Rules, Application & Request Status

Seventh Haven Writerly Advice & Review Shop | Open & Hiring |

(credit to Chang Dictator who made this, minorly revised according to this shop's specs.)

| RULES


1. You should credit the shop by posting a link to the review in your foreword. 

2. You MUST subscribe so that you can know when your review is complete. No subscription means no review. After you've read your review, comment so that we know it has been received. Feel free to argue your case in the comments if you feel that wronged in any way. If you would like, you can unsubscribe after commenting.

3. The password is TOPsyturvy.

4. Your story must ALLOW TEXT SELECTION. I need to have access to cut and paste parts of your story to provide you examples, suggested edits, and such. If you are uneasy with turning the text selection on, you may send me a word document with the chapters you want me to review at y2jsendoh[at]gmail[dot]com.

4. Due to the amount of time necessary to thoroughly read and analyze a story, please do not request for more than one review (per author) at a time.

5. Please submit your application as a comment below.

 

| REVIEWERS

 

 

Reviewer: secretseven

Status : Available

What kind of reviewer are you?

I am a generally nice, and I do care about your feelings. During my editing courses in university, my professors have always called me a rather conscientious editor, meaning I work with writers with great respect and treat your work as yours. I am, however, very picky, and I will harp on you about your narrative tone and word choices. It might be subjective, but I think it's important to note if you're writing reads awkward.

I am an ESL writer, meaning to say that my English is imperfect, and I have a particular weakness with tenses and preposition. So if you are looking for someone to look at your grammar, this will not be me.

I am a graduate of Bachelor of Communications Major in Professional Editing and Publishing, so you would think I know one or two things about story telling. I also write copy professionally, and working in getting published IRL. I also work for a publishing house as proofreader, first reader, social media and promotions person. I don't know what you'd want to do with these credentials, but I thought you might see that as useful for your consideration.

Rated//Yuri/: All except romanticized abuse**

** If you write about , domestic violence, and any other taboo themes, I expect you to have at least read about these issues and have taken in consideration the psychological consequence of these crossing of socially acceptable or criminal conduct.

Favorite Genres: Fantasy, light, slice of life, psychological, angst (but I am extra picky for angst, your story needs to be not angsty for angst sake)

Pet Peeves: Different coloured-fonts outside black for the body of your story, not capitalizing first letter of your sentences, POV shifts in one chapter, headings of character names (e.g. Sandara's POV, No one's POV), non-regular font for most of the body of your story (bolded and/or italicized everything), romanticized , plagiarized content, adaptation from another story unless it's done really, really good

Time taken per review: 1 month

 

Reviewer: DemiDeveron

Status : Inactive

What kind of reviewer are you?

I am laid back and open minded for the most part. I really value the authors voice, tone, and style of writing so I am not the type to try and change that at all. I also value the author's opinions, diversity, and views, and I always try to take those into consideration when I am editing or reviewing.

I have about 20 years of experience editing for a professional writer, so my reviewing style might not be exactly what people are used to around here as I also incorporate a lot of editing into it. But rest assured, I will still follow the review rubric of the shop and give you the feedback that you're looking for. In addition to that I will also edit the story as I go along, and you therefore have the option of receiving a word document version of your story via e-mail, so it will be easier for you to see my thoughts, notes, suggestions, and corrections. I will do this for all stories I review, but it's optional for the author to receive the full and complete edited version.

I will never change a sentence on you, I will never alter your voice, or your tone while editing, and I will stay true to, and value your individual style when giving suggestions and opinions. It's not my goal to change your story or your writing. My only concern is to help you improve and polish up your works. On that note, I tend to be very thorough (especially with editing), so you can expect lengthy reviews and a lot of comments and suggestions from me.

I consider myself a conscientious, respectful, and assertive reviewer/editor. I try to be as kind as I can during the process. However, I am far from lenient in the way that If I see something that needs correcting, I will point it out no matter how big or small it is. But, not under the pretense of being strict, mean or pushy. I respect the fact that the author has their own idea of how they want their story to be, so my only reason for being thorough in pointing out mistakes is to try and help the author as much as I can by making suggestions that will get the author to think about what needs to be corrected or altered.

Rated//Yuri/: I review everything!

Favorite Genres: Angst, drama, dark, psychological, thrillers, and mystery.

Time taken per review: 1-4 weeks

| REVIEWER APPLICATION

  1. You should write a review of your favourite AFF Story. There are no restrictions to your choice.
  2. Your review should follow this shop's letter format. Begin your review with Dear [writer], and write an introductory paragraph that mainly focuses on what you enjoyed about the story and/or the writer's strengths.
  3. You may choose to use the specified criteria in the Foreword, or choose your own way of organization.
  4. Post your review as a blog post.
  5. Complete the Reviewer Application Form.

 

| REVIEW APPLICATION

Story Title:

Story Link:

Reviewer (please choose one): secretseven (sample) // DemiDeveron (inactive)

Poster/Trailer URL (if available):

Genre:

Brief Synopsis:

Two Chapters you require to be reviewed: (This is in addition to the first 8,000 words I commit to, approximately from chapter 1 to 3 or 4. DO NOT INCLUDE THIS PARENTHETICAL MESSAGE IN YOUR APPLICATION)

Password:

I have allowed TEXT SELECTION in my story for review and understand that I will not earn a grade here. (YOUR NAME)

 

 

| REQUEST STATUS

 

Complete:

If Only You Knew [babylocket] (secretseven)

What A Beautiful Mess This Is [sleepingtodream24] (secretseven)

Allegro: Young Blood and Electric Blue Skies [duoxsoleil] (secretseven)

 

Pending:

 

Waitlist:

 

Rejected:

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
secretseven
Hello! I am reopening this shop. Previous submissions are cancelled as two years changes one's writing style. If you still want to have your stories reviewed, please let me know.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
caleesia #1
Chapter 1: Story Title: Time Is Finite
Story Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/886542/time-is-finite-friendship-romance-sliceoflife-originalcharacter-exo-sehun-jongin
Reviewer: secretseven
Poster/Trailer URL: http://i.imgur.com/CFijKe1.png
Genre: Romance
Brief Synopsis: Lee Arang fears change as much as she says otherwise, as change means growing up and growing up means Sehun and Jongin could leave, for Arang has made Jongin her home and given Sehun her heart.
Two Chapters you require to be reviewed: Chapter 7 and 9
Password: TOPsyturvy
I have allowed TEXT SELECTION in my story for review and understand that I will not earn a grade here. (caleesia)
douxsoleil #2
Chapter 25: So first of all, thank you for giving a lot of time to write this thoughtful review. As I read also in your note in the next chapter, I hope things will get better for you and I actually read this review since this morning, but I personally need to let myself organise my thoughts to give you a proper feedback because I do take critics harshly, but I understand that all the words above are meant for my improvement in becoming a better writer.
For the reviews that you read, I actually didn't really read too much about myself not being placed in the same position with the native English speakers, however I thank you for pointing that out for me. I always pay more attention for the pointers and the flaws I need to improve more than the praises they gave (praises are lovely, but of course what matter truly are the flaws so my story can be improved, also goes the same for my writing).
So, I'm going to give my feedback about the whole sections since there are a lot of questions appearing and I feel the need to explain some points, and I feel that this is one of the ways I can show you my appreciation for this review you have written for me, so here it goes.
mistressdean
#3
Chapter 25: Okay, so I did not read the entire review (I skimmed through the plot section, seeing as I don't want to spoil the story for myself) and focused on the title section and the writing style section (and so forth). I appreciate these long reviews you write because even your ramblings are something to take into consideration. It's like you're acting as both the average reader and the critic. Anyways, as I was saying, this story has been on my radar for some time and I liked the title at first glance, but something about it put me off too. Your review hit the sore spot! As for the rest, I can relate. I tend to get wordy and dwell on ideas for too long. I often have to tone down my unnecessary word choices and whatnot. OTL. Writing IS rewriting. Bless any author who is brave enough to share their work.
vrendezvous #4
Chapter 1: Story Title: i am leaving you
Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1104993/i-am-leaving-you-angst-krystal-romance-exo-kai-jongin-kaistal
Reviewer (please choose one): secretseven
Poster/Trailer URL (if available): -
Genre: romance, angst
Brief Synopsis: Jongin is the rich boy who breaks people’s heart. Soojung is the best friend he shares kisses and blanket with. When the doctor says that Soojung is dying, all Jongin can hear is his father saying: she is not worth of us. “I spend the last ten years defying my father to hang out with low life like you and now you are dying on me? I am not going to throw everything for something that decays so easy.”
It always cross his mind to leave her behind—alone and lonely—before she does the same to him. Both Jongin and Soojung are fighting not to be the one who gets left behind.
Two Chapters you require to be reviewed: it's a oneshot.
Password: TOPsyturvy
I have allowed TEXT SELECTION in my story for review and understand that I will not earn a grade here. (byharu)
dhaatk
#5
Chapter 1:
Story Title: Gehenna
Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/932501/gehenna-angst-jaejoong-mystery-yunho-yunjae
Reviewer: secretseven
Poster/Trailer URL: poster: http://i68.tinypic.com/2wok705.jpg ; trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=91cTASV4lXw
Genre: angst
Brief Synopsis: Kim Jaejoong is not actually human and has been on Earth for far too long. Jung Yunho is his new personal assistant and Jaejoong falls in love for the first time.
Two Chapters you require to be reviewed: 19 and 21
Password: TOPsyturvy
I have allowed TEXT SELECTION in my story for review and understand that I will not earn a grade here. (dhaatk)
mistressdean
#6
Chapter 24: THIS: taking out oppa because "it's annoying" is not a light bulb---it's turning away from cultural implications.
*applauds*
A line that I often see in reviews: "I understand this story takes place in Korea, but since you're writing in English, using oppa (blah blah) is annoying."
douxsoleil #7
Chapter 14: Story Title: Allegro: Young Blood and Electric Blue Skies
Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1096181/allegro-young-blood-and-electric-blue-skies-angst-krystal-romance-seulgi-mingyu-seventeen-wonwoo
Reviewer (please choose one): secretseven
Genre: angst, coming-of-age, romance, psychological, friendship.
Brief Synopsis: Jeon Wonwoo stops believing in everything when the people he thought would always stay, left and slipped away from his fingers. And then Seulgi comes, in the form of feline eyes and fluid movements, beneath the electric blue skies that soon will remind him of her.
Chapters you need reviewed: 1 and 2
Password: TOPsyturvy
What do you think is the strongest point of your story?
My way of writing that is able to picture the innocence of a teenager.
I understand that I will not earn a grade here. (douxsoleil)
Hi there! To be honest, I am using a one person point of view (which I never touched upon as I usually use the third person pov) in my story and I would like to hear your thoughts if I manage to pull it off, and please be honest with me as I hope to become better with your review. Anyway, I hope you enjoy my story at the same time. Thank you!
mistressdean
#8
Chapter 22: "You see narrative techniques often break grammatical rules. But this doesn't mean it's wrong, if you know what you are breaking and you can convince your reader that it's more for effect than from carelessness. This is the difference between a grammatical error and narrative techniques. "

YES. YES. YES. One in a while, I would break my story into fragments as a narrative technique. I had one reviewer point out that they were fragments (obviously) and I was daunted in the face because it was the character narrating how they were choking on milk. So yep, not everyone will like how you write nor will they understand the emphasis you're trying to convey.

Anyways, this chapter was entertaining!