Key has fallen from his almighty throne? Oh. Hell. No.

Oooooh I just read a post online that pissed me off. I mean it was from last year but still. 

Someone made a blog post talking about how Key's skills are deteriorating and how he is falling as a kpop idol and losing his standing in SHINee because of one not so great solo performance and ended the post by basically blaming it on Taemin's improvement in the group and how in a few years, the group will be "Taemin and the SHINee Scene." The saddest part was some fans that were commenting were saying things like "SHINee has three great vocals: Onew, Jonghyun, and Taemin. 3/5 is enough" and "Make that 4/5, Minho has been getting better." 

First off, I hope I never find these people. Mercy on their souls.

Second, Key is, and forever will be, an amazing idol. His voice is mothercrapping amazing and one of the most unique out there. SHINee isn't SHINee without Key, and the same goes for all of the other members. One bad solo performance doesn't mean he's suddenly a bad performer. I mean come on, how many times has Onew's voice cracked awfully during live performances, and you don't hear people saying, "SHINee would be fine without him. They have other great vocals." But no, you have to criticize Key, because he isn't a main vocalist, and he isn't a main dancer, and he isn't a main rapper, but guess what? He's still damn amazing at all three! Jonghyun's written a few songs? That's great, can we talk about the fact that Minho has written more, but you don't see people talking about that. Jonghyun and Onew are the main vocalists, but the one that had the permanent position on Immortal Song was Taemin. Everyone in the group is damn near perfect, but they don't always get recognized. But for some reason, one mistake and people have to flip their and start saying "SHINee is fine with just 3 vocals." If those people call themselves Shawols then that's a disgrace to the fanbase. 

Apparently SM was focusing too much on Taemin? Screw that. Everyone had their own schedule. Onew and Key were doing musicals, Minho and Taemin were going from variety show to variety show, and Jonghyun was writing and appearing on variety shows as well. So Taemin got most of Jonghyun's lines in Why So Serious. That was already explained to people by Taemin himself. Why are people taking it as a bad thing that Taemin's voice has improved and he's becoming a main vocalist, because lets face it, he's getting more high notes than Onew lately. He had a long note in Dream Girl, and Why So Serious, and he had the longest one in Everybody, and may I say he was amazing, but what? Because he's gotten better its suddenly his fault that Key is apparently "falling from his almightly throne"? Oh hell no. Key is just as great, just because his voice is different means nothing. It's because his voice is different that people love it. He shouldn't have to change for fans to like him if they've supposedly been loyal to him since the beginning. 

I'm going to quote something I saw on Twitter the other day. "Pull a Taemin and improve."

If you've scene that KBS Special called Hard Working Idols with Taemin, Kai, and Yunho, you know that Taemin said so himself, that he's spent hours trying to improve his voice and dancing skills. (It pisses me off that for some reason, its so difficult to find the one with only Taemin now, because when you search Taemin's cut, you just get "Kai" or "Kai and Taemin" like WTF damn exo saesang fans are pissing me off. But that's a completely different problem). He said his friends used to make fun of him, calling him tone deaf, and that he'd be famous for his dancing, but not his voice. He sure proved them wrong!! HA!

The point is that you can't blame Key's supposed "lose of talent" on Taemin. Don't throw whenever problems you have with Key on Taemin, that's a move. Key isn't my bias, but that doesn't mean I love him any less than Minho or Taemin (Yes, I have two biases. Minho because of his looks, and Taemin because of his talent. Sue me). I love all of SHINee equally, if one impresses me more than the other, that's my opinion, but that's not to say that I think one of them and needs to improve. I thought Taemin's voice was nice since their Replay era. Has it gotten better? Absolutely! But just because he's gotten better, doesn't mean anyone has a right to say it's his fault that Key or any other member may not be doing so well, or that SM favors Taemin over the others. SM doesn't force Taemin to spend extra hours practicing his vocals or dancing, Taemin chooses to do that on his own. 

Everyone has their ups and downs, and one or two downs doesn't give anyone, much less a Shawol of all people, the right to say that Key is a dead weight. Key is amazing, and honestly brightens my day. Have you seen his Instagram? He posts some of the craziest stuff, and it's some of the greatest things I've ever seen. Some of the pics he posts, most idols would be embarrassed to post, but that's the great thing about Key. He's bold and bright and he does everything he can to make his fans happy and make them smile even on their worst days. He could be dead tired but he'd still do what he can for his fans. 

Has anyone seen this before? He wrote a message to a fan that was depressed and cutting herself and encouraged her to stop, saying that he would watch over her posts to see her progress. And I'm not sure if I'm reading into it too much, but it kind of looks like he made a reference to cutting himself? Honestly, I don't know, so I'm not even going to get into that. The point is that this post encouraged that girl to try and stop cutting. She actually posted that she would try and stop for him. Maybe she did, maybe she didn't, but do you see what I mean? Key is a wonderful person, kind and caring, and he doesn't deserve the rude comments he's been getting. SHINee is nothing without Key, just as it would be nothing with Jonghyun, or Taemin, or Minho, or Onew. They are SHINee, whether some fans like it or not, and if they don't, than who cares? No one is forcing them to be a fan. Anyone who thinks the group would be great without any one of the members clearly isn't a real Shawol, and it honestly makes me feel ashamed at times to call myself a Shawol, knowing that those people are calling themselves the same thing. 

 

Moral of the post: If you have a problem with one of the members, get out. Whether it's Key, or any of the others, if you honestly in your heart and mind believe that SHINee would be fine without one of the members, than you have no right to call yourself a Shawol, and I hope you feel ashamed of yourself. Sorry to let people know that idols aren't perfect human beings. They are normal people, with incredible talent, and they make mistakes too. We try to see them as being these all-perfect beings, but they're not. They're human. Try to understand that. 

If even after this post, you still can't see how amazing Key is, than that's not my problem.

 

 

To end on a more humorous note: This has been another one of Cloudie's long rants. Stay tuned for more when I find something that pisses me off enough. 

 

 

P.S. ALL HAIL THE FOREVER ALMIGHTY KEY! 

May you forever shine brightly and never let stupid comments like those get you down! 

Comments

You must be logged in to comment
Recha_L
#1
Normally I don't read Long blog post, but yours is interesting and correct
I agree wit heverything you said, Key is called "the triple menace of SHINee" cuz he can sing, dance and .
In my opinion those fake shawol are just searching for an excuse to change fandom (it's obvious which fandom I'm talking about -__-), so don't mind them
It's just if they want to leave they don't need to bash on SHINee, seriously if they started to love an other band that's fine, we all can love more than one group, but insulting them and bashing, that's what I hate ghrrrr
Tisash
#2
Wtf? He can do all three. He can sing, he can dance, he can rap, he has the most amazing personality and a wicked sense of humour. Whoever who said that is clearly out of their wee little minds. I just hope that Key won't see such filthy comments though. He is amazing.

"Pull a Taemin and improve." AH the best! He really works hard
Kirakishou27
#3
Ohmygawd who dared to say something so awful??!! Amen to you, Cloudie, this was wonderful *gives you a big hug*
All five of them have their own unique traits, and none of them deserve to be criticized just because he is not their bias or sth >< My bias is Taemin and Minho (hah), but still I love them all very much, for different reasons of course ahahah. I won't bash one just becuz I favour one over the other sometimes; I mean can a shawol really be a shawol after doing something like this?? Shame on whoever said those awful words.
Thank you so much for writing this, it was brilliant!!!
yinyin_shawol
#4
its always OT5, they all have a reason>.< this is like rubbish>.<
yinyin_shawol
#5
just ignore them haha
prxncetaem
#6
sobs thank you for writting this ; n ; just bless your soul :ccc
Yuyenn
#7
I meant that SHINee isn't SHINee without Key! Sorry!

I don't like it when a member leaves a group.
mayamartin7b #8
SPEAK THE TRUTH!!! OMG. This is going to be kind of long, but I have been seeing this all over the place. People have said that Shawols are the most peaceful groups in Kpop. But they are vicious! They will dog any of SHINee out if it gets in the way of their bias. Like saying someone is uglier than their bias or worse at singing. I find all of SHINee equally amazing and great. You can't rank SHINee because they are THAT perfect. EVERY. SINGLE. ONE. Taemin's determination and improvement. Key's boldness and originality. Minho's awesomeness and competitiveness. Jonghyun's genius and self-confidence. And leader Onew who is so sweet and kind-hearted. Like there couldn't be a more perfect group in kpop.
SiMpLyJustine
#9
GOSH WHOEVER THE THIS WAS, I WILL SHOVE A CUCUMBER UP THEIR NOSTRIL. THEY HAVE NO RIGHT TO CALL THEMSELVES A SHAWOL.
AffxtedShawol
#10
I totally agree with you! All hail to the forever Almighty Key~~ whenever I see 'Shawols' hating on certain members and say that ot5 would be better without him I wonder how they dare call themselves Shawols. I've seen too many people hating on Minho and I don't understand. How can you hate on the kindest sweetest angel or the cutest lil froggy daisy princess Minho (or the smoking hot Minho) ok so––

I don't know if the girl stopped cutting, but she made an instavid in where she threw away her blades, one for each member and Key liked the video. It's sad to know that he used to cut ;;

i've got two biases too! taemin & minho (though it's really hard to just choose one, i mean they're all lovely with their own personal characteristics) but the one i 'stan' the most (like, on twitter) is taemin because he's my first bias and he's kinda like me~ kinda clumsy and forgetful and doesn't know what's going on 90% of the time lol. or his pokerface / emotionless expression. haha.
oooooh– and looks innocent but is in no way innocent >_> sorry for talking so much OTL