Rubric

Sweet Lies Graphic Contest | R1 CLOSED | Judging |
First Impression (15)
 

How does this poster make you feel? Did it make you go 'wow' or have an impact that made you want to stare at the image? Was the poster clear and presented nicely?
 
 
 
Creativity (10)
 
How creative was the poster? Was it different from others? How was the prompt used? Did it blend in creatively and make an impact
 
 
 
 
Unique (10)
 
How unique was the poster, was it original or was it predictable? Has the poster been done before or did you try something new and unusual than most posters?
 
 
Genre (10)
 
Did the genre match the prompt? Can the genre be clearly seen or does a hint of it that stands out? If the prompt didn't have a genre, was there a clear theme or genre created by the designer that could be seen within the poster?
 
 
 
Placement (10)
 
How well do the images go together? Do they look clear/HQ and fitting the poster and genre? Does anything stick out of place? Does something stick out that gives it a positive or negative impact?
 
 
Use of Quote (10)
 
Does the quote stand out? Does it dictate the way the poster turned out or did it make little impact? Does it represent something in the poster or does it stand out mismatched?  
 
Colours/Blending (10)
 
Were the colours appealing to the eyes, was the blending nice and flow throughout the poster. Did the blending match the feel of the poster and the images? How was the lighting? Did it improve your poster or harm the clarity or fuzz/blur the poster making it hard to see the details? Did dark blending/ lighting fit well and make the image enjoyable to stare at?
 
 
 
Understanding/ Interpretation of the Prompt (15)
 
Did the main prompt standout in the poster in a unique way and understanding of what the poster was meant to represent? Was it obvious to see the interpretation of the prompt or did it have a small hint with large impact? Did the prompt look like it was represented well in the poster or was it missed or only slightly visible?
 
 
 
 
Match of font to poster (10)
 
Does the font match the poster? Is it blended nicely, does the colours and style match the poster and genre?
 
 
Bonus (5)
 
Was the bonus used? Did it blend in nicely or not really fit in the poster well? Was it used in a positive way to affect the poster? Was the bonus a main focus or did it get cast aside?
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Overall

 

Overall (100) + (5)

Overall max (105)

 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
DeadRose
Sweet Lies Graphic Contest 2018 R1 OPEN!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
ome_omj
#1
Oh, I'm not sure this option is still available, but I'd like to know my scores after judging has been concluded :D
ome_omj
#2
Chapter 141: My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/264681
The Prompt I Used Was: 20
Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/8992/f/2018/174/d/1/project079___slgc_20_by_omeomj-dcf844w.png
ALL the People My Poster Are: Sehun, Jimin
Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes
Notes: I can't even believe this is my last theme for SLGC... :( this was such a fun journey
ome_omj
#3
Chapter 141: My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/264681
The Prompt I Used Was: 19
Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/2af1/f/2018/174/9/a/project078___slgc_19__wj__by_omeomj-dcf83iy.png
ALL the People My Poster Are: Jiho
Did I Use the Bonus?: yES
Notes: Jiho with dreads, oh my dude, I never got over this era
ome_omj
#4
Chapter 141: My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/264681
The Prompt I Used Was: 18
Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/10d6/f/2018/174/d/a/project080___slgc_18__lj_rj__by_omeomj-dcf82qc.png
ALL the People My Poster Are: Renjun, Jieun
Did I Use the Bonus?: no ( animation, ugh, end me with a plastic spoon k thanks)
Notes: this might have been one of the hardest (creativity-wise) but most fun posters i have ever done... i really really love the whole steampunk concept
-kkumie-
#5
Hello! I'm entering again :3

My Username Is: -kkumie-

My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1510486

The Prompt I Used Was: 14

Poster Link: https://i.imgur.com/aOhSdgo.png

Blog Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/blog/view/1256844

ALL the People My Poster Are: BTS jimin & Oc. *actually, is it okay to use an oc?*

Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes *but i'm not sure if there's a lot red. feel free to move the bonus away*

Notes: I'm quite lacking T T

Password: Blackie
stonee
#6
My Username Is: stonee
My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1726552
The Prompt I Used Was: Prompt 4
Poster Link: https://i.imgur.com/5cnul1u.png
Blog Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/blog/view/1256317
ALL the People My Poster Are: Ravi VIXX
Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes
Notes: I went with voodoo-ish vibe by changing ravi into a voodoo doll, which is why his face is a mess
Password: tannie
JiaAera
#7
My Username Is: JiaAera

My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/1547714

The Prompt I Used Was: #6

Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/9617/f/2018/154/d/3/sl_prompt_six_by_jiaaera-dcdd9e0.png

Blog Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/blog/view/1255520

ALL the People My Poster Are: Irene

Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes

Notes: Hello! I'd like to withdraw my previous entry and apply for the 6th prompt with this one. Irene was made to look like a lifeless mannequin (black, empty eyes, white, plastic-like shiny skin). I've decided to write the hangeul part of the title myself, so I hope it's depictable.

Password: Bastille
ome_omj
#8
Chapter 141: My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/264681
The Prompt I Used Was: 17
Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/f9eb/f/2018/153/7/5/project075___slgc_17__sj_bg__by_omeomj-dcdasf3.png
ALL the People My Poster Are: Gain, Narsha, Donghae, Heechul
Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes
Notes: uuuuuuh i tried using targets and etc to make it more obvious they were all 'dead' but it made the edit super confusing so I'm hoping the way it turned out makes it clear enough
ome_omj
#9
Chapter 141: My Username Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/264681
The Prompt I Used Was: 16
Poster Link: https://orig00.deviantart.net/611a/f/2018/147/8/a/project073___slgc_16__jk__by_omeomj-dcco6qv.png
ALL the People My Poster Are: Jennie
Did I Use the Bonus?: Yes
Notes: I'm not a big BP fan but Jennie is very photogenic so I tend to fall back to her pictures as resources