Comments:  ‹ ETHEREAL › shincom's first girl group / revamped 。

← Back to story

All Comments (249)

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
guisukigwi
#1
Chapter 4: If i were a rich espirit, i would buy all albums. And treasure each and every single one of the albums. Im so weak for girlgroups who do boygroup style like,,,imagine jangmi oppa or alaska oppa singing dancing rapping to bts...im weak. #sorryifitsoundswrong
Each girl has a duet omg ily lena thank you for considering each member of ethereal T^T ♡♡♡ im in tears im emotional
Also im sorry but who are y, wontak, hwanhee and youngmin? Im so sorry i dont know much about boygroups ;_;
guisukigwi
#2
Chapter 3: Aaww my authornim is a certified loonatic :"D i love loona and these subunits wow i see that each girl of ethereal gets to be in 2 subunits? Im,,,wow such talent
guisukigwi
#3
This rebooot wow its like a glow up :0 #sh00k
LostHeaven
#4
Chapter 7: noooooo, please don't discontinue Ethereal ;;
I love this story and it has a lot of potential it would such a waste for it to be thrown away.
I know you must be hurt at the response you've been getting as it seems I'm the only reader that bothers to comment to show you how much I appreciate your work. But please, please don't give up on Ethereal TT
LostHeaven
#5
Chapter 11: I don't even know what to say ;; This chapter, the way you're bringing Ethereal back to life is so goddamn solid, I am in pain because this is just too good to be real!
This chapter, I don't even know where to begin but I really like how you are emphasising Jangmi opinion on there being a leader in Ethereal when there's only four of them and they are all close in age.
Also, I love Meilin x Jangmi moments, especially the one where she touched her cheek to make sure she was real hahaha. However, I think Jangmi thinks to highly of Meilin? Like, she knows Meilin but she only knows a certain part of Meilin because despite being friends Meilin still hasn't showed her her flawed side? I don't know how to explain it but it feels like no one truly knows Meilin because she's reserved and secretive.
I died at dem Taeyong and Jangmi moments knowing their relationship will actually come to an end ;; Also, Jaehyun, Meilin is influencing you too much.
I for a second really feared for Kyulbin's life because the cats had vanished. But they ended up just being in the balcony, they were probably dating ^^ And that Illuminati joke though, and Meilin correcting it. Jesus, Meilin really reminds me of Temperance Brennan from Bones!
"They'll think we lost a human" asdfvgbjab lol but Anne and Margaret are pretty names! Just not necessarily for cats but I like how Meilin actually has a reason as to why they are named like that, after Scottish Monarchs (Scotland pride right there haha)
DaKyu is sailling, they are roommates, I'm expecting a lot of moments between them ;; also MeiMi
Will you be altering every single thing or only things you didn't like? For example, will you keep Kyulbin's knee injury or will you take it out? I'm very curious.
say_the_name
#6
ARE YOU SERIOUS??!?? I COME BACK TO A REBOOT LMAO YESSSS
So hyped, I missed my girls so much omg
guisukigwi
#7
Chapter 4: WOW HEART EYES AT EVERYTHING
Girl crush ethreal will be my favourite ethereal
Boygroup ethereal is important!!!
<3<3<3
guisukigwi
#8
Chapter 3: I SPOT LOONA AND IM NOT OKAY
ahaa i can sense your inner loona fangirl authornim :"D but yaaas for loona!!! ♡♡
Btw have you seen the newest loona mv?? :")
guisukigwi
#9
AAAHH AAAHH WHAT IS THIS IM SCREAMING MY HEAD OFF ASDFGHJKL
i cant wait!! the updates and the new layout looks so good, im in tears. Thank you so much for putting a lot of effort into ethereal lana :^) and aaahh theres still so many chapters i haven't commented yet T.T apologies for my lack of comments :"
LostHeaven
#10
Chapter 4: OMG AUTHORNIM DOES THIS MEAN WHAT I THINK IT MEANS??!??
ETHEREAL WILL EVENTUALLY BE A COMPLETE GIRL CRUSH GIRL GROUP? BECAUSE YEAAAS
But for real though, it would be amazing to see girl groups doing concepts like Bad or Chained Up however, I don't think the public would like it very much :/ which is sad but oh well, maybe SK one day won't be as discriminative as it is now.
I'm also loving the title you gave for the Three Sins installements, I like all the songs that are part of Wrath, Lust and Pride! God this reboot just started but I'm already so excited to see what's coming next!
LostHeaven
#11
Chapter 12: This chapter omg, I swear to God authornim!
Just its title screamed that it would be beyond amazing. This chapter is just so sad tbh, Dajung isn't like the other trainees, she isn't normally skinny (her body wasn't made that way? idk how to explain myself, sorry)
I to be honest cried at the part where Dajung was asked if she thought her body was beautiful and she said no ;; This is even more sad because that's what perhaps most female idols and even male idols have to put up with to fit the crazy beauty standards.
I loved this, the background you gave to Dajung's eating disorder is really well-written and it makes me look forward for future updates tbh ^^
guisukigwi
#12
Chapter 3: New subunits yes!! And there's loona aaaahh ♡
guisukigwi
#13
oh my lord a new layout!! ♡♡♡ it looks so pretty!! im gonna miss the old one :"D
guisukigwi
#14
Chapter 32: Im gonna tattoo espirit in my forehead :"D
And wow the colours are so cute!! Again, lena, you and your amazing editing skills. I am so touched, touched at how much time and effort you put into editing the pictures. Thank you, lenaa
guisukigwi
#15
Chapter 31: Im on my mobile so i zoomed my screen in and holy...did you...edit the albums omg...theres like ethereal in it and im in tears why did i just notice it now wow
Can i save all of the individual teasers that you made lena? :"D if its your copyright then its alright!!
guisukigwi
#16
Chapter 29: Lenaaa i am so sorry i havent been commenting in the longest time. School's been busy so yep :" but anyways lets get to commenting! ♡
For the past few chapters, i notice how you get better and better in writing. Like,,,the way you intertwined the characters and beautiful descriptions got my heart melting.
5 am wow thats hella early :0 but here where i live 5 am is the time i wake up for school ahaha so im used to it. Oh my lord, how does one sleep with eyes open? :0 thats unique. Aw poor dajung, i wonder when shes going to tell ethereal about her condition. I can only hope that dajung will be okay. :" uri main vocalist...
Wow i guess ethereal will be more active in social media, hopefully there will be more espirits. Meilin the coffee queen, i know meilin knows that too much coffee is not good, but pls meilin dont drink too much coffee :< ahahaha that shade jangmi threw at meilin though xD
Meilin the musical prodigy. Get that royalty meilin *fist bump* ethereal is so full of talent wow, even meilin's better than wendy :0 and holy mamamoo is very very talented in singing and this only means that ethereal is hella talented. Asffgjkl lena dont praise kyulbin shes gonna be all bashful and melt xD ah the girls are all underweight :( hopefully they'll gain more weight later on. I hate the fact that kpop idols must undergo a mandatory diet, just to please fans. The industry should prioritize health instead of beauty. And wow i never knew one of these nights actually portray different types of mental illness? :0
Moving dorms hooraaay ~~ \^o^/ and wow the rooommates ahaha the two ice citizens unite!! Will there be a changing of roommates?? Like say meilin and jangmi became roommates for like..a week ?? before switching roommates again. But if theres none then im okay with it
ioi dorm?? Wanna one dorm?? Omg imagine waking up and going outside the door and bumping into sohye :") i would do anything to see sohye (but not in a creepy sasaeng way).
Wohoo i cant wait for the new chapters!! <3 ah yes weki meki's song is a bit...yep but at least they debuted :") whos your weki meki bias?
LostHeaven
#17
Chapter 33: Destiny is such a great song ^^ I love how the album is beyond dreamy in all honesty.
I'm looking forward to the future chapters that will be put up for their first ever comeback ^^
LostHeaven
#18
Chapter 32: O M G
You gave Ethereal official color omg I'm 101% shook over them! They are so pretty, light mulberry is gorgeous and I'm sincerely in love with it! I feel like it really matches Ethereal and the pale blue as well! They are pretty colors and you matched them well! And of course, the girls' fandom name is beyond amazing!
I guess you chose it because the fans are Ethereal happiness and vice versa!
LostHeaven
#19
Chapter 31: I still can't get over the fact that you edited the teaser photos for Ethereal's 2nd mini album!
They all look so good ^^
Sica_Sicachu
#20
Chapter 30: You edited everything in Ethereal so beautifully!
I was afraid that you would alter every single thing when you first announced that you would be re-writing every single chapter of Ethereal but you still kept its key points and that is such a good thing! All you did was improve what was already good! Great job author nim ^^
I'm looking forward to what Ethereal may offer in the future!