EmpireKids9 [Not that person anymore]

Drunkards Review Shop [CLOSED]

Title: Not that person anymore

Author: EmpireKids9

Story link: Not that person anymore

 

 

Title: [8/10;]

 The title, is not that related to the story, YET. I am still waiting for the next chapters where Hyuna would meet Kris and show him she's not the same person anymore. So as of now, I don't have much to say, except for these:

-Capitalize all nouns, pronouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs. And lowercase all articles and prepositions. So in this case, your title should be written like this; Not That Person Anymore

-Your title is too "wordy" in my opinion. It's quite long for a title.

 

Foreword/Description: [6/10;]

Grammar and spelling were fine.

The description gives quite a lot of details already. When I first read it, I was like, "Oh, this goes like this and that..". It doesn't need Einstein to predict what is gonna happen. Also the lines weren't that deep. The words were quite shallow. Try using some simple yet deep words for the description. Simple yet deep words give interesting vibes to readers.

I am an author myself, and sometimes, I feel bored when reading my stories because of the shallow words. (^^,)

 

Plot: [15/20;]

The plot is cliché. So far, nothing unexpecting and life changing had happened YET. It lacks mystery, thus it failed to get my attention and interest as well. I'm sure what I felt awhile ago was felt by some people too. :)

 

Characters: [19/20;]

The characters were great. Very relateable and they don't have that perfect personality, especially Kris. Usually, he is the "perfect guy" in stories but you gave him a more realistic role, so good job for that! HanMi is a cute girl, children are always like that so I have nothing against HanMi and the rest of the characters.

One little observation though, It isn't appropriate to call your fiancée "noona", right? Even if it is a petname or an endearment. :)

 

Grammar and Spelling: [17/20;]

There had been a lot along the way. But don't worry, nothing major so I won't write some long- criticism about it. haha!

Just a suggestion though, try proofreading or find a beta reader.

You also have the same problem as mine, (i think). It's about the pronouns "he" and "she". Also, I read a sentence where the other mom was holding her son but you put "daughter" instead. It confuses sometimes. :)

 

Flow: [15/15;]

The story flow is smooth. It isn't that fast nor is it too slow. So I don't really have a say in this part. :)

 

Structure: [4/5;]

Good. :)

 

Score: 84/100

 

So here you go, I'm sorry if you find some of my words offending. I tried to say it all as politely as I can. Thanks ^_^

 

REVIEW BY: cookiemonster555

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
cookiemonster555
Calling mygracelesshope! Review is done!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Miawitch_1002 #1
Chapter 10: i've read the review (obviously).
no. i'm not American. I was really afraid that the plot is too generic, i just really wanted to make a best friend story. I'm glad that i made you laugh while reading.
Thank you so much^^
I'll credit right now :)
Miawitch_1002 #2
Story link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/722521/just-the-way-you-are-baekyeol

Title: just the way you are

Oneshot or Chaptered: one-shot

Genre:fluff ; comedy

Message: i dont mind harsh opinions, because i have lots to learn ..
thank you ^^
mygracelesshope
#3
Chapter 9: Thank you for the review! I fixed my foreword
and English is not my first language :)
wondermickey #4
Chapter 8: Thank you so much for your review ^^ It's my first time requesting for a review and I was glad I did request in this shop ^^ Thank you so much! Fixed my description and will try my best to follow your tips ^^ definitely crediting you on my story's foreword. thanks again ^^
mygracelesshope
#5
Story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/704785/lunacy-angst-dark-horror-vixx-neo-toppdogg

Title: LUNACY

Oneshot or Chaptered: chaptered

Genre: angst/dark

Message: It's still ongoing, and thanks in advance! ^.^
wondermickey #6
Story link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/699479

Title: It's tae on!

Oneshot or Chaptered: chaptered

Genre: romance

Message: hello! i want to hear opinions about this story of mine. thanks in advance for reviewing it :3
mysoulisstarving #7
Chapter 6: love the review. short and sweet haha and i've been requesting for posters here and there, since I at making posters.., thanks again!! ^^
Lovex2254 #8
Chapter 7: Thanks for the review! I know the title is long, but the story was inspired by a song of the same title. And in the description, I didn't want to write that it wasn't worth it because it would give away the ending. And yes Sehun was supposed to be written that way. A lot of time I find that the idol characters are written to be desirable in some way and I wanted to change that in this story. I wanted to portray two people who weren't working together and neither one could really make the effort to fix it. Yeah and I didn't explain what a joint was cause I kinda assumed most people knew, but a joint is usually what you use to smoke weed.
Lovex2254 #9
Story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/721429/why-d-you-only-call-me-when-you-re-high-oneshot-romance-originalcharacter-exo-sehun

Title: Why'd You Only Call Me When You're High?

Oneshot or Chaptered: Oneshot

Genre: angst, romance, slice of life

Message: thanks in advance :)
Nictaeny9
#10
Chapter 5: I'll credit once I'm in my com... But pls do pm me to remind me as I tend to be a tad bit forgetful now and then