Rubrics
2012 AFF SHINee AWARDS {reviewing}
INFO.
Story title:
Story link:
Author:
Category Chosen:
Critic/Judge:
BASICS
Title: 5/5 (Can it grab someone’s attention?)
Description/Foreword (Prologue): 5/5 (Can it spur someone to read on?)
NARRATIVE STRUCTURE
Overall flow: 15/15
(Does the sequence of events fall together nicely? Or do things seem too abrupt? How do certain actions/events lead to the development of the plot?)
PLOT
Creativity/Originality: 15/15 (Is the story a cliché, or does it have innovative ideas?)
Characterisation: 15/15 (How are the characters indrocued in the story? Is their appearance too abrupt? How well does each character match the theme of the story?)
WRITING STYLE
Narrative Flow: 10/10 (How are the sentences/paragraphs constructed? Do the words flow with each other? Or do the sentences seem choppy or abrupt?)
Grammar/Punctuation: 10/10
Vocabulary: 10/10
OTHERS
Relation to the category it is nominated for: 10/10 (How does the story, or specific elements in the story, relate to the category it is being nominated for?)
Overall Enjoyment: 5/5 (Did the judge enjoy reading this story? Does it seem to satisfy the other readers?)
Judge’s Comments:
TOTAL: 100/100
Comments