[R] PenguinLOvers772: A Remedy To The Broken Soul.

~BUBBLY G.S~ (HIATUS/HIRING TRAILER MAKER)
 
 

AUTHOR: PenguinLOvers772 STORY TITLE: A Remedy To The Broken Soul.

Title (08/10): I took off two points because well the title really gives away the plot.

Characterization (08/10): You gave Suhyun too much of an emphasis as her being a flat character. She’s not much of a character so going really into detail is a bit pointless. I also wish you would put more emphasis on Seungri’s character seeing how important he is to the plot.

Themes (10/10): I think you did an excellent job at representing depression. You gave the audience a point of view for them to be able to feel the character’s point of view.

Setting (00/10): You don’t really have a setting and I really can’t review something that doesn’t have it.

Description and Foreword (09/10): I think the description is rather misleading honestly because you really just barely graze over Suhyun’s character. Yet I would still keep it. Your foreword is strangely laid out.

Writing Style / Techniques (08/10): You have way too many spaces between the paragraphs. It gave me a bit of a head ache trying to keep my focus on the story and be interrupted by this giant space. The beginning author was not really necessary. You stated it once so you don’t really need to repeat it. If your reader didn’t read, it’s not your fault. Your grammar is excellent and there are no misspellings which is always a plus for me.

Presentation (07/10): I think your poster really misrepresents the whole story. I think you should really just stick to Youngbae and Seungri. However the rest of the layout of the story was neat and orderly which was great.

Structure and Flow (10/10): You have an excellent flow. Nothing is rushed or going too slowly which is rare to find.

Plot (10/10): I loved the plot. It’s got a very unique touch to it and probably the best story I’ve read within its category. I can tell you really had put a great amount of time in effort into this piece and for that I must applaud you. I really respect and admire writers like you.

Overall Enjoyment (10/10): This story has struck a personal chord for me. I was stuck in the same situation as Youngbae when I was little so I know what it was like to be like that. I enjoyed it and may be a bit biased in the enjoyment. I think you did an excellent job at representing the reality of the story.

Overall Score: 80/100
Overall Percentage: 80%
Reviewer's Note: Other than emphasis and spacing I think you should have this story advertised. It’s a beautiful piece of work and I hope it gets the following that it deserves.
THEUNICORNLADY

 

| STORY | THEUNICORNLADY |

 

 

 

 

 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
blossomheartz
Hi guys, just to remind, pls, pls and pls read the rules before requesting, it's the most important part so that nothing would happen in the future..

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
iluvbj
#1
Please make a cm for my story please
FortuneKookies
#2
I have requested a trailer for summerdust. Can you send me a link to who i need to pay?? Kamsahamnida!!! :D
ELFantasyhand
#3
Chapter 105: Thank you for the review. I'm maybe going to rewrite this fanfic one day.
AoifeCross
#4
Chapter 104: Thank you so much for the honest review. You pointed out a lot of concerns that I had over the story and I really appreciate you mentioning them (like the point of views, the relationship between Jungkook and Jimin, and other things too) Honestly when I first started writing the story, it all came from a small dream I had and I simply wrote it out. From there ideas started popping in my head and I was making it up as I wrote the story.
I didn't really have much organization or plans for this story so I knew it was super messy. But because I was already a bunch of chapters in I didn't know where to start editing or how. I really needed to get someone to review and help me find a way to improve and edit the story. I found this review super helpful! I've been thinking and planning on rewriting this fic and I really do plan on using this review as a guide to help me with the editing process.
Thank you so much! I'll credit you right away!
YoungChoi #5
HI! I’ve requested for a poster and bg. Thank you!
Pandaisy
#6
Chapter 101: I've picked up the trailer! Thanks for you hard work, I love it! xD
AmyleaT
#7
Hi. I've picked up the trailer. I love it so much. Thank you for the hard work. :)
summerdust
#8
Chapter 100: Sorry for the late pick up. Honestly I expected a low score ;; I even dreamt I'll get a 0 for this fanfic XD The reason I ask for a review on this is because I've edited this fanfic a lot of time and even I think it's not really satisfying in any way. It's not angsty enough and the flow, right is really all over the place. But I don't know how to fix it. But actually if not angst I really don't know what genre to tag it. I wrote this at that time where I really have the need to write something to be productive. And even though I don't know what to write I still force myself to think of something. So when I came up with an idea that I know very well I tried to make it in a story. But as I write this I realized that to make it in a story I should add other things even though I'm not really familiar with those. Especially being in a dorm since I've never been to a dorm in college. And a lot of other stuff. I also had a hard time of picking the main protagonist in the story. I am more familiar with BTS members so I use one of them. As for the plot it is basically that self harm. And I used the title Better because doing that really makes Taehyung feel better. When he cuts he feels relieved from his problems and yeah he felt better. I really should edit this again tho. Thanks for the review and telling me these. It really will help me in editing the story again. Picked up and credited :)
_cloud_
#9
Hello! I applied to be a trailer designer. ^^