♕ R E V I E W ♢ 0 0 5 ♕

♕ S I L V A N ♢ E Y E S ♕ A Graphic Review Shop {OFFICIALLY CLOSED}

NAME: Ascending                                                                                                                                                                                                    GRAPHIC SHOP: Misfit Graphics                                                                                                                                                             EXPERIENCE: Couple of Months

First Impression (6/10)

Ngaaw this looks so sad. Definitely has a light angst vibe to it. Did notice a few issues that were a little distracting.

Theme: Light Angst (10/10)

No problems here. Definitely suits light angst.

Composition & Balance (15/20)

In general your composition was fine. There is a balance between images and negative space which is good. I do feel however that some aspects could be slightly positioned better: Yuri is a bit too much to the left. It would be nicer if she was moved more to the middle. The quote next to Kai would look better right in the middle of the white space above his shoulder, as it looks awkward just slightly sitting on him. Also I feel the title takes up too much of the bottom half of the graphic.

Selection of Textures, Stock & Characters (13/20)  

All 3 characters were different. Kai was LQ and a little dark, Kris was HQ and a tad brighter, and Yuri was HQ but had a slight bluish/purplish tint. I'm also not sure that image of Kai. That shadow is a distracting blotch of dark colour, in my opinion anyway. I also think with all the bright colouring and bright white negative space, the top stock image was a little too dark compared to the rest of the graphic. Brighten.

Typography  (5/10)

I didn't mind the font for your quote, but I wasn't feeling the fonts for your title. I think your title takes up too much of your poster and that they're too thin. I think a thicker, more fuller font(s) would have been better.

Colouring  (4.5/10)

Your colouring was probably your main issue. It was the colouring of your characters that let you down. Since they took up majority of your graphic and they all had different colourings, it distracted me too much from fully appreciating your poster. You can adjust colouring through curves, levels etc. or by using textures, but yeah be specifically aware of this.

Use of Techniques (6/10)

Your blending and erasing skills were alright, although I didn't like the way you partially erased Yuri's head. I'm not a fan of that kind of blending.

Overall (6/10) - What are my final thoughts?

Overall, not too bad. For a couple of months, you're definitely on your way. Brush up on your colouring.

TOTAL SCORE: 65.5/100

I hope I wasn't too mean :/ I really do hope that you'll do well in the future :D

(PS: I'm sorry but I only have enough karma to give you and -Jester 30 karma points. I hope that's enough)

Miane27

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
Miane27
SILVAN EYES is officially closed. Byeeee :'(

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
-Jester
#1
Chapter 8: I understand what you mean for the quote and credits font. It's actually the same font as 'Beyond' but I guess it looked weird as a smaller font size. I also see what you mean about adding more color especially since Kai is white overall.
Thank you for reviewing, I really appreciate it ^^
bottleofdreams
#2
Chapter 8: Hihi, thanks for the special mention, I'm honored! ^o^
I really hope you'll re-open this though *pouts*
Btw, the graphic is really pretty! *-*
Ascending
#3
Chapter 7: thank you for the review! i know my coloring still and im trying to work on it. also, i realized after words that i had actually misspelled the title. but i know what you meant by too big of font and the character positioning. im still trying the learn so thank you for your thoughts:) im not so much concerned about karma points so thats fine. hope you'll be able to open this shop back up in the future^^
-dearmydeer
#4
Chapter 6: Thank you so much for the review! I kinda wanted to aim for a simple poster, but I'll change it! ^^
bottleofdreams
#5
Chapter 3: It's such a pity :"(
But it's okay, family is more important anyway ;)
Just hoping that someday you'll comeback and open this again
hoshie--
#6
Chapter 5: Thanks for the review! I'll definetly credit you once i get on my laptop.
I think i'll request here again next time :)
-Jester
#7
Chapter 3: It's understandable, family is more important and I wish you and your family well.
Take care ^^
bottleofdreams
#8
Chapter 2: Wow! Thank you so much! This is the highest score I've ever received so far! And I like your ways of reviewing, it's exactly on the spot. I'll definitely request again from you (maybe not long after this ^^)
And I want to get your permission to copy and paste this review on my blog, I'll credit for sure!
Again, thanks :DD
-Jester
#9
Requested :]
Ascending
#10
i requested^^