moonlightJHN

Pie-licious Review Shop; CLOSED- FINISHING REQUESTS

REVIEW PICKUP: moonlightJHN

Title: 2/5

I'm sorry but it happens to be really cheesy and anything with Cinderella is cheesy as it is really easy to give away the plot before reading the story.

Description: 2/5

Character profiles are a huge no-no. If you make a character profile, it just makes one feel like the author can't inaugurate the character within the story.

Vocabulary: 7/10

Nothing really different. Simple words and phrases. 

Grammar: 4/10

Since you disallowed the text selection I won't be able to add many corrections; just the basics though.

No matter what it's 'yelling' not 'yellings', since yelling, here is used as a Present Continuous Verb.

Try using a semi-colon [;] when you have too many commas.

Plot: 5/10

The first thing was you didn't even try to explain the features of the characters, which you should do more especially since this has an OC in it. For all I could know all these people might be Raptors something.

Another thing is that you mention SoRa' doll towards the end and you say that she carried it around everywhere. But the thing is, you didn't mention the doll anywhere else. (Correct me if I'm wrong.)

Other than that, most of the plot was roughly placed and felt at some points that this didn't belong here.

Effect on reader:  6/10

The same problem as before, you need to describe the characters within the story no matter how famous they are. 

Nothing else though. It was simple and expressed the feelings that you would have wanted it to convey.

Flow: 7/10

Smooth and there are no weird points where the plot breaks off but the fathers' role is a bit too unexplained to me as well as MungHee's and MungSoo's characters.

Overall: 60/100

Everything was organized and everything but the character thing; you have to work on that.  


REVIEWER: TheSparliestVampire
FINISHED ON: 10th July 2014
Reviews are not meant to insult so please don't take our reviews too harshly! This is only from one's point of view.

You can read her story here!

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
kaepie
Hey, kaepie here. I'm sorry but I won't be able to do my reviews as quickly, because I'm having a really busy week. I'll try my best, though!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
b2utifulstarlite
#1
-caas-
#2
Hi. I'm starting a shops list and I want to add your shop/gallery/list/contest/roleplay :
Can you pls complete this form and put it in the comments box for this link?

Author's name:
Author's link:
Co-authors:
Created:
Status:
Banner's link:
Shop's Title:
Shop's link:
Shop genre:
Description:
Author's Note:
Info you want to add:
Services/Packs/posters/trailers exp:

http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/802501/dream-city-shops-list-graphic-poster-trailer-advertise-shop-layouts-reviewer
b2utifulstarlite
#3
Chapter 30: Thank you so much for the wonderful review! I will work on the suggestions for the title and the description to improve them. :) In the future can I review for this story again?
Isellina
#4
Looking forward to my review :) thank you in advance
darkpleasure
#5
Chapter 30: Thank you for the review! I decided not to skip the reply and write one quickly (I need to go to work agh!)
Description- You had me wheezing due to lack of oxygen. I laughed so much! XD Yes, Chapter 6 was meant to be disgusting after some point and I'm glad (well, not exactly that word) that it turned out like I wanted. I always try to do my best in forming images easy enough for the reader to fantasize so this is the best compliment one can give me. Thank you! (and no, I am not such a director. I'll think about it now that you mentioned it, though xD)
Plot- 'My Love from the Stars' did give me an idea. But the powers and such were a loose combination of the 'EXO powers' and whatnot. I admit that it give me a boost in my inspiration, though. And the fainting when kissed might have been from MLFTS, I'm not really sure where I got that idea from... ^^;
Flow- I seriously don't deserve so many compliments! >ω<
I'm truly thankful for the time you took to review my story! Really! And I'm glad you liked it as well! I will surely come back when I finish my new story, if you would not mind. Also, could I credit you as a reviewer next to the shop credits? I like to credit the people who do the work as much as the shops they work for. ^^ (sorry for writing so much!)
searchingmyself
#6
again, applied for a review . thanks for your hard work:)
searchingmyself
#7
Requested for a review.
thank you^^