#2 If I Had A Lover by Isabella_luvs_shinee

♬ †råñqµïl MêlöÐïê§ Rêvïêw §höþ ♪ [ßusy]

 

Reviewer: tiffusan

The Title: The title isn't very captivating to potential readers. It seems a little bland and cliche. Also, from what I could see, your title and your description/story in general doesn't really match. The title should describe the story, but not give it away totally. (2.5 points)

The Plot: The plot, unfortunately, is something you could easily find in AFF. It's rather cliche and I wouldn't really want to read it as a potential reader. However, I'm sure many people who are looking for a typical romance/drama story would enjoy reading it. (5 points)

The Context: There isn't any descriptions of settings and characters and the majority of the story is just dialogue. This isn't something that you want in a story, so you should probably add some sort of description so the reader can visualize your story better. Also, there is no indication about which character is speaking. The indents and spacing are rather unusual too. (3 points) 

Character Development: Unfortunately, there isn't really any character development present in the story. Perhaps you should incorporate that in future chapters. (3.5 points) 

Plot Development: Like the above category, there isn't a sufficient amount of plot development either. Putting that in future chapters should make your story a little more well-written. (5 points) 

Overall: Kwangmin and Seyong aren't my biases, so this isn't a story I would read AS A READER. As a reviewer, however, I'd say that your story needs some improvements and changes. Hopefully, this review will somewhat help you become a better writer. ^^

Total Amount of Points: 19/50

~☁~

Just wanted to say that having low points doesn't necessarily mean you're a terrible writer and/or your story is terrible. Every writer has room for improvement. It's just that some need it more than others. Anyway, I hope my review will help you in improving your story. Thanks, again, for requesting! :) -tiffusan

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
finbatix
#1
thank you in advance for taking the time to review my story series^^
mizice90
#2
i have request for a review...
lynnryan
#3
Oh yay its done!
33.5/50 huh? Its much better than i thought.
Haha i know i'm not really a good writer and i get that alot.
Even from my language teacher.
But thanks for your honest review! I'm not sad at all, really.
I would love to improve more and i hope i can!
Anyways, thanks again!
Oh and you're welcome! I love loveee your exo shots! Do write more love! ;)
lynnryan
#4
I've requested for a review! ♥
GreenGardenPop
#5
Thanks for the review...
GreenGardenPop
#6
I requested
golferox
#7
Thanks for the review! I'm glad I didn't scare the living daylights out of you :P
KimPossible21 #8
Hi, thank you so much for the review :)
Yes, the character doesnt change much because she'a a young, healthy mother and I want her to be quite stable throughout the story, but she gets to realise and learn new things as the oneshot progresses xD

I wanted someone who hasnt read the original story to review it because I want to know a different perspective. XD
Thank you for doing this again.
Will credit when I get on my laptop.