✽ { I S I S } by writerinprogress94

{ e x o u r o ♡ reviews } // closed

 

 
 I S I S 
by: writerinprogress94

 

//TITLE: (2/5)

Spacing in between letters really isn’t that much necessary. Isis also seems too vague, plus it’s common to find fics with this title already. It fits your story, at least.

 

//DESCRIPTION & FOREWORD: (2/5)

From this I immediately thought that your fic is like one of those cliché good vs. evil stories already. This didn’t really put off much of a spark to me, either. Character description wasn’t necessary either. Readers would have to find out themselves on the roles of each character. You did mention “*More in-depth character descriptions will be revealed throughout the story”

 

//WRITING STYLE & APPEARANCE: (3/5)

I’m impressed at your writing style. However… I have to be frank…your poster kind of ticked me off.

 

//PLOT: (19/20)

Okay I admit this is just intriguing.

 

//ORIGINALITY: (18/20)

I could say that you made it quite original.

 

//FLOW: (13/15)

I got quite confused at the shift between Isis and Earth, but at least you placed an author’s note in Chapter 4 to explain this. Setting that aside, I’m okay with your flow.

 

//CHARACTERS: (13/15)

I can imagine what your characters are doing, and I could identify their distinct roles. But I couldn’t quite follow how you introduced “The Hunter”. The You/Bom thing was quite confusing as well.

 

//GRAMMAR & SPELLING: (15/15)

There’s only one I’d like to point out:

“On the far edges of the universe,” You probably meant “far edge” here. What I understood from far edges was that maybe at both the left and the right edges, they have an Isis. Isis is just one planet, after all.

This could be negligible to others, I guess, so I just let this pass.

 

//OTHER REMARKS:

I’m not really into fantasies but… wow?

//t o t a l: (85/100)
I’m sorry this took me long to post, but thanks for requesting n_n

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
BR_exo
#1
Wow your 20 years old this year, time flies. I hope you comeback. Seems like you left after Kris news :(
Nictaeny9
#2
Chapter 27: Erm what about my review?
chensing #3
Chapter 26: thanks for the review! ill fix those things ^_^
LISHlian
#4
Chapter 25: Hi! Thanks so much for the review! I will try to improve on all the things which you've mentioned, and work on the things which I'm lacking of. Thanks for your honest review! ^0^
Nictaeny9
#5
username: Nictaeny9

title: Dark Ties

link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/543164/dark-ties-dark-romance-snsd-taeny-taeyeon-tiffany-yuri

no. of chapters: 9 (on going)

theme: Dark, Drama, Romance

main characters: Tiffany and Taeyeon

is english your first language? : yes

password: 900326
chensing #6
username: chensing
title: monster in the corner
link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/562201/monster-in-the-corner-exo
no. of chapters: 1 (on going)
theme: angst, mystery.
main characters: kris x oc
is english your first language? yeah.
password: 900326

there's only one chapter so far :/ I hope it's still reviewable though? :)
LISHlian
#7
username: LISHlian
title: ☬Nemesis of the Sky Descendants☬
link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/388020/nemesis-of-the-sky-descendants-fantasy-krystal-romance-supernatural-exo-kai-kaistal
no. of chapters: Currently 3 (including prologue)
theme: romance, fantasy, angst, supernatural, drama.
main characters: Krystal, kai, exo.
is english your first language? Yes
password: 300326

Thanks. The story is nowhere near complete. It barely even started! But still, I figured that I needed a review to see how I was going so far. THANKS AGAIN! \^0^/
writerinprogress94
#8
username: writerinprogress94
title: "I S I S"
link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/306119
no. of chapters: 10 (well, 12 if you count the 2 most recent, but they're just author's notes, so you can ignore ch 11 & ch 12)
theme: supernatural/sci-fi/fantasy
main characters: "You" as Choi Eun-Su; BoA; TVXQ; SHINee; EXO; Infinite; Big Bang; 2NE1; many other kpop idols will end up with larger parts later in the story (I'm planning this out as a trilogy ^^)
is english your first language?: Yes ^^
password: 900326

I haven't completed it yet (not on here, anyway), because I've been thinking that it might need re-writing, which is why I'm hoping for an unbiased, in depth review ^^
pinkblink
#9
Chapter 23: Thanks for reviewing and subbing! :3 Will credit you in my foreword soon :)