Rubrics

2012 AFF SHINee AWARDS {reviewing}
hey shawols 
judging process/rubrics
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
___________________________________________________________

INFO.
Story title:
Story link: 

Author:

Category Chosen: 

Critic/Judge:



BASICS
Title: 5/5 (Can it grab someone’s attention?)
Description/Foreword (Prologue): 5/5 (Can it spur someone to read on?)

 

NARRATIVE STRUCTURE
Overall flow: 15/15
(Does the sequence of events fall together nicely? Or do things seem too abrupt? How do certain actions/events lead to the development of the plot?)

 

PLOT
Creativity/Originality: 15/15 (Is the story a cliché, or does it have innovative ideas?)
Characterisation: 15/15 (How are the characters indrocued in the story? Is their appearance too abrupt? How well does each character match the theme of the story?)

 

WRITING STYLE
Narrative Flow: 10/10 (How are the sentences/paragraphs constructed? Do the words flow with each other? Or do the sentences seem choppy or abrupt?)
Grammar/Punctuation: 10/10
Vocabulary: 10/10

 

OTHERS
Relation to the category it is nominated for: 10/10 (How does the story, or specific elements in the story, relate to the category it is being nominated for?)

Overall Enjoyment: 5/5 (Did the judge enjoy reading this story? Does it seem to satisfy the other readers?)

Judge’s Comments:


TOTAL: 100/100

 

 
 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!
lucky21
{shinee.awards} Judging rubrics have been posted~

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Shawol_and_ARMY
#2
Chapter 7: Title: The Chase
Unrated
Minho (adventure as main character with little to no romance
Link: https://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/141372/
Shawol_and_ARMY
#3
Chapter 2: Just found this today and was wondering when the results come out! Thank you for hosting this! If judges are still needs or If we can still nominate please let me know!
Tykkii #4
Chapter 6: Hi so when can we start grading? I'm so sorry if I am pestering you. Do tell me if you need any help managing this! Feel free to ask okay? :D
2am-ramen #5
Hey main admins!! Um, I changed my username ^^
Wallflower606* is now yozora-hoshi. So you might wanna update the judges page :D

sorry for the trouble ><
Isadora_Quagmire
#6
Chapter 1: So... No OT5?
2am-ramen #7
Chapter 1: and... ahahahahahaha *totally shocked*
what happened to you people ._________."
I mean, does no one ship the SHINee members with OCs?!!!!!
Is it only , , all the way these days? 8_8
2am-ramen #8
Chapter 11: Woah :I I checked up on the rubrics again today, and is it just me, or did you remove a few criteria? :O~