//GreenGardenPop

✔City Lights Review Shop // BATCH ONE CLOSED
GreenGardenPop || The Twilight of Our Love
reviewed by: MiyuChan

 

Title: [15/20]

Cliche and common; it wouldn't really catch a reader's eye. However, it does connect to your story, and that's the main focus of having a title. 

 

Foreword/Description: [10/10]

How are you doing this to me? I love your description; simple and sweet. Doesn't reveal too much, but it doesn't give too little, either.

Your foreword was also amazing. I loved the poem; full points for you.

 

Plot and Originality: [24/30]

Ugh, the originality was definitely not original; it was so cliche. Really? She gets leukemia? Thank God you didn't make her die at the end, though. 

Even though it was cliche, the plot was okay and you followed it very well.

 

Language: [10/10]

I saw no mistakes. Good job!

 

Characterization: [19/20]

Amazing characterization. Perhaps the flow of their love went a bit to fast? Maybe it's just me.

 

Flow: [07/10]

Again, perhaps the flow of their love went a bit too fast.

 

Total: [85/100]

I enjoyed your story, however, the cliche plot made my happiness go a tad bit down.

 


If there are any questions, please contact MiyuChan! Thanks for requesting!

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
MiyuChan
[12.11.13] please follow the form COMPLETELY or I will reject your request.

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
StarlightSpirit
#1
01. username: StarlightSpirit
02. story title: Your Wish Is My Command
03. story link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/613666/your-wish-is-my-command-fluff-infinite-romance-sunggyu-woogyu-woohyun
04. chapter count: 1 (around 5k words?)
05. rated?: no, but there are slight ual suggestions.
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded? Yes
08. anything else? okay? I do really appreciate constructive criticism as well
yanaera
#2
Chapter 5: Whoa. I'm super glowing right now.
Will reread and brainstorm more compelling titles. Also will figure out a smoother flow...
Thank you very much for the review!!
Jignog
#3
1- Username: DarkAngel1007
2- Story Title: Series of Oneshots/ Drabbles
3- Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/613735
4- Chapter Count: 5+(ongoing)
5- Rated?: Not unless stated
6- Password: the city is peaceful
7- Graded?: No thank you:)
8- Anything else?: Thank you for your hard work^^
vivi2133 #4
01. username: vivi2133
02. story title: Let Me See You
03. story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/612630/let-me-see-you-angst-drama-romance-exo-exom-xiumin
04. chapter count: 7 (ongoing)
05. rated?: no
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded?: yes
08. anything else? Thanks in advance and take your time! :3
yanaera
#5
01. username: yanaera
02. story title: Perfect Fit
03. story link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/385872/
04. chapter count: 1 (Complete) (5550 words)
05. rated?: no
06. password: the city is peaceful
07. graded?: yes
08. anything else? Will take all constructive criticisms with an open mind. Hope it is a good read!
kpopfan3
#6
Chapter 3: Thank you for the review!
Chuchucha #7
Username: Chuchucha
Story title: L.O.V.E
Story link:http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/605875/l-o-v-e-leejonghyun-jungeunji-apinkeunji-eunji-jonghyuncnblue-jonghyunxeunji

Chapter Count: 5 ( still unfinished)
Rated: -
Password: the city is peaceful
Anything: I don't mind a rude comments, I just hope your comments will give me more motivation to write it. Thank You
lissamary
#8
Chapter 4: I've seen the review! ^^
Ikr the story is so cliche xD
Chuchucha #9
Chapter 3: does the story must be completed?