esoyjin

☼ Perfect Dae Request Shop ☼ [Closed] [revamping]
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
  REVEW
PICK-UP STORY LINK REVIEWER: MIRO-CHAN AUTHOR: ESOYJIN layout credits

Story Title:

I did like the title. It seemed really common at first but after I read the story, I liked how you picked this title. Kris' Summer, since this story is about when Kris left which was in the Summer, I thought that it was really basic and not really exciting but like I said, after reading it, I thought it was quirky and quiet cute in the way. Summer can be referred as the girl he met and it's like telling the reader that it was someone he felt special towards and then after that in brackets was 'Goodbye Summer' which is him leaving her. I don't really know how to explain this well but it's mixing two things together yet they're the same such as Summer = season Kris left, name of the girl he met, Goodbye Summer = he's not going to return to where he met her after Summer, telling the girl he can't get attached to her. I liked how you planned out the title and I thought overall, it suited the story.

Graphics:

At first, reading the title and description, I didn't find the poster relatable to the whole story but when I actually read it, I felt like it did. It was summer yet the met at the night and that's what you're trying to explain thought the poster. The poster is simple and minimal and there's basically 4 things in the whole poster: Kris, Summer (April), the background and the title w/ the designer aka you. There's little things such as the triangle and possible filters but not really much happening which can be a good thing. I don't really think you could add anything onto that and it does describe the story well.

The cropping of characters aren't really done well but it's not very noticeable other than the legs and such but other than that, it's fine! I feel like you should get a background. Possibly a simple black with some navy blue mixed into it and have bokeh on it with the title but it's really up to you. I just think that if your story is quite angst, gore or sad, it should have some type of background to help create more of an atmosphere while reading the chapters if you don't put the poster within the chapter but it's really up to you. Many don't like having posters on their story and sometimes it's not really needed so it really depends if you want any background to be in the story! :D

Description/Foreword:

I liked how you did take a bit from the one shot and put it within the description or possibly the other way around but it did let us see into the story a bit. From

Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
wonpokemon
sorry for those that did not receive your requests!! 15.04.03

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Maddymoonchild
#1
Hi. Umm...I requested a graphic almost a month ago but have yet to receive anything. I requested on December 18 and the status list says I was accepted for the request. I was just curious as to the status of it.
snapshot97
#2
Chapter 17: thanks for the poster! whoo! i thought you guys are giving up on my request HAHAHAHA bt anyway it's fine it's really cute! thanks again. i'll be using it once i get a hold of my laptop :))))
suzyelf
#3
Chapter 14: Thank you for the review! I wasn't aware that graphic has that much of an effect, I'm not sure about that..
Hephaistos
#4
Chapter 13: Oh, also, I almost forgot. I'm not the one who made the poster and so I unfortunately don't know first thing about editing pictures and stuff, meaning that I sadly don't know what you mean. Do you know any adequate postermaker who would be able to produce what you're explaining in your description? Or would you be able to produce/show an example of what you mean? Then I could request it somewhere, and hopefully have it made soon. I want to improve my story as much as I can, graphics included!
Hephaistos
#5
Chapter 13: Oh dude thank you so much. I've been waiting for a review that will truly give me something to improve and that I can change for the better, so getting this makes me feel great. I agree with all of what you said, especially the narrative perspective. I started out with it and now I hate it (I have my reasons as to why though), but people have been telling me to stick with it. I'll make sure to change it as soon as I have the ability to.

Also, the grammar section is really good, I've been needing someone to point out my ty mistakes and to give me tips on how to handle English better. It's not my first language, but I'd say that's exactly why I need to improve.

I want to rewrite the story altogether, and dropping some subtle hints is a part of that process that I'll go through with great care for detail. I want it to become as good as possible, and I completely understand and agree with me having some problems that need fixing.

I'm very happy that you liked the story, I have an ending coming up that will hopefully blow some minds, and with this constructive criticism in mind I can make it even better. A great, big thanks to you for taking the time to review this, well worth the wait! I'll cite you in my foreword asap. :)
btsnodank
#6
Chapter 10: I've picked up, thanks so much for the lovely review :)
IMeMyandMine #7
Chapter 12: Picking up!
Thank you for the review I'll credit once I get onto my computer later.
KimmyNurry
692 streak #8
Chapter 11: Picking it up~
thnk u ^_^
ur not rude, ur criticism would help me improve a lot in the future :)
Hephaistos
#9
Chapter 3: Hey, I requested a review almost a month ago, I was just wondering what's up. Let me know if there is something wrong.