Shu867

Butterfly Review Shop | CLOSED | HIRING
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
 : Review for Shu867
by luvkookietae > Title: unorthodox relationships
> author: shu867 moonsun + seulrene college au. 
Solar and Moonbyul are best friends; people are just waiting for them to confess. Irene meets Seulgi at a coffee shop, where Seulgi proceeds to mess up her order every single time; despite this, Irene can't seem to stop coming back. Score: 76%
> Title: 8/10
> Description: 8/10
> Plot: 15/20
> Characterization: 18/20
> Grammar: 20/20
> enjoyment: 7/10  : The review 1. Title : 8/10
Okay I'll have to admit: Your title drew me in. It's not a common word, 'Unorthodox'; most people just use 'unusual' in its place. But then as I read on, i discovered that your story doesn't really fit its title? Unorthodox means contrary to what is usual, traditional, or accepted, but then you never mentioned that in he story, same gender relationships were stranger than normal. Unorthodox relationships basically means non -traditional relationships, but you don't seem to make an emphasis on that in your story. Think about it. 2. Description : 8/10
First Thing: Your description is super cute. I mean, who writes simple, easy descriptions any more? (NOT me) People nowadays love fancy scripture and plain weird vocabs, but yours is super refreshing. BUt why I cut marks off was the first four words: The 'Seulrene+Moonsun College Au'. Your decription is the first thing people see before they click into the story, so I recommend moving that to the bottom of the description. That's all. 3. Plot : 15/20
Cliche. I have no idea how to explain this further. You're 13, I get it (I'm a year older LOL) but your story is like oneof those classi
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
jaxial
Calling Shu867!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
CrazyJackson
#1
can we be affiliates?
Shu867
#2
Chapter 10: thanks so much for the detailed review! I've always had trouble with my pacing, haha...when I write, I don't have a predetermined plot or anything, I just make up the chapters as I go (it leads to super inconsistent writing XD)
the long wait is fine, I've been busy as well. I did better than I expected...heh I know I have a lot to improve on, but I started writing early so I have a lot of time to get better~
again, thanks so much! will definitely request here in the future, crediting soon
ambrozia
#3
i've submitted a request! :-)
-midnightbae
#4
Chapter 9: I’ve read the review!! I didn’t mind the wait, I was busy also with school and I understand you must have more important stuff to do hehe nevertheless I really liked the review! tysm for being honest! :) out of all the reviews I have requested this must be my fave (lol maybe because it’s my highest remark?) I really enjoyed reading ur review and I will consider ur suggestions! more love to ur shop xoxo
kamski
#5
I've submitted a request!
sharpteeth
#6
Chapter 8: i think the link to this fic is broken?
veneficious #7
Chapter 8: Picking up the review and thank you! You had me laughing through the whole review hahaha. Unfortunately, I'm actually a terrible writer, I usually only do straight pairings and I can't do anything more than a few chapters. I'm completely uncommitted T_T Thank you for your review nonetheless! No worries for the long wait, I appreciate your honestly. xD I definitely wanted Johnny to be more likable than Yeri, but a typical guy... hahahaha. I definitely understand personal preferences and differences between readers. Another reviewer scored this story a .90/100, whereas you scored it a .70/100. Both are good for me. I'm just glad the story made any sense at all. Thanks again for the review! :)
Shu867
#8
hi, sent a request!