Review for shineecrazed

Emerald Star Shop™ [CLOSED]

The Proposal review by Shiningstarstruck

 

 

Title: 4/5

For me, your tittle suit the story but it is better if the title was "The Proposal Day" or "That Proposal Day".

 

Foreword/Description: 7/10

You should make your description a bit longer and give a bit more information about the story but not so obvious. Your foreword was nice, neat and beautiful. I don't have any problem reading it.

 

Poster/Background/Trailer: 3/10

The poster was not that attractive. You should request a poster and background from a graphic shop. It will makes your story more attractive.

 

Storyline/Originality: 7/10

I like your imagination and the story line also great. At first I thought that Myungsoo would die or the girl cheated on him but not. It was the girl who would die. So far I didn't read any fiction like that so yours are the first. ^^ And I like angst story.

 

Grammar/Spelling: 10/10

There's no grammar mistake and spelling mistake that I found. Congrats!

 

Entertainment: 3/5

It is entertaining and I had so much fun reading it. 

 

Writing Style: 7/10

Your writing style is great but not that attractive. 

 

Total: 41/60

 

Story Link

Keep up the good work.


-18 Oct 2012 ; 5.50 p.m-

 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
mother-chucker
#1
Wahh~~ daebak!
EXOHunHanRis
#2
Applied as a reviewer~~ ^-^
Srikandi
#3
Sorry if it's too late. I want to cancel my request. Sorry....
Srikandi
#4
Sorry if it's too late. I want to cancel my request. Sorry....
Srikandi
#5
Sorry if it's too late. I want to cancel my request. Sorry....
Srikandi
#6
Chapter 1: http://www.asianfanfics.com/blog/view/353287

Hello~ This is my graphic application form
marygo #7
can i ask you something ? maybe do you made posters for fanclubs out of asianfanfic ?
Kaosuhime
#8
Chapter 1: Applied as reviewer :)
silentraven
#9
Chapter 37: thanks =D picking it up again =D
silentraven
#10
Chapter 24: Hi~ I'm sorry but I didn't notice it XD I have a co author in my story do you mind placing her name too in the poster please ? =) I'm sorry I forgot