Remember Me? by BAPKissmelikeEXO

Shark & Elephant Review Shop [HIATUS]

 

 
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

(Remember Me?)

author: bapkissmelikeexo
character/s: sehun, luhan
genre/s: romance
reviewer: shark
----------------------------------------------------------------
 
 

 

Title:  5/5

It suits the fanfiction well.

 

Foreword/Description: 4/10

When I first looked at your forward I cringed. There, in the first stanza was my biggest fanfic peeve, colored text. And not the tolerable colored texted, the unnecessary colored text. There is no need for color in your forward so please, change it.

I didn’t get the stanzas with colored text;

I dated you for a bet.

You never loved me?

Hi Luhannie. Remember me? I’m back.

Who is the one talking and it doesn’t make sense that he/she would care if the other didn’t love him/her because he/she dated the other for a bet. Unless they are not the same person, that is really confusing. If they are two different people, please put the stanzas in separate quotations to look like;

“I dated you for a bet.”

“You never loved me?”

The line;

Hi Luhannie. Remember me? I’m back.

Confuses me. Who is the one speaking? The first or the second line person. Please verify who is who, not with colored text, but with quotations.

After the colored text everything is fine except for the last two stanzas. It shouldn’t be;

“For a revenge.” But just, “For revenge.”

And change the last stanza to “Until she got tangled into a love triangle.” To make it flow better.

Honestly, after reading the forward/description, I was not compelled to read the rest of the fic. You need to make the forward more interesting to catch readers’ attention. That is what the forward/description is for anyways. I suggest adding more detail.

In the description there is white text highlighted in blue. Dear God, please change that.

 

Appearance: 4 /5

It’s easy on the eyes except for the colored text in the forward.

 

Plot: 7/20

The plot of your fanfiction is not evolved yet and it’s really common. I can already tell where this fanfiction is headed and it’s not even finished yet. I don’t think you should’ve requested a review when your fic’s plot hasn’t even ed yet.

 

Mechanics: 12/20

I found few spelling errors, and that can be fixed by double checking your work before you update. I’m not going to lie, the flow of your fic is terrible. The transitions are way too fast. I find myself reading over and over again to understand what’s going on.

 

Characterization: 15/20

Characters follow their roles, but are not fully developed.

 

Flow/Style: 3 /15

Terrible flow, refer to Mechanics. Your style of writing; not my type. You should not express actions between asters (*). And what was that random chat room thing in chapter one?

 

Overall Enjoyment: 1/5

 

Total: 51/100

 

 

 

 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
BelleandFran
[shark&elephant;] new batch is open guys!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
onew-sangtae
#1
username: onew-sangtae

story name: Getcha Head in the Game!

story name: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/510729/getcha-head-in-the-game-exo-crack-ot12-highschoolmusical

story genre/s: crack/comedy, i guess (and a lot of references)

story type/status: uncompleted; chaptered

other: is it too repetitive or...?????? i , i just need like a punch in the face and i guess this is a place to get punched in the face?
writerinprogress94
#2
username: writerinprogress94

story name: ABA: Accidental Baggage Assumption

story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/655736/aba-accidental-baggage-assumption-oneshot-romance-sungmin-superjunior-you-airport

story genre/s: I have it tagged as romance, but... I'm really not sure XD

story type/status: Completed/one-shot (possibility of being turned into a short story later)

other: Does putting it in 2nd POV make it seem too awkward? And what genre WOULD it be under? Please and thank you!
sweetcide-r
#3
username: sweetcide-r

story name: Painful Regret

story link:https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/464569/painful-regret-infinite-myungsoo-oneshot-romance-suzy-myungzy

story genre/s: angst

story type/status: completed-one shot

other: more suitable title maybe? hihihi thank you :>>
myungxsm
#4
username: TaeMiMi

story name: Isolated Destiny

story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/634236/isolated-destiny-angst-infinite-romance-woohyun

story genre/s: Angst;romance

story type/status: (is it completed or not? chaptered or a one-shot?) chaptered;not completed

other: (do you have a specific area/rubric you want us to help you with more?)maybe the plot part? :/ thanks in advance!
momodays09
#5
momodays09
#6
username: momodays09

story name: Last Breath

story link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/597465

story genre/s: angst, sad

story type/status: (is it completed or not? chaptered or a one-shot?): Short chapter, completed

other: (do you have a specific area/rubric you want us to help you with more?): Could you look more into the characterization and flow? And also the mechanics please? x.x
lissamary
#8
username: lissamary

story name: The Last Petal

story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/607250/the-last-petal-angst-oneshot-romance-yixing-exolay

story genre/s: Romance, angst

story type/status: complete

other: -

Take your time :)
World-Class #9