Ripped: You're My Wife!

☠I'll Rip Your Story to Bits.☠ Reviews && Fanfic Help [Closed]
Author:  heechan27
Reviewer:  --placingfifth
Status: Picked-up and credited.
Posted: 12.16.12


Your Story is Called What?!:  ☠☠☠☠☠ 

Personally, I didn't like it. Not only seemed one of those 'I'm Living with --' kind of stories, but it just didn't look attractive. I pretty much already guessed the biggest surprise of the story without even looking at it. 

So this Thing Right Here...That's a Description and a Foreword...? You've Got to be Kidding Me!: ☠☠☠☠☠ 
I must ask for you to be very careful when writing your description. If the title manages to lure the readers in, the description is like a little taster of your writing. If it isn't right, the readers won't continue. The problem with your description was that you told just way too much. I mean, I was practically already reading the actual story. Also, you changed grammar quite a lot. Also, you used the wrong words at times. That didn't help, either. For example:

Knew [ Wrong ]

Found out [ Right ]

 

Your little foreword did not help at all. I am a big Eunhae shipper, so I pretty much know quite a lot about the characters already. When I saw your foreword, I was like, 'Seen this before. Should I skip?' But I couldn't, because I had to review your story. The line that slightly put me off was,

Flirtatious fishy.

What? It was just so out of place.

I'm Ready To Stab Your Characters Now:  ☠☠☠☠☠ 
They seemed like such cliche characters. Donghae; the bad boy. Eunhyuk; the nervous wreck (in a way) or the weak one. Minor Characters like Kyuhyun; plain. Some of the characters seemed very unrealistic. The girls at the club weren't very realistic. Quite forward, a bit too much as well. Also, the way how Donghae is acting after a simple relationship is rather overreacting, right? From what I saw, the relationship wasn't much.

I took off points because of unrealism, the character profiles in the description and that fact that also their thought process was awkward to read. 

Are You Sure You Know What You're Doing?  ☠☠☠☠

Well, I had never really seen this kind of fic before. But nonetheless, I cannot ignore the unrealism of it. There are many questions about it that I just need to ask.

Why did they make up that weird contract?

What's up with donating all the property to the poor if the child refuses?

What's with making the contract before the children were born?

Why didn't they think that the children weren't going to be both girls/boys?

Why don't they just break the contract?

Breaking a contract is possible.

There were a few weird things that happened here and there, but even those were cliche.

Better Stay In School and Listen to your English professor: ☠☠☠☠☠ 

Your grammar consistently changed tense and because of the certain situation you were writing about, I couldn't get into the story properly. It was just awkward for me. Your spelling was actually fine, but the grammar was just too much to dismiss. Also, your punctuation as well.

"Blah blah blah?", [ Wrong ]

"Blah blah blah?" [ Right ]

You don't need that comma. 

 

.. [ Wrong ]

... [ Right ]

An ellipse has three dots.

 

"Blah blah blah." she said [ Wrong ]

"Blah blah blah," she said [ Right ]

 

"Blah blah blah?" she tapped her chin.. [ Wrong ]

"Blah blah blah?" She tapped her chin. [ Right ]

I Can See Why You Like Writing Better Than Arts: ☠☠☠ 

Your poster did not match your story. If I saw it, I would've thought that it was going to be some angst/romance story. But your story seemed more on the funny side. You had no background, but I won't blame you for that. Your font was readable though, so good work. 


*YAAAWNNNN* Meter:  ☠☠☠☠☠ 
This is my personal opinion, but if I ever came across your story, I wouldn't have read it. I have been on AFF for a very long time, so my reading range has changed over time. The main reasons were because of the cliche plot and grammar.

I won't say if your story is worth readiing. I strongly believe that it is not my place to tell you that. You are the judge of your court. You make the calls. But please, try learn from this. 

VERDICT: ☠☠☠☠☠/☠☠☠☠☠


 

Read the rubrics if you don't get the review. If you want a soft copy of this, just tell us and we'll personally PM it to you. Any questions, just ask. Thanks for requesting!

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
blingblingforever
[I'll Rip Your Story to Bits]The Crush Review--Complete![Chapter 21]

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
relau99 #1
You haven't updated since 2012, does that mean this shop is no longer working?
Everyone is cool and I'd like to get my story ripped if you will still accept requests in the future ^^
Mahwiii
#2
Chapter 54: i reallllyy am super sorry >.<
at that time i had exams and couldnt log in but then i stopped coming in aff.... really sorry..
i even took some of ur time and its just too late now...
but now i checked..
uhhh idk what else to say >.<
am stupid am sorry ...
....
i really know its late but i still feel bad and will feel bad if i dont apologize probably.. sorry >.<
MasterTickleBack
#3
Chapter 45: ☠AFF Name: LadyTickleBack
☠ I want a: review
☠Story Title: Rulebreaker
☠Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/408307
☠Details: school, romance,
Password: You, you, you are so addictive.
☠☠Main Group in your story: B.A.P.
☠☠How many chapters does your fic contain? 9 right now
tinnitus
#4
Chapter 68: *pouts* It's still closed and the holiday's over DX
Kwontokkii
#5
Chapter 44: This is cool :D
YongOppa
#6
I would like to withdraw being a deliberator.

As for the fanfic review I've been assigned too, I'll review it, put it in a blog post and personally PM it to the requester.
Haruka-Harukaze75
#7
☠AFF Name: Haruka-Harukaze75
☠ I want a: review!
☠Story Title: Vampire Knight Destiny (Korean Ver.)
☠Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/340868/vampire-knight-destiny-korean-version-afterschool-ftisland-infinite-japanese-korean-snsd-superjunior
☠Details: you, you, you are so addictive.
☠☠Main Group in your story: After School and Infinite
☠☠How many chapters does your fic contain? 2 so far
dreamyflower
#8
Chapter 47: I've got a question. Would you review a really long story? One that has 40 chapters; each chapter has 1200-1800 words. And the story is not finished yet.