Review ~ Meant to Be

Midnight Wolf Reviews and More [Re-opened]

 

Title: Meant to Be

Author: Katakatica

Reviewer: Leisty

 

Title:  (3/5) The title isn’t that quite catchy, though it has a connection to the plot, the title just doesn’t really stand out that much.

Foreword & Description: (9/10) I actually like your foreword and description. You even put a part of your first chapter to it. But that would make the readers’ skip that part because they already read it.

Grammar, Spelling, etc.: (13/15) Just one few typo, you put sad instead of said. And your punctuations are fine except that you can use the semicolon instead of the comma.

Plot Line: (18/20) The plot is very intriguing. I only deducted some point since I don’t really have anything to say about it since it only has one chapter to it.

Flow: (8/10) The flow, same reason, it only has one chapter to it but even with only one chapter, you manage to make it eye catching.

Originality: (9/10) Again, arranged marriages are pretty common. But the part with asking a fairy for help is something unique. Most arrange marriages get boring because the plot they use is pretty cliché, but yours isn’t. You don’t use a grandma or someone older to make the characters marry each other out of their own will.

Characters: (10/10) Maya seems to be pretty real for an OC. To be honest, I stopped reading OC/You fics because they tend to make the OC to be Mary Sue. But you managed to make her real, the way how you describe how she was feeling, how self conscious she was. I just hope you don’t end up transforming Maya to Mary Sue.

Overall Enjoyment:  (10/10) I really enjoyed reading this; you’re giving me hope to read an OC fic again. I’m even tempted to subscribe, I’m actually debating if whether or not I should subscribe. This could even be a one shot and it will still be awesome.

Bonuses: (10/10) For the poster and background also for not using every color available on the planet.

(90/100)

Note: For the note that you posted on your comment, yes you are heading into the right direction with the plot and the OC and it doesn’t seem cliché for an arranged marriage type of story.

Comment after picking up.

Credit the shop and reviewer

Thank you for requesting and come again ^^

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Angel110
#1
Chapter 23: Wow! Thank you so much for the amazing review and such a high score! I think it's the highest I got so far!!! *^*
I'm so happy about it because I put so much effort into it along with my co-author who wrote eg. the childhood scenes of Sungmin!
I credited you<3
attaek_on_writing
#2
1.Username: aidylx16

2.Story Title: Strange Sights

3. http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/677484/strange-sights-supernatural-historical-leo-racism-vixx-jungtaekwoon-sensitivetopic

4.Password: Voodoo by Vixx or Where are You? What are you doing by B.A.P

5.Pereferred Reviewer: Any availible to review!

6.Fluent English Speaker: About 90%? I have trouble with my grammar sometimes. Other than that i'm pretty fluent
Lovex2254 #3
1. Username: LoveX2254

2. Story Title: The 27 Club

3. Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/762564/the-27-club-angst-romance-selfharm-exo-luhan-triggerwarning-27club

4. Password (favorite song): Good Luck

5. Preffered Reviewer(List is below):Anyone who's free

6. Are you a fluent English speaker: yeppers
myheartswishes
#4
1. Username: myunghyun4ever

2. Story Title: Runes of Despair

3. Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/701077/runes-of-despair-action-exo-exok-exom-mark

4. Password (favorite song): 1004

5. Preffered Reviewer(List is below): PandaChels

6. Are you a fluent English speaker: Yes

P.S: Please make it as detailed as possible and focus lots on Characterisation, description of events and settings, flow, plot etc. Thanks in advance.
Angel110
#5
1. Username: Angel110 (JanineLoveLife and me are/were writing both requests together equally)

2. Story Title: The Two Faced Beauty

3. Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/643875/the-two-faced-beauty-angst-violence-originalcharacter-exo-kai-sehun-kimjongin

4. Password (favorite song): Strong-SJ M

5. Preffered Reviewer(List is below): KreiKrei

6. Are you a fluent English speaker: look at the comment below
Angel110
#6
1. Username: Angel110

2. Story Title: All That I Have

3. Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/469027/all-that-i-have-angst-drugs-kyuhyun-kyumin-sungmin-superjunior-

4. Password (favorite song): Strong-SJ M

5. Preffered Reviewer(List is below): anyone who is comfortable reading about mental pain and self-harming

6. Are you a fluent English speaker: pretty much? I'm no native speaker but on a high level i think~
chquine #7
Chapter 19: Thank you for the review KreiKrei... =D
I appreciate the feedback and the advice... =D
I'll try to improve the plot and the OC better...
Thank you! =D
Lovex2254 #8
1. Username:LoveX2254

2. Story Title: Ice Queen

3. Story Link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/531759/ice-queen-b2st-beast-hyunseung-romance-bap-daehyun

4. Password (favorite song): Still Alive by Big Bang (as of right now, anyways ^^)

5. Preffered Reviewer(List is below): PandaChels

6. Are you a fluent English speaker: Yes!