Judging System and Other Consideration

Treat Me a Fic!

Judging System and Consideration

 

  1. I will be honest. I am looking for a story I can enjoy the most. While this may alarm you due to the possible subjectivity (which is inevitable), but my fanficcing experience will (hopefully) let me choose the best story here.
  2. There are generally 3 things I look for in a good fic: plot, characterization, and writing style. I am certainly not the best out there for grammar and stuffs, but good grammars will add up to the writing style factor.
  3. I am aware of the lenience in choosing genre may create a chance for you to 'cheat' this contest (e.g. choosing my OTP and writing a tragedy fic so that my OTP perish and your OTP can end up together). While I do love good angst, but I can see which one of you is having an intent to destroy my OTP on purpose, and which is merely having an intent of writing a heartbreaking wonderfully-written angst for my OTP. I undoubtedly do not mind the latter though.    
  4. As you might be aware of, choosing a less popular pairing from my OTP list will probably increase your chance in winning the best story in that particular OTP category.
  5. Finished/completed stories are prioritized to win the semi-contest. But in a case-per-case basis, I may determine an unfinished story to be better than a completed one. Considerations that I will take into account in evaluating a story:
  • Unfinished story may lack points in plot (because plot is something that I will evaluate based on its whole-package thingie), but if the writer is skillful enough, s/he may have impeccable characterizing characters skill and engaging writing style, and I might choose the latter.
  • Characterization is something you just need to consistently build. But if you're basing your fic on a non-AU one (for example, the setting is the idols' real life), your analysis/intake on keeping the characters in-characters will be greatly taken into account.
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
pinboo
Treat Me a Fic [8/12] - Results and Winners are out!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
forevernever
#1
Chapter 15: Thank you for the goody bag and the award! I'm actually so surprised- I completely forgot I entered! Sorry for the unfinished story, but I'll try to finish it when I'm out of school ;A;
Congrats to the winner! I look forward to reading more of the entries but wow that story is amazing.
vanilla1211
#2
Chapter 14: Omg! Thank you for the supporting awards, honorary mention and the goody bag! You made me a poster too akdlfjs. It's my first time to do this kind of thing (?) and I fangirled all night trying to form a literate reply or anything but I failed. sigh.

Anyway, thank you so much! Without this semi-contest my story won't be there.

Congrats to the winners! All the stories seems so cool and I hope I'll manage read all of them on my Christmas&New year break x)
onigirisama
#3
Chapter 14: Aw! Thanks for the supporting awards and the honorary mention ;0; this is my first time entering a contest and I was so nervous but I'm glad you enjoyed the story haha c: ALSO. Congrats to the winners, just by reading pinboo's blurbs about them already intrigues me!
sooyoungie-unnie
#4
Chapter 12: thank you very much unnie <3
and congratulations to all the winners <3
sparksfly7
#5
Chapter 15: Congratulations to the winners :))

Also can I just say that the posters you made are incredible? How'd you make all those in such a short amount of time?? You're so talented ^^ In writing AND poster-making.
kisoap
#6
Chapter 14: well
kind of just mindblown right now
lkdsghasjkdlfsjdkgalkdsgajskdfsdkj i really wish i had coherency but: thank you so much for holding this contest and congratulations to all my fellow winners! i'm glad you enjoyed my fic ;____;
michyeossuh
#7
Chapter 14: Oh no you didnt!!!! Ohmygaaaaaahd!!!!!! Thank you so much for giving me 3rd place. It really means a lot to me coz you are one of the best authors that exist, imho. Der Marchenclub will be a novel that will always hold a very dear space in my hypothalamus. this is too much for a reaction but honestly, this is the first time I have joined a contest and kyaaaaaaaah!!!!

Im sorry for rumbling. And congrats to all the winners and participants! And to you, too, pinboo dear!!! Great contest!