(FR) MOONWHITE

Cosmos Review Shop - (CLOSED + REVAMPING)
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

 

FINISHED REVIEW (FR) : MOONWHITE - VICTORIA FALLS

Please pick up your review by reading this, dropping a comment and crediting us (reviewer and shop) using our banner (link back to the shop.)

 

 

TITLE: Victoria Falls

AUTHOR:  MoonWhite

MAIN CHARACTER(S): SNSD Tiffany Hwang & Kim Taeyeon

GENRE(S):  Romance, travel

SYNOPSIS:  Two seemingly unrelated girls, Tiffany and Taeyeon, met as tourist in a foreign land, Zimbabwe, a country that is home to the famed Victoria Falls. Several incidents then brought the girls closer to each other despite their rough beginnings. They later returned separately to their home country, South Korea, to find out that their fates continued to intertwine with one another and their fondness for each other deepens.

STORY STATUS:  Yuri, chaptered fanfic (10 chapters + 1 epilogue), completed

REVIEWED BY: Nixxiom

 

 

Title

I didn’t really receive any impression with the title. When I was assigned to work on your story review, I wasn’t anticipating reading and working on it because I was not at all intrigued with how it sounded. It seemed a bit plain and dull from my point of view, until I actually read the story.

‘Victoria Falls’ doesn’t seem to have a relation with the actual plot line. For me, it describes the setting perfectly, but it doesn’t give me any hint as to what the story will actually be about. Your title needs to be relevant with the whole story, not just the setting.

Now, in terms of originality, ‘Victoria Falls’ is a great example. I’ve read that Victoria Falls is one of the Seven Natural Wonders of the world and, while being a bit hesitant to read the story, at the same time it kind of intrigued me. And after I read the story, the title became meaningful in its own way, because then I could see how it related to the plot because of how it represented the place where our two main characters met.

 

 

 

Appearance

As for appearance, I can't really say it gave me anything to work with. All I saw were two girls and a waterfall. I knew that the two girls were Tiffany and Taeyeon, and that the waterfall was Victoria Falls, but what else? I was questioning myself because I thought that there was something that I was missing, so I looked over the poster multiple times and I couldn't tell anything else about the plot. Although I absolutely loved the soft colours and detailed background, I didn't really like the poster itself.

 

 

 

Foreword / Description

Unlike the title, the description definitely gave a great preview about what I was about to read in the story. It didn't give me too many details, as to ruin the story, but it gave me just enough information and a good bit of humor to make me want to keep reading. I must say, t

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
YodaYeol
We are closed and finishing all requests. We'll be open once we completed all requests.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
eunh0o
#1
Chapter 3: hello, i was wondering if you're still accepting reviewers! if so, i would like to apply to be one! I've had a bit of experience beta-reading my friends' essay and also i'm a writer myself! i just wanted to try out something new and would be very glad to offer my services to your team! thank you, hope you'll give me a response!
pandatypewriter
#2
Chapter 26: Thank you so much for the review! Thank you hocbaidi! It was very insightful and has given me a good guide to how I should write my future stories! Thank you so much and I will credit today!
girly_author-nim457
#3
Chapter 24: Thanks for the review! It's really helpful because I always feel like my writing can get better so thank you so much for the helpful advise, changes will be made! I credited/picked up the review ^^
*** Special thank you to strawberryhyun_ for taking your time especially since you had midterms (hope you did well and the delay was no problem)
Moony_Kat
#4
Chapter 23: Hi there! Thank you for your review! I really appreciate the feedback although maybe I was expecting a bit more of it on the characters at least, but I do understand that you have other stories to read and review, so still, I am contented with your review. Thank you again!
I picked up and credited :)
Tripping-Panda
#5
Chapter 22: First of all thank you so much to the review shop to give us an opportunity to get our stories reviewed and then thank you so so much to sekaimi who've spent their precious time on reading and reviewing my story STRANDED.
The review gave me such a great insight on what I can do to improve my writing, and also a good confidence boost. Which you sometimes need and I feel really inspired to keep writing after this review. You have many good points! I am going to redo the description to fix the mistakes and I went through my story to fix the few grammar mistakes you pointed out! I go through my own stories and when you've read and written something many times you easily miss the mistakes, so thank you for helping me with that!
About the characters, thank you for noticing that! I'm actually happy that you're not familiar with NCT, because then you can focus on the characters of the story and not just them as a group. I did focus on creating the characters with more depth and also be a little realistic with the development of their relationships.
You're right about the dialogue, maybe I've become used to see that when I read and just adapted to it, I'll try to experiment with my writing and avoid doing that.
I really love having multiple characters, but it's hard, I try to do it with balance and I am happy to hear that it worked out in the end!!
I know the ending is terrible, you should've seen me writing it, took me so long to actually convince myself this was the way it was gonna go down.
I appreciate the detail of your reactions to each chapter!
Your review was excellent! Really nice job of presenting it both very informative and inspiring. Good balance of compliments and constructive critism, which is perfect. Good luck with your other reviews! Thank you again! <3
I have credited the review shop and sekaimi !! <3
ExoDoll
#6
Chapter 21: I have credited the reviewer and the shop!
ExoDoll
#7
Chapter 21: Thank you so much for taking the time to read my story and giving me feedback. I'm glad that you enjoyed it and I understand about the whole proof reading thing. I need to get a beta reader soon for my grammar as most of the chapters are messily written in train/trams/buses or small lunch brakes and I don't really have time to go through the chapters after writing them. Thank you once again for your time and effort.
I will make sure to credit the shop and the reviewer in the story :)
Moony_Kat
#8
Chapter 20: Hi there^^ Thank you very much for the detailed review, I wasn't expecting it, but it's really helpful! I do tend to only proof read once before posting it, so I know that I have a lot of mistakes, which is great that you pointed them out :) I do feel you that the plot feels a bit rushed, but that was the entire point behind it: to give only moments in time and leave the reader wondering what exactly happened in between. It's a new style I tried... got to admit that this was meant to be a full story, but I decided against it because I have too much on my plate right now, so that might be another reason why the plot feels a bit rushed^^' Anyway, I really do appreciate your insight and hope you've enjoyed it!
I put up the credit and will correct the mistakes you've pointed out! Thank you again <3
kamski
#9
Chapter 17: Hello! I am here to pick up my review! Thank you so much for your insight, I'm glad you enjoyed the story! I was worried about the pacing and the character portrayals, so you've really put my mind at ease ^^
Thank you so much for your review, I've picked up and credited!