SiwonsGirl96 | Did It Mean Anything To You?

♥♥ SummerChild Review Shop ♥♥ [CLOSED! - Sorry because I'm too busy with the graphics shop! :( ]

 

Did It Mean Anything To You?

 

Title: 2/5

Your title was too long. A title is supposed to be eye catching and short, and enough to explain some part of the plot, but not enough to explain what the whole story is about. The title should also be reeling the reader into the story. It didn't do any of these things to me. It was too long, and it was uneccessary to add 'YeWook Twoshot' in the end. You could've just tagged it, which you did, so you really didn't need it in the title. 

 

Appearance: 15/15

I honestly loved the poster. I really liked how happy the characters were, like in the ending. Your font was readable, and it wasn't an eyesore. The colors were simply perfect for the story. Great job to the designer, Ayomie. 

 

Characterization: 9/10

I really liked the characters. I liked how Yesung grew from being an insensitive person to a person who realized Ryeowook's true feelings. Even though I'm not an ELF, I enjoyed the story a bit more than I enjoy my biases stories (coughBAPcough). You were consistent with your characters, and even though there were only two chapters, the change of Yesung's heart was not surprising, which is a good thing. 

 

Foreword: 10/20

You used the foreword as an author's note. I ask you, why? The description was perfect! I was completely drawn to the story, and I really loved how fluffy it was! The foreword though..../sobs. You could've just put a line or two in the foreword, and I'll be as happy as Kyuhyun when he plays Starcraft. 

 

Storyline/Plot: 20/25

I haven't read twoshots like this one, so great job in being unique. There was no definite storyline, since there were only two chapters, but I get the main idea. Yesung does something involuntary. Yesung apologizes to Ryeowook. Ryeowook accepts Yesung's apology. A reader has to know at least the main idea, and you succeeded in that area. Good job. 

 

Writing Skill/Technique: 9/10

"Now Sunggie, watch and learn. 'Cause you're about to lose like you've never lost before." 

Correct: "Now Sunggie, watch and learn because you're about to lose like you've never lost before." 

 

You can't start a sentence with a conjunction. A conjunction connects words, phrases and clauses. It does not start a sentence. 

 

Stupidness

Correct: Stupidity

 

Other than that, i haven't found any grammatical or spelling errors. Good job in editing your fanfiction! 

 

In expressing your characters, you were very descriptive. It was easy to picture Kyuhyun playing Starcraft, Yesung's hurt face and Ryeowook's smile. 

 

>> Total Score: 65/100

 

 

 

Note: Do not forget to credit to us!

Copy and paste this onto your FOREWORD! Review by Summerchild Review Shop

Thank you for requesting.

 

 

- Reviewer: Ram | Summerchild

4th of Sep, 2012 -

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Inspirit7_love #1
- Username: Inspirit7_love

- Story name + link: The Twisted Path of Love --- http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/260874/the-twisted-path-of-love-chunji-infinite-romance-suzy-teentop-woohyun-you

- Genre: Romance

- Number of chapters you've posted:6

- Anything else?: Please be honest ^^ . You may take your time ^^ Thanks a lot :)
FxGenerationLover
#2
- Username: FxGenerationLover

- Story name: Tiffany

- Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/263991

- Genre: Drama,

- Number of chapters you've posted: Three

- Anything else?: I want an honest opinion, and if you can please help me improve ^^ thank you :)
SadisticSinner #3
Oh thank you ^-^ It rly helped me alot <3
eusiah
#4
Username: unblurthefuture

- Story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/245841/1/back-pain-fluff-oneshot-exo-lay-suho-sulay

- Genre: fluff,

- Number of chapters you've posted: oneshot

- Anything else?: any advice for me to improve? :) Thank you.
SadisticSinner #5
- Username: SadisticSinner

- Story link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/245849/author-s-pet-2min-fluff-jongkey-onew-shinee

- Genre:,comedy,fluff

- Number of chapters you've posted:4

- Anything else?: I want my fic to be reviewed strictly and also if it's possible, I want some advices of how can I improve my writing skills and at what I lack the most. Thank you ^-^
kyouyas
#6
- Name / Nickname: Ram

- Profile link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/152337

- Have you ever written any fictions? (It's okay if you haven't): YES

- Have you ever been a reviewer before? (It doesn't matter if you haven't): YES

- What genre do you want to review the MOST? (Angst / Romance / Horror / Comedy / Drama / Sliceoflife /...): Fluff, comedy, romance, angst and drama.

- What genre do you want to review the LEAST?: , amd Yuri

- Are you strict?: I'm pretty lenient, but if the author wants strict, I'll be strict.

- Your own rule:

1. Respect me. If you don't, I'll turn you over to Youngjae from B.A.P to teach you some manners.

2. Credit me. It's okay if you don't credit me in yor story. You can credit me in a blog post if you want, as long as I can see it. If you don't, I'll send Mato Planet's Yongguk on you.

3. Last, but not least, smile. I know you might think I gave you a really harsh review. I just want you to improve. Every writer out there has potential, and I want you to see it. If you're still sad though, You can request from Daehyun to serenade you :)
CloudUnknown
#7
- Username: SiwonsGirl96

- Story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/258983/did-it-mean-anything-to-you-yewook-twoshot-fluff-ryeowook-yesung-yewook

- Genre: Fluff/Two-shot

- Number of chapters you've posted: 2

- Anything else?: Please tell me how I can improve my writing skills...^_^