Review for Rebel Makeover

[CLOSED] Bee's Review & Advertisement Shop

Title (3/5)

I lied your title. It's just that it did not captivate me into clicking on it and reading it. But It did fit the story very well.

Description/Foreword (8/10)

I absolutely loved the foreword! It was so long and normally I would take points off for that but because it really captivated me and kept my attention it definitely made me want to read on. The only problem was the structure. Though it was visually pleasing it screwed up the sentence structure, other than that amazing!

Characters (8/10)

I loved the characters and they all seemed to stay true including the main girl, Rian. Though it seemed she changed too quickly from her rebellious behavior to a cutesy pie. But that was how she originally acted so I thought it fit kind of perfectly. Though I do wish you would’ve made her behavior change a bit slower I still loved the characters.

Plot (15/20)

I loved the plot! Everything seemed kind of perfect in that sense but I will say that I have read and heard of stories like this. But I still read it and loved it because it wasn’t cliché in an annoying repetitive sense that made me want to stop reading it. You did have tons of twists and turns that kept me captivated and intrigued and I loved that part of it, so good job!

Grammar (15/20)

Your grammar was very good for someone whose native language is not English, however. You did have a couple of mistakes that made it hard for me to read. You were missing words to make a sentence complete and it also skipped very important words that made the sentence mean something else or be utterly confusing.  You also used the wrong tenses occasionally and used words that do not exist in the English language.  But overall you had amazing vocabulary and I absolutely love it when people use big words instead of the usual drawl.  So I was pleased with your vocabulary.

Flow (6/10)

Your flow was probably your biggest problem; you jumped around from point of view way too much. I love hearing form others points of view but I also hate it when it jumps around a bit too much and also to random characters. Also the fact that words were missing also made it harder to read and flow nicely.

Visual Things (12/15)

Your font was perfectly fine, but of course there was a problem. You used caps way too much also you used the full term for CPR, when it would’ve been simpler for the character to say CPR; because honestly I don’t know anyone who says the actual words. Also addressing that you use capital letters too much, you should either italicize those words instead or even just say that the person specifically placed emphasis on this one word. Otherwise it just gets very irritating and I tend to shout the word out in my head or out loud when I read it and it’s written in all caps. The poster was very simple and pretty!

Ending (--/10)

You did not have an ending yet. So this will not count towards your final score.

Extra Comments: I am really sorry I took forever to update and review your story! I have a very bad habit of getting distracted and handling too many things at once. I really loved your story however your writing does need help, but I do wish you luck with it. ^^

Total 67/90

Rebel Makeover


I hope this helps your writing improve and I wish you luck!^^

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
keyoppa_aina
#1
Chapter 31: I'm here! ^^ First of all, I am so happy to read about your comment on the title because personally, i think a title is very important to capture a reader's attention and I am so glad you gave that a full mark ^^ And the description, if it wasnt for the ending, i bet i would get a higher marks right? After you pointed about the ending, i tried reading the description again and you were right. It is somewhat too cheesy and spoil the mood, my bad, wuuu~ >< I won't comment on each of it because that's just too long LOL but overall, I am happy with your review <3 I have weaknesses on grammar [always] and I need to expand my vocab and improve my sentence structure too

"Like I said before I honestly have no clue how you managed to make such an unoriginal idea somehow original and unique. I loved that a whole lot. " <--- you have no idea how much you motivate me with this. I am so happy to read that, thank you! ;___; <3
Nhoxmew
#2
Chapter 33: Saw the ad xD Thank you very much. But I would like to add in a few additional things regarding my request :) I would like some words in the curse quote ("Hark! Hark now! ... a happy ending.") to be bolded if possible. The words are: regret, time, punishment, find, love, not, happy ending. If you can please bold them xD Thanks~
soo-ya-milk
#3
Chapter 1: Review form:

Author: kpopstan13

Author's link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/411909

Story title: Between Love & Friendship

Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/519903/between-love-friendship-infinite-ljoe-myungsoo-romance-schoollife-exo-kai

Is English your first language? No~

Chapters length: ( long, short, varies) It "varies" depending on what's gonna happen in each chapter. The first chapters were quite short from 1000-1200 characters only but as the story progresses, it becomes unconciously longer.

Is it complete? Not yet.

How many chapters if not complete? 36 Chapters.

poster link: http://i.imgur.com/qFBRs9u.jpg
 
Critical comments will be welcomed :) I won't mind it seriously. I need those as an author in AFF. Please tell things honestly ^u^ You're great! ;D
Nhoxmew
#4
Chapter 1: Author: Nhoxmew

Author's link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/wall/333787

Story title: This Everlasting Devotion

Story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/665794

Summary: Cursed with a bittersweet fate, as lovers, they shall cross each other's path in every lifetime. Yet as strong as it may be, their love will never be answered.

Two male gods, engaging in a love-hate relationship, caused massive chaos during a silly fight in the holy Palace called Paradise, otherwise known as Heaven. As the result The Great decided to punish them. A punishment that will last eternally.

" Hark! Hark now!
Mark my words, insolent creatures.
O how I regret thine existences; marry I doth.
Aye, time canst not be reverted verily.
Hereby the punishment thou deserve.
For lifetimes thou shalt find each other,
Love one another,
But I,
I wilt make sure thou wilt not have
A happy ending. "

"Hey hyung."
"What is it?"
"Do you believe in second chances?"

Genre: (but no ), angst, romance, fantasy, drama plus a bit of comedy and mystery.

Characters: Infinite's Sunggyu and Woohyun (Woogyu)

Rated (yes/no): No

Oneshot (yes/no): No

Poster link: http://i.imgur.com/v0OyzDd.jpg
EXO-TIC_12 #5
Chapter 1: Author:

Author's link:

Story title: The MatchMaker

Story link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/665333/the-matchmaker-arrangedmarriage-fluff-romance-you-exo-luhan-baekhyun

Summary:To love is a crime, a crime that is paid with the death penalty.

This is the law of society. However there is the other option. You can love the one whom society matches you with through the system simply called the "MatchMaker" where there are absolutely "no flaws" and "you'll love your match."

The "MatchMaker" is a system where all 18 year olds enter. They "match" you up with another girl/boy and you just simply get engaged, married, and have children.

But Byun Baekhyun and Cho Minji are lovers.

Secret lovers. Only a few know that secret. But still...

Secrets, especially one as dangerous as that, are meant to be kept secrets, because if spilled, you'll be lying in your grave.

But the "MatchMaker" had other plans for the secret lovers.

Genre: Romance

Characters: Cho Minji(OC)

Rated (yes/no) yes

Oneshot (yes/no) no

I'm still working on it T^T
Kate_Sunshine
#6
Chapter 30: I'm not so satisfied with the review, but anyway, thank you for the fast work :)
kaseume
#7
Chapter 29: Thanks for the review~It's really helpful~ ouo
DriBSK #8
Chapter 27: Hi. Thanks for the review.
But it took a bit too long. =/
i will take your advice in consideration in my stories (though i have 'given up' on this particular story)
Thanks
Kate_Sunshine
#9
Chapter 1: Review form:
Author: Kate_Sunshine

Author's link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/119172

Story title: Fix Me

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/670469

Is English your first language? -No

Chapters length: ( varies)

Is it complete? No

How many chapters if not complete? 2 (With a third chapter upcoming.)

poster link: https://24.media.tumblr.com/d8ce3c7176b3752971cd5f571748449e/tumblr_n13nb7l85H1r2xjzzo1_1280.jpg

Thank you ^^
kaseume
#10
Chapter 1: Review form:

Author: Aphrodite123

Author's link:
http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/395755

Story title: Breakeven

Story Link:
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/650633/breakeven-angst-oneshot-romance-exo-kris

Is English your first language? no~

Chapters length: it's an oneshot~

Is it complete? yup~

poster link:
http://i1276.photobucket.com/albums/y467/skydrunk/BE1_zps20dbc039.png

thanks~ ouo