☁ c a l l i n g : shineecrazed ☁

☁ d r e a m i n g i n t h e c l o u d s ☁ review shop [ⒸⓁⓄⓈⒺⒹ]

 

☁ Title [10/10] : Your situation is very mutual to the alternative ending in the actual. Well Done. 

 Appearence [4/5] : Your poster is only revealing to the original and not the alternative ending, so I you're just one mark off from a perfect score. Next time, try to make your poster mutual if you're going to make an alternative ending or have a seperate poster. 

 Foreword & Description [18/20] : Both foreword & description were very well written and neatly organized. But I feel like the description should be your foreword and your foreword should be your description. Make sense? Haha. What I'm saying is what you wrote in the foreword is giving information about the story in a "report" sort of fashion. While your description is an insight of your story in  just a few words, which is what a foreword is supposed to be. 

 Characterization [10/10] : I read opinions on Myungsoo's inner personality and you portrayed his soft side really well in both stories. His love for Juhee is very sweet, almost as if there could possibly be an "infinite" love. Well done, very well done.  

Originality [9/10] : Originally, I thought to give you a prefect score because I've never read a story where the lover has killed his/her lover. But than there was the alternate which was not really original except the peas thing which I thought was adorable. 

 Plot [15/15] : I enjoyed both plots very well. Your angst is a bit more likeable (in my opinion) than your fluff. It's good that you're trying new things though. 

 Spelling/Grammar/Punctuation [15/15] : Perfect.

 Flow [15/15] : It flows naturally which makes the story easy to understand and read.

☁ TOTAL : 96/100 

 

Verdict

A very well written stroy that portrays Myungsoo very accurately.The love between Myungsoo and the Juhee is strong and "infinite" For the readers who love stories that are angst or fluffy.

--- 10.14.12 ---

tumblr_mbag6rI3En1rbfn08o2_r3_500.gif

story link : here 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
KatyMikayla
#1
Chapter 14: Awww, sad day xD hahaha, but you told me about this, lmfao xD
shy_rabbit
#2
☁username : shy_rabbit

☁profile link :http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/274747

☁story title : Strawberry Ice-Cream

☁story link : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/316232/strawberry-ice-cream-romance-you-jongup-bap-daehyun-bapandyou

☁genre/mood : Romance School

☁short summary : You meet some more friends after the first few weeks of school, you get along with them very well. You one day get a text, a text u never expected
Maudmoonshine #3
Chapter 12: Thank you so much for that kind review!~ i appreciate it a lot and thank you so much for sharing your insights :) and i agree with that 'small things come in small packages' thing..

aand yeah. I just like to say that these kind of things actually does happen. i just sort of gory-fied it a bit for fictional purposes.. But please, don't think that I ever wish it to happen to anyone especially to our idols. I was cringing the whole time i was writing it. XD

Would it be alright if i credit you in the foreword tomorrow? I am in my phone right now... I promise to get to it as soon as i can.
:)
Maudmoonshine #4
You might be busy right now, but please I'm not in any rush, okay? Thanks in advance!~ :D

☁username : Maudmoonshine

☁profile link : http://www.asianfanfics.com/profile/view/168628

☁story title : Everyday is a Sunday Evening

☁story link : http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/270340/everyday-is-a-sunday-evening-angst-creepy-eunhyuk-henrylau-psychological-superjunior-twoshot

☁genre/mood : Angst or violence

☁short summary : Henry and Eunhyuk were traumatized by a crazy fan

Thanks again!~
jokerkkhe22
#5
Chapter 10: Thanks thanks ! Huft, I actually feel relieved, even though I get a very low score, but at least I know what's wrong with my story. Guess I will edit manyyy things. Did I use korean words ? I don't remember though. Even though I don't too agree with you in the foreword thingy. Thank you ! Let me love you ! XD Just kidding ! I will credit youuuuu !
im-so-curious
#6
Chapter 6: Hey thank you so much for reviewing :)
It was really good to get an unbiased opinion, thank you!
Also, I completely agree with you about it sounding choppy, I was actually thinking this myself and was debating whether to edit it a bit and your advice has made my decision definite :)
Just a side note:- I am very pleased with my score but shouldn't it add up to 87? Or is my maths really bad? :p haha
Thanks again, I will recommend your review shop if I see anyone wanting a good, honest opinion from someone who knows what they're talking about :)
FxGenerationLover
#7
Chapter 5: 94? woaaaahhh <3 let me love you down! <3 THANKS!
I'll put this in my story and credit you~ thank you so much!
starliet
#8
Chapter 4: Whoa.
I was not expecting a 90
A 70 maybe... but a 90?
Wow, thank you~! I will credit once I'm off of my phone c:
smolder
#9
Chapter 3: Wait... just wondering, but shouldn't the total be 96?
Sorry, I just noticed :P
smolder
#10
Chapter 3: Omo!
Wow, I actually didn't expect such a good review.
Thank you so much!

I'll keep your opinions in mind when I update my story :)