Review ► TheLandOfBrownSugar

Imaginations Poster and Review Shop [ BATCH 1 CLOSED | HIATUS ]

 

BEHIND THE MASK

by : TheLandOfBrownSugar

Title: [2/5] I really don't like mainstream stuff and I think the title is kind of too main stream, I've seen dozens of stories with a similar title. It's also not very interesting and attractive. I might only check out the story if it's a ship that I really like if it isn't, I'll maybe just pass it.

Graphics: [4/5] The poster was great, it has the right feels of the story, your layout is simple and readable, nice, and neat.

Foreword & Description: [7/10] Your description is fine, it doesn't reveal too much but, really straight to the point of the story. The description only made me a bit craving too know more but, overall it was nice. Foreword is plainly author's note and credits, nothing much.

Plot: [15/20I think the story seemed main-stream. In the first chapter I thought it was going to be like the typical quiet guy and popular girl love fan fic.The plot gets more interesting and the last chapter's plot twist is pretty interesting, I did expect that a bit thou. A cliche with a twist, it's still cliche. But hey, things like these never get old and you made a cliche better. Great job.

Characterization: [7/10] I could feel the character's emotion . I can feel both character's loneliness which they hide in different ways. By being an attention and a scary quiet guy. I also like how Sunny and Hoya's character has similarities in different ways. If you get what I mean. Still, these kinds of characters who hide who they really are is pretty often found in fanfics.

Originality: [6/10] I give you half because the plot is like cliche but, one extra point for you for making it a tiny bit interesting.

Flow: [9/10] Your flow is amazingly steady. Even though it's really short, all the chapters connect perfectly. It's also very perfectly paced. Plainly great.

Grammar & Spelling: [13/20] I do see some spelling and grammar mistakes. Some are not really that noticeable  Some are irritatingly noticeable, also making me distracted from the story. And it's not much of a surprise since English is not your first language. Some of your choice of words don't fit perfectly. Then again, it's still readable and not that bad.

Overall Enjoyment: [4/5] I liked it. Even though it's really short and all. A bit cliche, but you made it more interesting. Then again still kinda boring. Add the fact that I love one shots. So, I enjoyed it overall.

Bonus points: [5/5] 

Final Points : [72/100] Your points aren't maximum just because the story is a bit too cliche. Still, I believe you would write better stories in the future if you practice well and be more creative with your plot. Thanks for requesting for a review. I hope I wasn't too harsh and I hope I helped you with your story. 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
DorkyBubbleTea
Random Dork Poster and Review Shop is now Imaginations Poster and Review Shop with layout changes and more!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
ErinKrystal
#1
Chapter 7: I'm sorry for the late comment... *bow
Thank you very much for the honest review, really appreciate it! :D
prisjones
#2
Chapter 15: Hi I'm sorry about your laptop, I wouldn't mind waiting as I am using another poster from another shop that I requested before from you. I will use that from the time being and when you finally get a new laptop I will use the poster you will make, if that is alright with you??
hotLover5
#3
Chapter 15: I'm sorry to hear that your laptop were broken..You can cancel my request..I didn't want feel burden..I will request once again..Don't worry you a great reviewer..=)
haeimecah
#4
Chapter 15: I am terribly sorry to hear about your laptop. I hope it get fixed soon. My story is for a competition which ends in April, so I would like to cancel my request. Maybe I'll request again for my other stories. :)
Se_Min
#5
Chapter 15: I'm so sorry about hearing that your laptop were broken..
I guess I have to cancle my request because the competition ended on May.
I will request again once you get you new laptop ^^ Fighting !!
PandaSnoppy
#6
Chapter 1: hey im srry can i cancel my request?? since im deleting my fanfic
cactus_dream
#7
Chapter 15: Thank you for the announcement and sorry for ur broken laptop..

And i think i'm cancelling my poster request..bcause it's too long for me to wait till May or June and yes i'm afraid that my story gonna end if i wait for u..
It's really nice to stop by here and have a nice author like u..
Thank you and hwaiting!!! ^^
miniflash
#8
Sorry can i still cancel my request? because i'll need to to delete my fanfic, sorry if i'm late