douxsoleil

Guardian of A Lantern // A Unique Review Shop

tumblr_ncde1yBe6S1qbjzsxo1_1280.jpg

 

Title : 4.5/5

Your title is super simple and straightforward which actually reflects your story,and I'm talking about the concept here.Title reflects the direction of your story but I don't expect the emotion you put in the story which is a great surprise element,in my opinion.

Graphics : 4/5

You doesn't have a proper graphic so I'll just replace it with the relevancy of your story with reality.

I think the emotions are being delivered well.I kinda get the sense of reality when I'm reading,how you being precise about how people can feel when they are in certain situation or problems. 

Description : 6/10

You doesn't have much words for your description but I have to praise you for its ambiguity that mislead me.Actually,I still don't understand the relevancy of the description with your story.

Plot : 22/25

Yep,you nailed it.I can see the development of your plot.I love how you make it the alternate POV which works well even if it can be confusing.What I don't really get was that how Luhan was saved by YoonA and did YoonA get hurt by her first love or what?I maybe get that Luhan might took an interest in YoonA,maybe more than a friend and that he tried to help her to be bright a girl but I'm still confused by the part where YoonA said that he shouldn't love her when he doesn't know her.Is that the same he that made her stop believing in love?I guess at the end YoonA finally jumps right?

Characters : 24/25

Flawless.You perfectly described your character's personality which is a bonus for you.There might be some slight confusion on how they become like that but everything else is perfect since sometimes you doesn't need to explain everything right?

Grammar : 19/20

Your grammar and vocab is nothing but nearly perfect.There is this teeny-weeny mistake where YoonA shred the paper,shreds of papers scatter in the air and yoona had brutally tore the envelope and tossed it in the air...you can change it to as YoonA had...Other than that it's okay,fine actually.

Enjoyment : 8/10

I enjoyed your story.No,I'm not kidding.Actually my jaw almost dropped when I first read your sentences.I was like,your vocab is no kidding and your grammar...phew...It's actually hard to write one shot,plus yours is simple and short,because sometimes the emotion is not there but you did it,haks.

Total : 87.5/100

Others : Overall it's an enjoyable and a superb story.Simplicity plays the biggest role but you made it work by putting in the emotions nicely and the words that perfectly described a situation.They made your story wonderful and even though I'm usually being strict about details and I gotta admit that you lack some,but still its a roundly perfect story.Good luck with your future one-shots and sorry for this delay,never thought that life was going to happen to me,^^.

 

 

Like this story? Give it an Upvote!
Thank you!

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
StoicBread #1
Hi! Do you accept affiliation requests? if so,
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1123113/ ^^
Thanks!
Im-Yeon #2
Chapter 6: Thanks for the review!!! Yeah I have problems with typos. Sometimes I proofread my chapter like 6 times and I still can find typos.

I'm glad I manage to intrigue you ^^ some people say that it's too was early to get reviews cuz I still have a long way to go. It's kinda true cuz until now, nobody can guess the actual plot I have in mind. The trailer was from a shop so there are parts that I don't intend to have. Like Taecyeon doesn't appear to save Yoona or anything like that. That's just cliché.

Thank you so much for the review and pointing out things. I'll proofread whenever I'm free and I'll definitely tell u after I credit the shop. Thanks again ^^
Uniquestel
#3
shashashy
#4
Username:
shashashy

Name of Story:
Pink Laces

Story Link:
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1119830/

Short Summary:

Everyone in Fantagio Academy knows that Cha Eun Woo and Im Chae Mi are archenemies. Hence, they are better off fighting than cats and dogs. Maybe it was because of Eun Woo's irrational thinking, or maybe it's because of Chae Mi's pride. Whatever it is, everyone knew that the moment they laid their eyes on each other, they were enemies. It was hate at first sight.



There are four events that are associated with gowns in Fantagio Academy, and those events has something to do with the four seasons, summer, spring, autumn and winter. Chae Mi wasn't into those events, but she went to the autumn ball anyways.
douxsoleil #5
Chapter 5: Hi there!! Sorry for the long response, and I'm glad that you like this story, despite the flaws and all. It's my first ever proper one shot and yeah, I gotta agree that the details are not there and there are vague reasons why they become the way they are now. I was writing what went through my mind that time, I guess that's the reason why this story is so emotional with lots of holes in it. Anyway, thanks for the helpful review and I already credited the shop!
Im-Yeon #6
Chapter 1: Heyyy i am really interested for a review. Dun worry, it's not long. only about 7 chapters. Pkz tell me if u accept my request
Im-Yeon #7
Chapter 1: Username: Im-Yeon

Story Title: Yours, Faithfully

Story Link: http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/1031022/yours-faithfully-angst-donghae-snsd-taecyeon-taecyoon-yoona-yoonhae

Short summary:
It was all just an act
It was all just a lie
It was all just a play
To make her die.

Donghae promised the woman he thought was the love of his life to crush the fragile Im Yoona to pieces. He will make her cry. He will make her suffer. He will make sure she dreads the day she was born.

A mysterious man
A beautiful wolfish grin
A dark background
A mark that will tarnish her purity

That was all she could think about him. She had fallen deep for him from their first encounter. And when this stranger she barely knew popped out a ring and ask for her hand in marriage, she immediately said yes.

She didn’t realize she was digging her own grave…
douxsoleil #8
Chapter 1: Username:douxsoleil
Name of Story:scorching-red
Story Link:
http://www.asianfanfics.com/story/view/792016/6/of-wasted-breaths-and-slipping-fingers-yoona-yoonkai-kaisoo-sestal-luyoon-seventeen-yoonstal
Short Summary: in one summer he never forgot, luhan met her, the girl of his dreams, the girl that he dreams.