+ sistarsstar1
` m a g n o l i a — a graphic review shop :: 「 REOPENED AFTER YEARS! 」magnolia
SistarsStar1
Review
First impression [4/5] : Pretty nice, it looks neat and nice!
Font [8/10] : The typography looks really bright, and I suggest you to use another font for the 'astro' (but this one is already pretty fine!) and also, the credit looks a little unclear.
Mood [11/15] : I don't know. Why romcom? It looks more like a profile edit since it consists only of one person. The coloring does look romcom, though.
Coloring [8/10] : It fits the mood and the coloring is pretty cute! Just a v v v little bit too bright, but that's no big deal. Maybe you'd like to match the skintone a little bit more with the other renders.
Placement [8/10] : I think the placement is already quite good, not gonna say a lot here.
Blending+technique [16/20] : The background still looks like they are just a lot of flower pictures being put in one frame, for me. Especially the flower near the title, it looks slightly awkward, somehow? (and the plant on the left, it feels awkward). Also, his picture that is exactly above the title, the render is still slightly untidy esp. if you zoom in and look at the corners. It might be great to tidy them up!
Resources [4/5] : There can be a lot more resources to be put, but it's good!
Originality [7/10] : Not the most original piece you can go with.
Overall look [12/15]
Total score: 4+8+11+8+8+4+7+12= 78/100
Personal comment: First of all, I am sorry if it is too harsh or it's an inaccurate review o/ ps i am curious about who that eunwoo is HAHAHA thank you for requesting here, upvotes are appreciated and please comment once you've read the review to let me know that you've read it! good luck and thanks! ^^ -asdfghjm15
Comments