//Ntaecola

✔City Lights Review Shop // BATCH ONE CLOSED
Ntaecola || Phaethon; Up In Flames
reviewed by: MiyuChan

 

Title: [15/20]

Though it was definitely eye-catching and intriguing, it was not your own title; also, replace the semicolon with a colon. The 'in' is not capitalized.

 

Foreword/Description: [08/10] 

I would have gave you full points, but the author's note would have looked better in the foreword.

 

Plot and Originality: [15/30]

Since it was not your own idea, half-credit.

 

Language: [06/10] 

There were some problems in your dialogue. Always end dialogue with either a period, comma, exclamation mark, and question mark.

 

Characterization: [19/20]

Good job.

 

Flow: [09/10]

Good job.

 

Total: [72/100]

 

 


If there are any questions, please contact MiyuChan! Thanks for requesting!

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
MiyuChan
[12.11.13] please follow the form COMPLETELY or I will reject your request.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
StarlightSpirit
#1
01. username: StarlightSpirit
02. story title: Your Wish Is My Command
03. story link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/613666/your-wish-is-my-command-fluff-infinite-romance-sunggyu-woogyu-woohyun
04. chapter count: 1 (around 5k words?)
05. rated?: no, but there are slight ual suggestions.
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded? Yes
08. anything else? okay? I do really appreciate constructive criticism as well
yanaera
#2
Chapter 5: Whoa. I'm super glowing right now.
Will reread and brainstorm more compelling titles. Also will figure out a smoother flow...
Thank you very much for the review!!
Jignog
#3
1- Username: DarkAngel1007
2- Story Title: Series of Oneshots/ Drabbles
3- Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/613735
4- Chapter Count: 5+(ongoing)
5- Rated?: Not unless stated
6- Password: the city is peaceful
7- Graded?: No thank you:)
8- Anything else?: Thank you for your hard work^^
vivi2133 #4
01. username: vivi2133
02. story title: Let Me See You
03. story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/612630/let-me-see-you-angst-drama-romance-exo-exom-xiumin
04. chapter count: 7 (ongoing)
05. rated?: no
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded?: yes
08. anything else? Thanks in advance and take your time! :3
yanaera
#5
01. username: yanaera
02. story title: Perfect Fit
03. story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/385872/
04. chapter count: 1 (Complete) (5550 words)
05. rated?: no
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded?: yes
08. anything else? Will take all constructive criticisms with an open mind. Hope it is a good read!
kpopfan3
#6
Chapter 3: Thank you for the review!
Chuchucha #7
Username: Chuchucha
Story title: L.O.V.E
Story link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/605875/l-o-v-e-leejonghyun-jungeunji-apinkeunji-eunji-jonghyuncnblue-jonghyunxeunji

Chapter Count: 5 ( still unfinished)
Rated: -
Password: the city is peaceful
Anything: I don't mind a rude comments, I just hope your comments will give me more motivation to write it. Thank You
lissamary
#8
Chapter 4: I've seen the review! ^^
Ikr the story is so cliche xD
Chuchucha #9
Chapter 3: does the story must be completed?