fefedove

Pie-licious Review Shop; CLOSED- FINISHING REQUESTS

REVIEW PICKUP: fefedove

Title: 4/5 I think 'Our History' is quite a nice name, and it has revelance to the story. It's not overused. However, if I were to scroll down on a list of stories, I wouldn't click on yours based on the title, because it didn't really attract me.

Description: 5/5 Well, your description pretty much sums up your whole story, but without telling the plot, which is a good thing because your story is really short and revealing the plot wouldn't have made it as interesting.

Vocabulary: -/10

Grammar: 10/10 From the emails the other members of EXO has been sending, I didn't see any grammar mistakes so I'll give you full marks on this.

Plot: 7/10 I think... having a character have a miscarriage is a pretty common plot. I've seen many stories out there like that, but I liked the idea of you putting it all into a web browser's history. I've never read anything like this before, only chats, and even though the history was kind of complicated for me, it was really unique, and original.

Flow: 9/10 I don't really know how to grade you on your flow since it's like a web browser history... But since it looks good enough to me, a 9.

Effect on reader: 5/10 O_O Idk I was pretty confused when I read it because which were supposed to be the chats and which were the history... I'm a really slow person erhhem excuse me. A miscarriage is a very sad thing, but since you didn't actually put it out in words, but only in the searches history, it didn't affect me. I didn't feel emotional while reading it, and even though the layout was well done, I don't think I was that attracted to your story. 

Overall: 55/100 I'm sorry if the review was so horrendously short >< 

REVIEWER: kaepie

REVIEWED FINISHED ON: 07/16/2014

Reviews are not meant to insult so please don't take our reviews too harshly! This is only from one's point of view.

You can read the story here!

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
kaepie
Hey, kaepie here. I'm sorry but I won't be able to do my reviews as quickly, because I'm having a really busy week. I'll try my best, though!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
b2utifulstarlite
#1
-caas-
#2
Hi. I'm starting a shops list and I want to add your shop/gallery/list/contest/roleplay :
Can you pls complete this form and put it in the comments box for this link?

Author's name:
Author's link:
Co-authors:
Created:
Status:
Banner's link:
Shop's Title:
Shop's link:
Shop genre:
Description:
Author's Note:
Info you want to add:
Services/Packs/posters/trailers exp:

http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/802501/dream-city-shops-list-graphic-poster-trailer-advertise-shop-layouts-reviewer
b2utifulstarlite
#3
Chapter 30: Thank you so much for the wonderful review! I will work on the suggestions for the title and the description to improve them. :) In the future can I review for this story again?
Isellina
#4
Looking forward to my review :) thank you in advance
darkpleasure
#5
Chapter 30: Thank you for the review! I decided not to skip the reply and write one quickly (I need to go to work agh!)
Description- You had me wheezing due to lack of oxygen. I laughed so much! XD Yes, Chapter 6 was meant to be disgusting after some point and I'm glad (well, not exactly that word) that it turned out like I wanted. I always try to do my best in forming images easy enough for the reader to fantasize so this is the best compliment one can give me. Thank you! (and no, I am not such a director. I'll think about it now that you mentioned it, though xD)
Plot- 'My Love from the Stars' did give me an idea. But the powers and such were a loose combination of the 'EXO powers' and whatnot. I admit that it give me a boost in my inspiration, though. And the fainting when kissed might have been from MLFTS, I'm not really sure where I got that idea from... ^^;
Flow- I seriously don't deserve so many compliments! >ω<
I'm truly thankful for the time you took to review my story! Really! And I'm glad you liked it as well! I will surely come back when I finish my new story, if you would not mind. Also, could I credit you as a reviewer next to the shop credits? I like to credit the people who do the work as much as the shops they work for. ^^ (sorry for writing so much!)
searchingmyself
#6
again, applied for a review . thanks for your hard work:)
searchingmyself
#7
Requested for a review.
thank you^^