thank you for the review (and the feature - wow, I'm honored)! I read it well ^^
I actually like your way of thinking that Jongdae was inhaling the flames over and over again as atonement for his sins. The thought hadn't crossed my mind, haha XD
Ah, yes...Yixing XD To be quite honest, I just needed a ghost of his past, and since Yixing's my other bias.....X) Yeah, there was really no deep reason behind it being Yixing. Just personal preference, ahaha XD
But I'm glad that you enjoyed reading it while reviewing it ^^ I'm glad that I was able to convey the process of insanity in Jongdae to you, the reader. :)
AleatoryThinker #7
Chapter 33: Thank you for the review! I really appreciate the feedback. I'm seriously a dunce when it comes to titles as in I have no idea if the title is good or bad no matter how many times I think it over. In this case, I couldn't come up with anything that wouldn't give the assignment away, because, yeah, I'm not creative. Plus I'm not concise with words. A bad combination.

I'll definitely be on the lookout for those boring/lagging scene when I'm editing. The make-out scene was never planned so the suddeness makes sense. I'll either move it on the timeline or possibly cut it out. Making the character emotions is something I'll have to work a lot harder on, but I'm really glad the characters came off as realistic.

Once again, thank you for completing this review as it helps me a lot!
vexatious #8
Chapter 32: Thank you so much for the review! I haven't read it yet, but soon I will <3 I've already credited you in my foreword, so thank you so much again!
azxema
#9
Chapter 28: Not that person anymore's author here.
I wouldn't mind a late review, i'm not in a rush so yeah. I still want my review
vexatious #10
Chapter 28: Hi! Im sorry for the late response i havent been able to go online. Yes i would still want to read my request :)