♣ ggaman | review

♣ modern times request shop
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter

Destroy, Missing | ggaman

Title (2/5)

The title is grammatically correct, but I am unable to connect the story's title to the story itself. I don't understand how it relates to the plot. In my opinion, the plot seems to be about creating something, not destroying or having something missing. 

 

Appearance (5/5)

The poster is good, it has the main character (Sehoon), the title and all the other pieces. I like how the crane was added since it seems to be a symbol of wishes or possibilities. I would've suggested adding the EXO members, but it seems like the story will focus more on Sehoon rather than all the other characters you mentioned on the list.

 

Description/Foreword (8/15)

The description was quite interesting, especially the last sentence ("God give me a wrong creature"). Although there are grammatical errors in the description, the last phrase was pretty powerful as if Sehoon didn't think of this girl to be a human being, which made me wonder if he was a snob or was frightened of this girl. Personally, I would put the second part of the description (title, written by, starring, etc.) in the foreword. The first part of the description was a lot more interesting and captivating than the second part.

There's not much to say for the foreword, as they are used for author's notes. 

 

Plot (10/25)

Destroy, Missing focuses on the main character, Oh Sehoon, and his journey in completing making his wish comes true. 

Honestly, I can't really judge the plot. The five chapters hardly progress the story, and if it does, it progresses really slowly (which I'll explain more under the "Flow" section). From the first chapter, I am told of who Sehoon is and what kind of life he lives in (including the kinds of people he socialize with). Other than that, I only see Sehoon progressing very little to the plot. He needs to complete a dare, which is to make 1000 cranes, but he hasn't even made those cranes for the last five chapters. Therefore, he hasn't met the OC, and all he's been doing is hanging out with his friends.

In conclusion, the plot's pretty dull. Nothing much is happening, and the plot isn't moving forward.

 

Characters (5/15)

Since most of the characters didn't really show up or made an impact to the story's plot yet, I'll be focusing on Sehoon.

Oh Sehoon is the youngest among his 11 best friends (the EXO members). He's kingka, and he's happy with his life. Although he's kingka and popular among the ladies, he seems pretty ordinary and weak. From what I see, he seems socially weak and mentally weak, and he's dependent on his friends (like when he couldn't pay for the items he wanted or walking to school with his friends in the morning because he had nightmares at night). He's a pretty static character, but he's determined to complete his dare. That could've shown improvement in this character, but he decides to back down and ask Luhan to help him complete his dare. The plot hasn't progressed much, so I suppose that the character, too, can't progress any further.

 

Writing (Spelling/Grammar/Punctuation) (7/20)

There were a lot of grammatical errors,

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
luqluq
#1
Requested~
dearmonet
#2
Chapter 13: Picked up! Oh my god.. I'm sorry I picked it up late..
Terrachipzx
#3
Chapter 20: Thanks for the review! I'll credit soon when I can get to my laptop.
You really helped a lot and I'll make sure to put your tips to good use! ^^
tofujagi
#4
Chapter 21: Just wanted to let you know that I have picked up my poster! Thank for making this poster for me; I'm really loving it! ^_^
-natsukim #5
Chapter 21: thanks for all services and good luck for your school! being a senior in high school is surely fun, trust me XD
Lovex2254 #6
Chapter 18: Thanks for the lovely review I will credit when I get on the computer! The thing about Mira agreeing to live with Luhan has to do with the fact that she's not yet 27 and also the fact that it will be revealed that she doesn't really have anywhere else to go. And I do agree that Luhan is a weak character at this point, but I did want it to seem like he isn't doing anything good for Mira because I wanted him to be portrayed as not knowing what to do to help her and being unable to do so. I was trying to show exactly that he thinks he understands her because they've been through so much together but he really knows nothing. Again, thanks so much for the review!
xaoieu
#7
Chapter 16: OMG THIS IS BEYOND PERFECTION ;A; I LOVE IT SOO MUCH <3
Thank you and sorry this re-do, authornim.
myheartswishes
#8
Chapter 14: Thanks for the review :) I credited you already. Yeah, I agree with the characterisation part of the more insignificant members since it's really hard to write about 12 members, unless i kill some off which may not be that good an idea, but nevertheless, thanks :)
creamcoloured-
#9
I requested!