007. CaitieC

❝macarooooons : reviews : officially re-opened!
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter


 reeeeeview!❞
   ▲ Hi there, sorry for the late review. ><" You know, busy busy busy. XD Anyways, thanks for getting this in. I'll start with the first impression: "Oh, it's really pretty!" because it really is. Everything is put together nicely and cleanly and I really like the positioning. The textures used were not bad either. Tiffany is rendered well - there are no extra white stuff on her edges. She is very HQ too. Overall it's just... nice. XD Very nice. Good job.

I don't like the two biggest roses however (the red one and pink one). Seems like they have to be colored more? Their colors seem duller than the rest, especially the pink one. Maybe a little vibrance or some brightness/contrast adjustments would do the trick.

Next is the text. The font isn't horrible but it's not really "wow!" either. I think it's okay but it's really plain compared to the collage next to it. I felt like there had to be more to it to balance out the whole graphic. As for the quote, it's okay to have it in plain text so I have nothing to complain about that one. XD Uh, what else is there? Oh, your watermark. ^^ Perhaps it would be better to put it at the corner? Because it's kind of on the title. I mean, it's not sinful or something for it to be on the title but usually for simple edits like these, the watermarks are quite hidden and quietly placed in the corner to focus on the edit and technique and texture, colorings, etc.
Please Subscribe to read the full chapter
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
sehununnielol
#1
Chapter 2: ❝ Username: sehununnielol
❝ Graphic link: http://imgur.com/gO3fih3
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: cute
❝ Years of experience: a few months
❝ Extras: Lol idk how to edit pics professionally.. kkk
kim-shoemin
#2
❝ Username: happyasian777
❝ Graphic link: http://imgur.com/je9xkoy
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: Romance
❝ Years of experience: 1 year and a couple of months
❝ Extras:warning: BEWARE OF A REALLY BAD POSTER! I'm really bad at typography so the title is really bad, so I tried to make it simple! So I really hope that you'll talk about that in my review. Also, I know this poster is very simple because I'm not very good at blending. Anyways, looking forward to your review!
lexxxi16
#3
❝ Username: Zinni-
❝ Graphic link: http://i.imgur.com/FUOhN7E.png
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: Happy, Cute
❝ Years of experience: 2 years
❝ Extras: This is just a random poster i made, it's not related to any story at all, just fyi.
AsianNoodles
#4
❝ Username: AsianNoodles
❝ Graphic link: http://i1062.photobucket.com/albums/t496/The-Or/TBWNF.png
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: horror, mystery
❝ Years of experience: 1 1/2
❝ Extras: totally sorry for requesting another one right after I requested >< lol once again on pixlr, and y but I want to see how I can start improving myself! X]
AsianNoodles
#5
❝ Username: AsianNoodles
❝ Graphic link: http://i1062.photobucket.com/albums/t496/The-Or/COM-1.png
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: Mystery, action
❝ Years of experience: 1 1/2
❝ Extras: I actually use neither photoshop nor gimp haha, so the quality is bound to be significantly lower than I could be hehehe. I use pixlr, since my dinosaur of a computer refuses to be compatible with both gimp and photoshop. And take your time! haha!
teenme14
#6
❝ Username: Teenme14
❝ Graphic link: https://24.media.tumblr.com/0f860851171e43a58966b1a275404bb4/tumblr_n6nn8d0S8a1to9q10o2_1280.png
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: Romance, Autumn
❝ Years of experience: 2
❝ Extras: Take your time! ^^
fairykyu
#7
❝ Username: fairykyu
❝ Graphic link: ❝ Username: minideer
❝ Graphic link: http://i.minus.com/iZclbM9eA33gR.gif
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: angst, supernatural
❝ Years of experience: almost 4 months
❝ Extras: Thank you! take your time <333
YOOMESBOND
#8
❝ Username: minideer
❝ Graphic link: http://i.minus.com/iZclbM9eA33gR.gif
❝ Graphic type: Poster
❝ Genre: Romcom, cute
❝ Years of experience: 3 months
❝ Extras: Thank you! And this is heavily inspired by Vanivici.
ChemicalLuvs #9
❝ Username:ChemicalLuvs
❝ Graphic link:http://i1296.photobucket.com/albums/ag13/Dyo_omma/tumblr_mwei3nF5PS1qh1cveo1_500_zps1ec4e173.png
❝ Graphic type: graphic contest
❝ Genre:mystery,action(?)
❝ Years of experience: A year
❝ Extras: My newest graphic contest poster. This is a different style from my usual poster. I do hope I did good for this. I really like your review and hope you mind reviewing another of my poster :))
ChemicalLuvs #10
Chapter 12: Hi! Sorry for the late comment. I just got into internet today. Thanks so much for the review!! I knew the font are off somewhere -.-
I'm glad you didn't think its a complete failure OTL
I'll try to fixed my poster with this :))
Thanks again