Corner to Corner Graphic Reviews

Description

Intro: Hello everyone.  This is –MIBbustin here to help you improve on your graphic skills.  If you don’t see me fit to review your graphics then don’t request a review from me.  I do real talk and if you don’t and can’t handle stuff like this then you may leave.

Who: Who am I to review your work?  I’m not an expert with graphics, heck I don’t even make graphics but I am a graphic viewer who knows what’s good and what’s not.    I sub to A LOT of graphic threads and as a viewer I come across a lot of graphics that aren’t that great.  I don’t leave comments on threads because it’s not needed.  My opinions can be kept to myself and that’s what I like to do. But if you request for my opinion then best know that my opinion is going to be real , no sugarcoating, and no miss nice.  It’s real talk, and that’s what I’m about.  If you have the balls and can handle a strong opinion then come and request.

What: I don’t just criticize your work; I also give a mouthful of tips, what’s a review without tips?  I also don’t do short reviews, my reviews are LONG so be prepared to read your eyes out when you request from me.  My reviews are said to be helpful from past requestors so I hope you will find them helpful also.

Why: Why did I start to review graphics?  I started because I wanted to help local AFF designer’s improve, we can only improve with opinions and guidance from others.

 

 

01. Sub to shop before requesting.
02. Comment before and after requesting.
03. Do not request more than twice at a time.
04. Bash but no cursing.
05. Must have more than two months of experience before requesting a review.
06. Fill the form with details, DO NOT skip anything on the form.
07. Read everything on your review.
08. Improve your graphics before re-requesting.

 

 

 

First look: (What I think of the poster, -quality -theme -overall impression) (10/10)
Photos: (Does it compliment the theme or contradict) (15/15)
Mood/theme: (Did you get a hold of the theme/mood that you wanted) (15/15)
Blending/Cropping: (Messy? Good?) (10/10)
Resources: (Any textures, PSD. Did you use them correctly?) (20/20)
Composition: (Does the photo placement look okay?) (10/10)

Fonts: (Does it go well with the overall poster?) (5/5)
Quality: (Is it appealing? Is it good enough to use?) (15/15)
Side Comments: (This is the section where I will give me comment, review aside)

 

 

Foreword

 

01. dream-
02. BunniesOnTheMoon
03. Creamysmiles
04. Aravis223
05. INFINITEaddict193
06. Goodlynlyn
07. shineecrazed 
08. jess-for-you - Graphic
09. Hiirah - Graphic
10. MisyaDW - Graphic
11. star_x - Graphic
12. AienaFieka97 - Graphic
13. J-oanL - Graphic
14. ing - Graphic
15. gray-- - Graphic
16. BunniesOnTheMoon - Graphic

 

 

 

 


Requests CLOSED

 

 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
teaquiIa #1
would you like to be an affies? c:
a graphic review shop, `( gleaming sunset; www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/243077
star_x #2
Nope.i dont want to change my graphic.^^ just take ur time ok.
smolder
#3
Chapter 8: Thank you for taking the time to review my graphic! I agree with everything you said. Originally, I had desaturated Yuri and put a layer I filled with a light shade of blue on top of everything, and set the blend mode to "Color" (or "Hue", I forgot o.o) to kinda integrate the poster, but looking back, it does make it look dull and monotone. I can't download fonts on my computer for some reason, but I'm sure I definitely could've made a better choice with the typography.
Again, thank you for reviewing this graphic! I'll definitely take your comments and suggestions into account for my future posters.
-melonfreak
#4
Chapter 5: Thank you so much!~ ^^
Yay, I got higher! :)
goodlynlyn
#5
Chapter 6: Thank you for the honest review ^^ I might post it on my portfolio and I'll definitely request again
exovevo
#6
I requested ^__^
ing
#7
requested for a review~
take your time :)
smolder
#8
I'm really sorry to say this, but is there any way I could change the graphic being reviewed? If you haven't started already, that is. It's just that I feel like I've somewhat improved, and I myself have caught a lot of mistakes in the graphic I requested for (like the girl's body being transparent LOL)
So if it's okay, could I change the graphic?

Sorry for the inconvenience!
-Jester
#9
Chapter 4: Thanks for the review ^^
I feel that your review is spot on. Since this is an older design that I did, as i look back at it I find that I didn't really do a good job at it. I was kinda ignorant at the details I guess. I hope I improved in the next graphic that I request from you :]
BunniesOnTheMoon
#10
Chapter 4: Are you still taking requests or are you spots full?