*Insert idol name* can't sing!!!

 

I see this everywhere,

 

 

fan calls out *Insert idols name* can't sing live

stan of idol: well have you tried singing and dancing, AT THE SAME TIME? It's hard!!! :((
 

 

This irritates me to no end. like it's not my job to sing and dance cause I'm not an idol? if I was an idol, and I was trained to be an idol, I'd hope I'd be able to sing and dance well otherwise, why am I getting paid to do a mediocre job. 

 

also before you call me out telling me I've never sang and danced at the same time, I have? I was in musical theater, but even though the dancing is a little bit more simplified I still had to sing and dance, AT THE SAME TIME!!! *sarcastic gasping* 

 

It also irritates me cause they'll go to no end to bash other groups, and say they're terrible singers and whatever. If an idol , they . don't be biased just because they're your fave. For me, VIXX is one of my favorite groups, but do I admit sometimes they've had some terrible performances and probably need to work on singing live? Yes I do admit it. Do I admit after how many years SJ has been out only K.R.Y is still their stable vocal line, and everyone else kind of compared to them? Yes I admit it. Do I admit that sometimes SHINees lives sound weird cause one of them is pitchy? Yes, yes I do. 

Just because they're your favorite groups doesn't mean you can't accept tha there are some things they can't do and should improve on. As a fan, if you admit that "oh, maybe they should improve on their singing/dancing" then, they probably will, and they'll practice then.... BAM!!! They've improved cause you helped them. 


*this can apply to life too* 

Bam whutttttt .

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
2yLight
#1
I tried singing and dancing at the same time before for a school project and trust me, at the end of the song, I'm out of oxygen.
Hibernius #2
A lot of anti twice has been bashing twice. like wtf. Can you dance and sing at the same time. Can you sing and dance the best when you're a rookie. Noooooo, f those antis of our fave group.
Minini #3
Preach this. If they can't sing, they can't sing. Being a fan doesn't mean blindly accepting whatever an idol does, be it good or bad.
MissMinew
#4
I just find it a needless argument to get into. Why say "someone can't sing" when that is obviously a lie. Just because they may not be the best, doesn't mean they can't sing at all. It's just needless hatred, it's not even constructive criticism. If it was "today's live wasn't that good as compared to others" then it was legit - but it's not, it never is. It's never "oh, he sang a little out of key today but this member honestly did well today". It's never "this song doesn't really fit their voices". It's always just plain out "XXX can't sing".
I'm not gonna deny that some our better singers than others. And I don't really comment on lives at all because I only have Internet and the quality of a live is just not the same as opposed to when you're actually there, listening live. (I also find fangirl screams so annoying that I really don't want to watch the lives on youtube) But if people actually started talking constructive about my biases voices, then sure as hell, we can talk about them not being perfect. If it's all just senseless hatred, don't expect me to agree on it at all.
chan-sick
#5
Bless.
Once I was called a fake fan for saying that no one is perfect. Apparently real fans have to think that idols are flawless :)))